NATO investigates claims that U.S. airstrikes killed 22 Afghan civilians

Published Feb. 11, 2017

KABUL, Afghanistan — The NATO mission in Afghanistan has opened a preliminary investigation into claims that more than 20 civilians were killed in recent U.S. airstrikes in the southern province of Helmand, military officials said Saturday.

Elders from the Sangin district, the scene of heavy fighting in recent weeks, with the Taliban blowing up Afghan army posts there, have said that multiple U.S. airstrikes early Friday killed at least 22 civilians, including several women and children.

Brig. Gen. Charles H. Cleveland, a spokesman for the U.S.-led NATO mission, insisted that the military command had seen no conclusive evidence that civilians were killed in the airstrikes but said "a formal review to determine the credibility of the claims" had been opened. The investigation team involved NATO officers outside the U.S. command to ensure impartiality, he added.

"We are absolutely investigating this, and we take claims of civilian casualties seriously, although at this point we have no indication at all that civilians were killed," Cleveland said.

Relatives of the victims, however, provided a different account.

Hameed Gul, 18, who sells soft drinks in Lashkar Gah, the provincial capital, said nine of his family members in the village of Lakari in the Sangin district were killed by the airstrikes. He and one of his brothers, who was also in Lashkar Gah, are the only surviving members of their family, he said. Their father, Mullah Pacha, was killed in an explosion years ago.

"My elder brother and I traveled to the village to find out how our mother, brothers and sister have been killed," Gul said. "When we arrived, the villagers were digging them out of the debris."

Gul said fighting around his village had forced his family to move to Lashkar Gah, but his mother and siblings had returned to Sangin about three months ago because violence had intensified in the Lashkar Gah area.

He said the airstrike killed his mother, Bibi Bakhtawar, 40, six brothers ages 4 to 17, a sister, Naz Bibi, 5, and an infant niece.

Hajji Mohammad Dawod, an elder from the Sangin district who had fled to Lashkar Gah, said that another attack struck the house of Malim Faida Mohammed, killing him and 12 family members: his two wives, two of his daughters-in-law and eight of his children.

Dawod said the airstrikes destroyed houses near a mosque where Taliban fighters were staying and killed civilians. The toll, he said, was also confirmed by people who attended the burials.

"There is no doubt that the civilians have been killed, and the government should not hide it or deny," he said. "This is not fair."

A report released by the mission last week said that in 2016, airstrikes by international and Afghan air forces had caused 590 civilian casualties (250 deaths and 340 injuries), the highest toll since 2009 and nearly double that recorded in 2015.

Afghan government officials in Helmand on Saturday continued to reject claims that civilians had been killed in Sangin. But their reasoning also underscored the government's shrinking control there, as the Taliban have essentially seized all the territory right up to the gates of the government compound in Sangin.

Keep up with Tampa Bay’s top headlines

Keep up with Tampa Bay’s top headlines

Subscribe to our free DayStarter newsletter

We’ll deliver the latest news and information you need to know every morning.

You’re all signed up!

Want more of our free, weekly newsletters in your inbox? Let’s get started.

Explore all your options

"The area which is targeted is free from civilians — there's no resident within 3 kilometers of the district center, and the airstrikes were conducted 700 meters from the district compound, where no civilians are able to live in that close range of the battleground," Hayatullah Hayat, the provincial governor, said in a news conference in Lashkar Gah. He said about 60 Taliban fighters were killed in the airstrikes.

In a sign of how bad the fighting in Sangin is, the United States alone has carried out about 30 "air-to-ground" attacks in the district over the past week — a term that includes airstrikes as well as ordinance fired from helicopters, Cleveland said.

The Afghan air force has also been engaged in recent battles, but officials would not comment on the exact number of strikes its aircraft had carried out in Sangin. In all of Helmand, the Afghan air force conducted 114 airstrikes in the past three months, said Gen. Dawlat Waziri, a spokesman for the Afghan Defense Ministry.


Helmand is Afghanistan's largest province in terms of territory and leads in poppy cultivation. As the Taliban has wrested much of it from the government's control, the U.S.-led NATO mission, which has been drawn down to a small advisory and counterterrorism mission, has been forced to step up its involvement. There are about 13,300 international troops in Afghanistan, 8,400 of whom are American.

The United States has announced that 300 Marines would be returning to Helmand in the spring to advise and assist the Afghan forces trying to hold off the Taliban, who have tightened the noose around Lashkar Gah.

At the peak of the fighting in Helmand in 2011, there were roughly 20,000 Marines in the province. Their return to Helmand, after a complete withdrawal in 2014, is a telling indication of the direction of the war.

Gen. John W. Nicholson, the commander of U.S. and NATO forces in Afghanistan, last week described the war as a stalemate and said he would need a "few thousand" more troops to help the Afghan forces break the deadlock.

Also Saturday, a suicide bombing in Lashkar Gah struck a group of soldiers who were lining up outside a bank to receive their pay, killing at least eight people and wounding 25 others, said Abdul Karim Attal, the leader of the Helmand provincial council.