1. Opinion

Parents and students deserve answers on the state’s massive ‘safety portal’ database | Column

When developed in the absence of technical expertise about ethical and fair systems, tools such as the Florida Schools Safety Portal can harm students and their families.
Photo provided by Ora Tanner [Courtesy of Ora Tanner]
Published Aug. 15
Updated Aug. 20

Editor’s note: After the author wrote this column, she attended the Marjory Stoneman Douglas High School Public Safety Commission Meeting and was heartened that members appeared receptive to her technological considerations shared during a public comment period.

Hoping to prevent another mass school shooting, Florida is assembling a huge central database called the Florida Schools Safety Portal. It will use a shockingly large amount of data from state agencies, school records, mental health data and social media monitoring to flag warning signs of a student who might be the next school shooter. Even setting aside questions of privacy, security and civil rights, how do you actually build such a data-driven system?

I’ve researched the Florida initiative in my work as a fellow with the Aspen Tech Policy Hub, and I am troubled by the lack of transparency about how the safety portal actually functions. I have worked with extremely large student datasets, and I know how much time and expertise it takes to create a centralized database of student information. I am also aware of the biases and issues of equity and fairness inherent in technology design. The Statewide Threat Assessment Database Workgroup was established to make recommendations for technical aspects of the safety portal. The group consists of people from several state agencies, including the Department of Law Enforcement, Department of Children and Families, Department of Juvenile Justice and the Agency for Health Care Administration. But it’s not clear if technical experts were included.

Preventing school shootings through data is a herculean task fraught with ethical and technical considerations. When developed in the absence of technical expertise about ethical and fair systems, tools such as the Florida Schools Safety Portal can harm students and their families. Say, for example, a student who happened to be in foster care was incorrectly flagged as a threat in the centralized database. If a developer does not identify and fix this algorithmic error, over time, the system will incorrectly correlate every student who has been in foster care as likely to incite school violence. Bringing technical experts into conversations about the design, development and deployment of school safety systems can fix these problems on the front end. Some of the basic questions we should be asking include:

Is it even possible to use data to predict school shootings? It is almost impossible to create such a system. There just isn’t enough information about the small number of students who actually commit mass acts of violence, compared to data about students who make up the entire school population. There are too few data points to accurately model school shootings because they are statistically rare events. Any conclusions drawn from an analysis of the data will be unreliable at best.

What is the quality of the data being used in the system? Before bringing large amounts of data from separate sources into a single database, developers need to “clean” the data. That involves identifying, removing and correcting inaccurate information in each student record. Otherwise, the system will be rife with errors and inconsistencies, and team members who use the data will make poor decisions based on distorted insights. Once cleaned, data from each record must then be cross-referenced with all other records for each student, a process called data integration. In addition, data errors will slow down the time it takes to access the data. It would most likely take a team of 10 people working full time at least one year to clean all the data proposed for use in the safety portal.

What are the potential biases? The data sets included in the database are problematic from the outset due to their high correlation with race, gender and socioeconomic status. For instance, 47 percent of intakes in the Florida Department of Juvenile Justice for fiscal year 2017–2018 were black youth, while 60 percent of children placed in out-of-home care through the Florida Department of Children and Families are white. Other potential entry points for bias lie in the creation of algorithms used to analyze the data (algorithmic bias) and in the people who will view student data, such as threat assessment team members (observation bias). Schools must ensure that teams are trained and pre-screened for biases. Procedures should be established to prevent conscious and unconscious prejudices against student groups that are disproportionately impacted by digital surveillance technologies and increased policing.

Policymakers should be transparent about the details of how the Florida Schools Safety Portal operates, accountable for evidence that it actually works, and that it will be fair to all students. It is unwise to neglect the insights of technical experts, students, parents, educators, community members and other stakeholders in the development of such a data-driven school safety system.

Ora D. Tanner is assistant director of the Office of Undergraduate Research at the University of South Florida. She previously worked as a nuclear physicist, science educator and more recently as a graduate researcher on NSF-funded grant projects related to digital game-based learning and assessment. She spends her free time working with several nonprofit organizations to help equip underserved students with technology skills. She is the parent of three children who graduated from Hillsborough public schools and is currently a doctoral researcher in educational technology at USF. She spent the summer in San Francisco as a fellow at the Aspen Tech Policy Hub where she completed a technology policy project on data-driven school safety initiatives.


  1. The four girls who were killed Sept. 15, 1963 when a bomb was thrown into the Sixteenth Street Baptist Church in Birmingham, Ala., are seen, from left, Denise McNair, 11; Carole Robertson, 14; Addie Mae Collins, 14; and Cynthia Dianne Wesley, 14. Associated Press
    Fifty-six years ago, a bomb blew apart the Sixteenth Street Baptist Church, killing four girls and injuring dozens more.
  2. In their political afterlife, former politicians and their staffers are hoarding unspent campaign donations for years and using them to finance their lifestyles, advance new careers and pay family members, an investigation by the Tampa Bay Times, 10News WTSP and TEGNA-owned TV stations found. CHRISTOPHER O'DONNELL  |  Steve Madden
    Reps. Gus Bilirakis and Kathy Castor are still pushing the House to take up the reform legislation. It’s past time.
  3. 1 hour ago• Letters to the Editor
    High tide from offshore hurricane Michael creeps up into the Sponge Docks in Tarpon Springs Wednesday afternoon after the Anclote River backs up. Jim Damaske
    Here’s what readers had to say in Monday’s paper.
  4. Activist Greta Thunberg, foreground, participates in a climate protest, in central Stockholm Sweden. PONTUS LUNDAHL  |  AP
    Here’s some interesting commentary from the opposite poles of the political spectrum.
  5. Connie Schultz File photo
    It started out with a question over a wonderful birthday dinner.
  6. Yesterday• Letters to the Editor
    With his machine gun, a paratrooper of the U.S. 82nd Airborne Brigade advances near Hue at the height of the Vietnam War.
    Here’s what readers had to say in Sunday’s paper.
  7. editorial cartoon from times wires Bill Day -- Florida
  8. Target and some other big retailers plan to hire more seasonal workers than last year.
    Tampa Bay businesses could struggle to find enough qualified workers during the busy holiday shopping season.
  9. Signs posted at St. Petersburg's North Shore Park in September 2016 warned people to stay out of the water due to contamination from sewage released by the city's sewer system after it was overwhelmed by Hurricane Hermine. Times staff
    Raise environmental fines for local governments and companies, but also help communities rebuild their infrastructure.
  10. An architect's rendering shows part of a planned research center and hospital on N McKinley Drive in Tampa for Moffitt Cancer Center. During the 2020 legislative session in Tallahassee, the center will seek an increased share of Florida's cigarette tax to finance the McKinley Drive project and other improvements. Moffitt officials said Thursday that the increase would finance $205 million, to be paired with $332 million they have already allocated for the project. Moffitt Cancer Center
    The cancer center is a global leader and a regional economic driver. It needs more space to accommodate more patients, researchers and technology.