1. News

Skepticism greets new federal plan to help homeowners

Published Feb. 4, 2012

Hoopla and headlines follow the announcement of each new federal program to help distressed homeowners, as they did last week when President Obama detailed his latest initiative.

But five years into the housing bust, results have been in short supply.

In Florida, about 100,000 homeowners have gotten some sort of assistance, which seems like a lot until compared to the number who have not been helped, including:

• 371,000 in foreclosure.

• 530,000 three or more months behind on their mortgages and headed in that direction.

• 2 million more who owe more than their homes are worth.

The bottom line?

"The (programs) were of little benefit," said Jack McCabe, a Deerfield Beach housing consultant. "It's like putting a Band-Aid on skin cancer."

University of Central Florida economist Sean Snaith agreed. He said many of those who received help eventually defaulted because they couldn't afford the loans.

"The policies have been the opposite of battlefield triage," Snaith said. "The government has been helping the homeowners who could not be saved."

President Obama's latest plan addresses that complaint.

The $5 billion-plus initiative is not designed to help those in foreclosure or delinquent on their mortgages. Rather, it targets homeowners — 2 million in Florida — who are making their payments but owe more than their home is now worth.

That means they can't sell their homes and can't refinance to take advantage of historically low interest rates. Refinancing would put spendable dollars in their pockets, which might stimulate the economy.

But prospects for the plan are uncertain at best.

Snaith said this type of plan should have been proposed two years ago.

"We've missed the boat for sweeping changes," he said. "Now, Washington is in policy gridlock. I don't see much happening in an election year."

Brian Sullivan, a spokesman for the U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development, understands the skepticism in Florida of the incremental results produced by the federal programs.

"You can be quickly cynical in a place like Florida that has suffered so badly," he said. "Florida is right in the middle of this."

But he points to those who have been able to keep a roof over their heads with the help.

Nearly 90,000 Floridians are making lower monthly mortgage payments because of the Making Home Affordable Program. An additional 10,709 were on trial modifications as of November.

About $1 billion in federal mortgage aid given to Florida through the Hardest Hit Fund has helped 4,487 homeowners pay their loans for six months while they find work or higher-paying jobs. Of the nearly 36,500 applications, more than 3,800 came from Hillsborough, Hernando, Pinellas and Polk counties.

The administration also recently expanded eligibility in the Home Affordable Modification Program, known as HAMP, for borrowers with higher debt loads. The program will triple the incentives the government pays to banks that reduce loan principals.

Regulators expected the earlier version to help 4 million borrowers, but fewer than 1 million have been served. About $19 billion remains in the program.

McCabe, the housing consultant, believes the new guidelines could help many Floridians, but he cautioned that it's nowhere near enough money.

"The $19 billion is just enough to help South Florida," he said. "This is a trillion-dollar problem nationally."

Information from the Palm Beach Post was used in this report. Mark Puente can be reached at or (727) 893-8459. Follow him on Twitter at


  1. Rabbi Reb Tuviah (Paul Schreiber) is rarely seen without his guitar. He will sing at the upcoming Rosh Hashanah and Yom Kippur services at Temple Beth David in Spring Hill. Paul Schreiber
  2. Waves crash in front of an American flag that is planted on a jetty during a high surf from the Atlantic Ocean, in advance of the potential arrival of Hurricane Dorian, in Vero Beach on Sept. 2. GERALD HERBERT  |  AP
    Their efforts underscore the risks of a warming planet for the state’s future.
  3. The National Weather Service has issued a tropical storm advisory for Puerto Rico and the Virgin Islands. Tropical Storm Karen currently has maximum sustained winds of 40 miles per hour. National Weather Service
    A tropical storm warning is currently in effect for the eastern Caribbean
  4. A Thomas Cook plane on the tarmac at Gatwick Airport in Sussex, England Monday. British tour company Thomas Cook collapsed early Monday after failing to secure emergency funding, leaving tens of thousands of vacationers stranded abroad. (Steve Parsons/PA via AP) STEVE PARSONS  |  AP
    The collapse of the firm will have sweeping effects across the entire European and North African tourism industry and elsewhere.
  5. Natalie D'Alessandro and Izaac Deal break out into dance during the inaugural Pride Festival in 2018 in downtown New Port Richey. BY MICHELE MILLER  |  Michele Miller, Times Staff
    New Port Richey gathering will feature a week of lead-up events.
  6. When police officers arrived at the home, they found the man dead from an apparent gunshot wound on the back patio of the house. Port St. Lucie Police Department/Facebook
    The man called dispatchers late Saturday to say he had fatally shot his wife and her boyfriend, and that there were two children inside the home.
  7. Dear Penny: Will bad credit kill my chances of landing my dream job? FRANCESCORIDOLFI.COM  |  Getty Images/iStockphoto
    Be up front about your circumstances.
  8. Don Green of St. Petersburg demonstrates a hamstring stretch. SCOTT KEELER  |   Times
    These muscles are important. A few key exercises can help you get them - and keep them - in shape.
  9. FILE - In this Oct. 11, 2012, file photo, Hunter Biden waits for the start of the his father's, Vice President Joe Biden's, debate at Centre College in Danville, Ky. In 2014, then-Vice President Joe Biden was at the forefront of American diplomatic efforts to support Ukraine's fragile democratic government as it sought to fend off Russian aggression and root out corruption. So it raised eyebrows when Biden's son Hunter was hired by a Ukrainian gas company. President Donald Trump prodded Ukraine's president to help him investigate any corruption related to Joe Biden, now one of the top Democrats seeking to defeat Trump in 2020. PABLO MARTINEZ MONSIVAIS  |  AP
    The younger Biden’s business role raised concerns among anticorruption advocates that Burisma was seeking to gain influence with the Obama administration.