1. Transportation

As ballots start coming in, All for Transportation makes its case for sales tax hike

With the general election just 25 days away, citizen's group All for Transportation is campaigning hard to win support for a one percent sales tax hike to pay for transportation. With the backing of local business leaders, the group has raised more than $2 million for its campaign. The new tax would raise $276 million per year for road, trails, better bus service and transit. [SKIP O'ROURKE | Times]
Published Oct. 12, 2018

TAMPA — There is little disagreement that Hillsborough County's roads and bus network are not meeting the needs of the fast-growing county.

But how to fix congestion and pay for better transit remains a thorny issue even as voting by mail already is underway on a proposed one-cent-on-the-dollar sales tax hike to raise billions for transportation improvements.

All for Transportation, the group that got the plan on the ballot, on Friday took its campaign to Cafe Con Tampa, a weekly current-event discussion group.

RELATED: Here's how money from a sales tax hike would improve transportation in Hillsborough

Its leaders urged people to vote for the tax, which would raise about $276 million per year for 30 years to pay for road improvements, sidewalks, trails, better bus service and transit. Some 32,000 mail ballots already had been returned as of Friday afternoon in advance of the Nov. 6 general election.

"We have so much sprawl that has been approved out in the Brandon area; it's almost impossible not to own a car," said Rena Frazier, an attorney and one of the group's leaders. "The congestion has gotten unbearable."

But the group faced some tough questions from critics who wanted to know whether the investment would actually reduce congestion, make streets safer and help low-income communities.

The tax would raise about $8 billion during its first two decades. For a household with an income that's average for the county, around $55,000, the proposal would mean an extra $120 per year in taxes, according to a sales tax calculator developed by the Internal Revenue Service.

Basic groceries, prescription drugs and medical supplies are exempt from the sales tax. Still, critics point out that sales taxes are regressive and hit lower-income households disproportionately.

That is one of the concerns of the NAACP's Hillsborough chapter, which has yet to decide whether it will back the plan. Its board is scheduled to meet with leaders of the group on Oct. 18.

"They cannot explain what it will do for the African-American community other than add buses," said Yvette Lewis, president of the chapter.

Lewis also wants assurances that the African-American community will be represented on an independent oversight committee that will be established to ensure the money is spent as promised.

Jim Davison, a Tampa physician and critic of All for Transportation, questioned whether the investment would reduce congestion. He has devised his own transportation plan and says it would pay for the same projects through a sales tax hike of just one-quarter cent on the dollar.

Hillsborough commissioners in June forwarded Davison's plan to a citizens advisory committee to consider but have not shown any inclination to move it forward.

"You're telling people in your flyers and made a statement here that congestion is going to get better," Davison said. "That's just not true."

Doing nothing is not an option, said Christina Barker, a leader of All For Transportation. She pointed to estimates that show about 700,000 people moving to Hillsborough over the next 30 years.

"If we do not do something, this is the best that it's ever going to get," she said.

Whether the tax would pay for new roads and road widening was another concern.

The charter amendment written by All for Transportation prohibits portions of the tax earmarked for congestion relief, road and bridge repairs, sidewalks and bike trails from being used for new roads or road widening.

But of the money that is allocated for roads, close to 20 percent can be spent building new ones, the group says.

Brian Willis, an attorney and All for Transportation leader, challenged the perception that people in Hillsborough reject paying for transportation improvements while those in other communities back them. Voters in the Seattle area, for example, in 2016 approved spending $54 billion on mass transit.

But other than a failed 2010 referendum, Willis said, no transportation plan has been put to Hillsborough voters for decades.

"It's not that we fail more often than them," he said. "It's that we try less."

Contact Christopher O'Donnell at or (813) 226-3446. Follow @codonnell_Times.


  1. Yesterday• Business
    Col. Jennifer Crossman smiles as Boomer, a 5-year-old dog, sits in the passenger seat of her car during the firefighter challenge at MacDill Air Force Base in Tampa. [Times (2016)] Tampa Bay Times
    Uber customers can now be connected with willing animal chauffeurs — for a fee.
  2. OCTAVIO JONES   |   Times Pasco County's long-range transportation plan no longer includes a proposed sales tax increase.
    The federally required plan guides transportation needs and expenses through 2045.
  3. Ryan Cummings, 23, of Tampa, left, and Alex Frey, 25, also of Tampa, rent Spin electric scooters from a corral located along Zack Street Tuesday, May 28, 2019 in Tampa. Electric scooter companies Spin, Bird, Lime and Jump were being deployed within the next few weeks according to a tweet from the City of Tampa on Sunday. Campbell and Henigan spent a couple of hours Tuesday trying the electric scooters. Frey and his friend Ryan Cummings rented two scooters during their lunch break. "We are going to Armature Works, we couldn’t do that without these." said Frey. CHRIS URSO  |  Tampa Bay Times
    Plus the most bizarre incidents of electric scooter vandalism around the city.
  4. The traffic signal for eastbound traffic on Drew Street at McMullen-Booth Road in Clearwater. Image by Archive
    A reader wonders why the sign at the end of Bayside Bridge instructs trucks heading north to exit during specified hours rather than stay on the bridge.
  5. In this Feb. 23, 2015 photo, a car is hauled from a canal in West Palm Beach, Fla. The driver was taken to a local hospital where he died. Palm Beach County has over 300 miles of canals, built to move water. Since 1997, 181 people have drowned in vehicles that ended in canals. (Lannis Waters/Palm Beach Post via AP) LANNIS WATERS  |  AP
    Of the nearly 1,100 people nationwide who died from 2013 to 2017 when vehicles went into water, 1 in 6 died in Florida.
  6. Dr. Daniel P. Greenwald, a well-known Tampa plastic surgeon, died on Oct. 5 when his twin-engine plane crashed soon after taking off from Kokomo Municipal Airport in Indiana. Greenwald family | Tim Bath/The Kokomo Tribune via AP
    An employee at the Kokomo Municipal Airport said Dr. Daniel P. Greenwald told him he wanted jet fuel for the Piper Aerostar. A friend says there’s no way he would have knowingly done so.
  7. Rekira Owens, a bus driver with the Hillsborough Area Regional Transit Authority, greets officials from behind a newly installed shield as they board a bus Thursday in Tampa. The clear divider is meant to protect drivers from physical assaults after a driver was killed in Tampa this year. CAITLIN JOHNSTON  |  Tampa Bay Times
    The two transit agencies took action after a Hillsborough driver was stabbed and killed by a rider earlier this year.
  8. A car on the south side of Cleveland Street at Osceola Avenue on Tuesday in downtown Clearwater. That block of Cleveland Street, which ends at Fort Harrison Avenue, provides 16 short term metered parking spaces, at left and right.
    The change to the new system will be gradual.
  9. The Florida Department of Transportation originally closed the southbound I-275 ramp to northbound I-75 for 10 months to replace the entire bridge deck of the overpass, but it's taken more than a year to complete. A detour was created that will have drivers exit on the US-41 exit to take that road to College Avenue where drivers can get back to I-75.
    When the project originally began on July 29, 2018, the Department of Transportation projected it would take 10 months to complete. A year and change later, some readers don’t see an end date in...
  10. Delta will offer nonstop flights between Tampa and Seattle in March 2020. (Mark Lennihan/Associated Press)
    The daily flights expand Tampa International Airport’s connections to the Pacific coast.