Advertisement
  1. News
  2. /
  3. St. Petersburg

MAGA hats, Facebook ads: Politics mar nonpartisan St. Pete council race

The St. Petersburg City Council races are supposed to be nonpartisan. Partisan politics are leaking into the campaign anyway.
District 3 City Council candidates Orlando Acosta, left, and Ed Montanari. [Scott Keeler, Chris Urso]
Published Oct. 21

ST. PETERSBURG — In one flier, City Council member Ed Montanari, shown in black-and-white, wears an oversized, red, Donald Trump “MAKE AMERICA GREAT AGAIN” hat off-kilter like a dunce cap, with some of the president’s more colorful tweets emblazoned in the background.

In another, a cartoon figure — presumably Montanari, as his name is plastered all over — wears a MAGA hat while struggling to lead an elephant, the official mascot of the Republican party. “The elephant in the room,” the ad says, is that “Montanari is actually a right-wing Trumper.” A third ad, with yet another picture of Montanari in a MAGA hat, describes the incumbent council member as “St. Pete’s Donald Trump.”

The Florida Democratic Party is running ads against incumbent City Council member Ed Montanari and on behalf of his challenger, Orlando Acosta. [Campaign advertisement]

On the flip side of all those ads, distributed by the Florida Democratic Party, District 3 challenger and Democrat Orlando Acosta stands draped in blue alongside the word “progressive.” Montanari, a registered Republican and the lone conservative voice on the council, said he voted for Trump in 2016, but didn’t campaign for him. He doesn’t own a MAGA hat, he said, and said the ads are “not fair.”

“It’s just disappointing that someone who has never shown up to a City Council meeting ... all he wants to do is spout negative things, a lot of which are made up about me,” Montanari said.

Acosta isn’t the only one to bring partisanship into the non-partisan City Council race.

Montanari published a Facebook ad that identified himself as a Republican. He said the language was a mistake and took it down. Acosta, who declined to answer questions by phone, wrote in an email that Montanari’s ad was “blatantly illegal," and said the Florida Democratic Party’s ads “simply fit Ed’s record and reflect Ed’s own advertising.”

With their invocations of national politics and party symbolism, the party’s mailers and door hangers and Montanari’s Facebook ad cast a partisan shadow over the District 3 race to a degree unseen in the other three city council races on the Nov. 5 city-wide ballot. It also may not all be legal.

Another Florida Democratic Party ad refers to Montanari as a "right wing Trumper." [Campaign advertisements]

Per the city’s charter, municipal elections are nonpartisan, and have been since the 1930s, according to University of South Florida St. Petersburg emeritus government professor Darryl Paulson. That’s when an anti-corruption reform movement swept cities across the country, a recoil against the influence of political machines. Reformists favored nonpartisan elections so the city would be governed on the basis of what’s best for the city, not for a particular political party, Paulson said.

RELATED: Incumbent’s record focus of St. Petersburg District 3 race

“It was also premised on the notion that most of the issues cities deal with are common sense issues, that don’t have political solutions, they have common sense solutions," the professor said.

It’s the state’s election code that actually define the rules regarding advertisements in nonpartisan elections:

“A political advertisement of a candidate running for nonpartisan office may not state the candidate’s political party affiliation,” the code says. “This section does not prohibit a political advertisement from stating the candidate’s partisan-related experience. A candidate for nonpartisan office is prohibited from campaigning based on party affiliation.”

That puts Montanari’s ad — which he said he took down after the Acosta campaign released a news release about it — in plain violation of the statute, said Tallahassee-based election lawyer Ron Meyer. Montanari said he saw a proof of the ad and requested the word “Republican” be changed to “conservative.” But the original version of the ad accidentally went live. He said he wasn’t sure how long it was up before his team removed it.

“My campaign, in my opinion, 99.9 percent is above board," he said. "Every T is crossed, every I is dotted. We made a mistake with one ad and when we found about it, we took the ad down. On the other hand, he’s running a negative campaign, trying to paint me as somebody I’m not, and it’s getting paid for by the Florida Democratic Party in a nonpartisan race.”

“It’s not the same,” he added.

RELATED: Two distinct views of St. Petersburg mark District 7 council race

If Acosta had put out the Montanari attack ads himself, they likely also would not have been kosher, said Florida Democratic Party counsel Mark Herron. But Acosta said the ads were designed, paid for and distributed by the party. He acknowledged the party let his campaign know about the ads “as a courtesy.”

Political parties and committees have far more leeway than candidates in their advertising, even in nonpartisan elections, Meyer said.

“There’s that pesky old thing called the First Amendment, which mean parties and political committees and other organizations have certain rights,” he said. “Over the years, it has been made plain that political parties may do the same things in nonpartisan races that they may do in partisan races.”

This door hanger from the Florida Democratic Party on behalf of Orlando Acosta calls Montanari as a "St. Pete's Donald Trump." [Campaign advertisements]

But do those things belong in a nonpartisan local election?

“If one candidate is clearly representing democratic values and one candidate is clearly representing conservative or right wing values, we’re going to point that out," said Alex Morash, the Florida Democratic Party’s press secretary. "Voters have a right to know that.”

Paulson disagreed, and asserted it’s incumbent upon the candidate to prevent partisanship from entering at all.

“In theory, you can say the party did it," Paulson said. "But in reality, if the party is going to cheat on your behalf, then you’ve got to respond to that cheating.”

RELATED: St. Petersburg District 5 candidates offer similar views on city

Whether it works is a different issue.

The St. Petersburg council race is reminiscent of the 2017 mayoral election, when Democrat Mayor Rick Kriseman successfully leveraged partisan politics to defeat former Mayor Rick Baker, doing everything he could to tie the Republican Baker to Trump.

Paulson called that the height of partisanship in St. Petersburg city elections. Success for Acosta based on that strategy depends on voters finding the Florida Democratic Party’s ads believable.

“Voters aren’t going to believe them if they don’t have a ring of truth or an air of credibility to them,” said Paulson, who once served on the city’s charter review commission and led a now-defunct countywide commission on fair campaign practices.

RELATED: Disagreements in District 1 St. Pete City Council race stray from the issues

Former City Council member Karl Nurse, a Democrat, said this election is the first time he’s seen a party invest so much into mailers. But, he said, it’s no more partisan than the 2017 mayoral race. Or even the 2001 race, when Nurse ran himself.

That year, the Republican machine geared up for Baker, donating heavily to his campaign. Baker, who eventually won and served two terms, held a campaign event headlined by then-Gov. Jeb Bush, recalled Nurse, who served alongside Montanari for two years and donated to Acosta’s campaign.

“So I would say that was fairly partisan,” Nurse said.

ALSO IN THIS SECTION

  1. Olivia Pruna, a student at Nina Harris Exceptional Student Education Center, practices with the school's drum line last year. The Pinellas County school district is asking parents and others for suggestions on ways to improve exceptional student education in the county. DOUGLAS CLIFFORD  |  Tampa Bay Times
    News and notes about K-12 schools and colleges in Pinellas County.
  2. A sign seen on the front door of Pom Pom’s Teahouse and Sandwicheria in March, after owner Tom Woodard stopped serving drinks with plastic straws. The St. Petersburg City Council voted 5-2 on Thursday night to ban single-use plastic straws. [CHRIS URSO  |  Times]
    The City Council tweaked its own ordinance banning single-use plastic straws, which is set to take effect on Jan. 1, 2020.
  3. Apollo Global Management has offered $130 per share for Tech Data's stock in an acquisition worth $5.4 billion. If regulators shareholders approve, the home-grown company will remain based in Pinellas County, where it employs 2,000 of its 14,000 workers. DIRK SHADD  |  Tampa Bay Times
    Private equity firms like Apollo create wealth for pension funds, financial institutions and individual investors by buying assets that typically are sold later at a profit.
  4. USF student Gabriela Young is the owner of Earth and Ivory, an online jewelry business with items made out of clay.  [Special to the Times | Sarah Foster] SARAH FOSTER  |  Special to the Times | @sarahtheartiste
    Gabriela Young went from selling bracelets to friends to making clay wares for customers with her business, Earth and Ivory.
  5. Celina Okpaleke conducts a choir singing traditional African songs during an African Mass at St. Peter Claver Catholic Church in Tampa on Nov. 10. LUIS SANTANA  |  Times
    November is Black Catholic History Month, a time to learn and share stories about the intrepid and devout.
  6. St. Petersburg's single-use plastic straw ban kicks in starting Jan. 1, 2020. BOYZELL HOSEY  |  Times
    The City Council on Thursday is set to adopt some tweaks to the ordinance, including making all straws by-request-only.
  7. St. Petersburg's new 26-acre Pier District, with components that will include a coastal thicket walking path, marketplace, playground and pavilion, is nearing completion. Shown is the tilted lawn in front of the Pier head building that is being created  with Geofoam, soil and grass. SCOTT KEELER  |  Tampa Bay Times
    St. Petersburg hopes to sell naming rights in the Pier District — available for annual payments of $50,000 to $1 million for 10-year terms — to help offset taxpayer subsidies.
  8. The Pinellas County Commission moved closer Tuesday to granting a total of $20.6 million to three museums: the Salvidor Dali Museum (top), the Tampa Bay Watch Discovery Center (bottom left), and the St. Petersburg Museum of History. Photos courtesy of Pinellas County
    The Dalí Museum, St. Petersburg Museum of History and Tampa Bay Watch are on track to receive bed tax dollars for expansions.
  9. St. Petersburg police Assistant Chief Antonio Gilliam is one of three finalists for chief of the Tallahassee Police Department. Gilliam has spent his career in St. Pete but was born and raised in Tallahassee. [Courtesy of Antonio Gilliam] Courtesy of Antonio Gilliam
    Antonio Gilliam, who oversees the department’s investigative services bureau, said he couldn’t ignore an opportunity to lead his hometown police department.
  10. Northwood Plams Boulevard in Wesley Chapel has been closed for six months for sewer repair, and residents are ready for it to reopen. After a couple delays, Pasco County expects the project to be complete by the end of the week. Times File
    A Wesley Chapel reader wants to know when Northwood Palms Boulevard will reopen.
Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement