1. Weather

Hurricane Irma: Best and worst case scenarios for Tampa Bay

[National Hurricane Center]
Published Sep. 7, 2017

Every weather update brings more bad news.

It looks more and more likely that Hurricane Irma will hit Florida, but exactly where is hard to say. Some models show landfall around Tampa Bay while others call for a hit closer to Miami.

LIVE BLOG: The latest updates on Hurricane Irma

What are the best and worst scenarios for the west coast?

CLICK HERE FOR AN UPDATED VERSION OF THIS STORY: Best and Worst case scenarios for Tampa Bay with Irma nearing Florida

There is a slight chance, maybe about 10 percent, that the hurricane — already a Category 5 storm — curves east and back out to the Atlantic, said Jeff Masters, co-founder Weather Underground. That's the best option.

CATEGORY 5 HURRICANES: Eight things you need to know

There's a roughly 20 percent chance that the storm hits Cuba or Hispaniola, Masters said, weakening before it heads toward the mainland United States.

"Cuba has destroyed a number of intense, major hurricanes," Masters said, including Hurricanes Dennis in 2005 and Ike in 2008. That would also be better for Florida.

But the notorious spaghetti plots show a grimmer picture, the variegated lines essentially blocking out the entire peninsula in forecast maps.

"The spaghetti is centered right over the center of Florida and there's a lot of spaghetti to both sides," Masters said.

HURRICANE GUIDE: Emergency information, tracking map and storm resources

The cone of uncertainty (where a storm could make direct landfall) covers the entire southern third of the state.

The message, then, is familiar: Don't panic, but prepare.

In Tampa Bay, the biggest threat from a hurricane is storm surge. A potentially devastating track for Irma would take it up the state's west coast, just offshore, said 10Weather WTSP meteorologist Bobby Deskins. Some models show Irma blowing over Key West with 135 mph winds before moving north as a Category 3 or 4 storm. That would send water rushing over barrier islands and surging into Tampa Bay.

"That's kind of the worst case scenario for us is a west coast brush," Deskins said.

Irma is unique because it has been a powerful storm for a while, and it's getting bigger. On Tuesday at 2 p.m., the National Hurricane Center announced the storm was already the strongest hurricane ever recorded so far east in the Atlantic Ocean. Winds were up to 185 mph.

"The problem with hurricanes is as they get older, as they're around longer, they grow," said Colorado State University research scientist and hurricane forecaster Phil Klotzbach.

Irma has experienced several eyewall replacement cycles — a common process for major hurricanes that widens the windfield, Klotzbach said.

Satellite imagery suggests Irma has already undergone four such cycles, said Derrick Herndon, an associate researcher at the University of Wisconsin-Madison. Another storm that experienced several eyewall replacements was Hurricane Ivan in 2004, he said.

LIVE RADAR: Interactive storm track, hourly outlooks, 10-day forecasts and weather alerts

If Irma misses Cuba and Hispaniola and heads into the Straits of Florida, it would become even more massive. The storm cold undergo another eyewall replacement as it passes over that area, sucking up warm water and intensifying further, said Herndon, who works at the Cooperative Institute for Meteorological Satellite Studies.

The hurricane will likely be very different than the region's last close call, Hurricane Charley, an extremely tight but powerful cyclone that struck Punta Gorda in 2004.

"Irma could miss Tampa by 100 miles and there could still be significant impact in Tampa because the storm is very large," Herndon said.

Some models call for the hurricane to hit the southern tip of the state and spin straight north, which would bring tropical storm force winds and downpours to both the east and west coasts.

"Heavy rain is going to be an issue," Masters said. "I think regardless of what this storm does Tampa is going to get [at least] 5 to 10 inches of rain."

Based on early models, forecasters are citing Hurricane Donna, which struck Florida in 1960, as a good comparison for what Hurricane Irma could potentially do.

LOOK BACK: Hurricane Irma is being compared to Donna, which slammed Florida back in 1960

Masters, in a blog post Tuesday, wrote of how Donna churned through the Florida Keys as a Category 4 storm before hooking into the area around Naples and Fort Myers. The storm pushed into the center of the state as a Category 2 storm, continuing to wreak havoc before spitting back out into the Atlantic.

Donna showed that even cities inland should not feel safe from an approaching storm, Masters said.

"That storm was no joke," Klotzbach said.

But Floridians should also know Irma will not be a perfect duplicate of Donna, said Rick Knabb, a hurricane expert at The Weather Channel and former director of the National Hurricane Center.

"It's definitely a top-end hurricane, Category 5. It's scary," he said. But just where it hits and how strong it will be at that point remains to be seen.

"Irma will write its own story," Knabb said. "It's not going to behave like any past hurricane."

Contact Zachary T. Sampson at or (727) 893-8804. Follow @ZackSampson.


  1. Maintainers prepare KC-135s refueling planes to be evacuated from MacDill Air Force Base in August. A new study predicts MacDill and other Florida bases will experience a sharp rise in the number of days when the heat index tops 100 degrees Fahrenheit, making it unsafe to be outside for extended periods. MONICA HERNDON  |  Tampa Bay Times
    MacDill Air Force Base is predicted to see big increases in days the heat index tops 100 degrees.
  2. An arctic blast will chill the eastern U.S. this week and send temperatures in Florida well below normal on Wednesday. National Weather Service
    Tampa Bay might not freeze this week, but we’ll get the coldest temperatures of the season so far as they dip well below normal.
  3. The St. Petersburg waterfront shines in the morning sun. Cool, dry weather is forecast to continue well into the week.
    Following the hottest October in history, things might finally cool during the second week of November.
  4. Buchanan Street near A1A in Hollywood flooded in late September of this year due to king tides. [Taimy Alvarez | South Florida Sun Sentinel] TAIMY ALVAREZ  |  South Florida Sun Sentinel
    Even as saltwater swallows their streets, they find a way to carry on as though nothing is out of the ordinary.
  5. [Times files]
    The bay area has endured record-breaking heat this fall. But it’ll get cooler on Saturday and then really cool on Sunday. Enjoy it while it lasts.
  6. Abundant Halloween decorations are seen  in much of the Old Northeast neighborhood of St. Petersburg. The neighborhood has become a destination for trick-or-treaters from across the city. Photos by Edward Linsimer
    Going trick-or-treating in Tampa Bay? That costume better be breathable.
  7. A motorist drives down a flooded Meadowlawn Dr. near Kingswood Dr. in St. Petersburg after Tropical Storm Colin dumped heavy rains over the Tampa Bay area Tuesday. [JAMES BORCHUCK   |   Times]
    The partisan divide is less pronounced in a state already grappling with rising seas and stronger storms.
  8. The projected path of Tropical Storm Olga National Hurricane Center
    The storm is expected to merge with a cold front and become post-tropical before impacting Louisiana late tonight.
  9. The low-pressure system in the southwestern Gulf of Mexico has a 60-percent chance of development over the next two to five days. National Hurricane Center
    Most models don’t project the system to become anything stronger than a tropical depression. And a short-lived one, at that.
  10. Temperatures could dip below 70 Tuesday for the first time since Mid-May, setting a new record for consecutive days at 70 degrees or above.
    For one day this week weather will dip from scorching to normal.