1. Opinion

There is no ‘value-added’ in forcing good teachers out of struggling Florida schools | Editorial

Florida should not let one flawed measure disrupt learning in schools trying to turn themselves around.
Fifth grade teacher Michelle Brandon is one of four Hudson Elementary School teachers to be removed after two weeks of classes because of her state VAM score. Here she reviews classroom rules with students on the first day of school 2019. [JEFFREY SOLOCHEK  |  Times]
Fifth grade teacher Michelle Brandon is one of four Hudson Elementary School teachers to be removed after two weeks of classes because of her state VAM score. Here she reviews classroom rules with students on the first day of school 2019. [JEFFREY SOLOCHEK | Times]
Published Sep. 24, 2019

It doesn’t matter if the teacher is effective. It doesn’t matter if the teacher has received good evaluations from the principal. Under counterproductive state law, teachers at struggling schools can face mandatory reassignment if their so-called “value-added model” score is too low. That arbitrary rule has forced good teachers out of classrooms where they are most needed, and the state should change this dysfunctional practice before it causes even more harm to vulnerable students.

The “value-added model” -- VAM -- attempts to measure how much a teacher contributes to a student’s gains in math and reading by comparing what a student is projected to learn over a school year with what the student actually does learn, based on standardized tests. A teacher is credited for a student who does better than expected, and held accountable for one who does worse. In theory, this is not a bad idea. In practice, it’s messy, inconclusive and controversial. It would take an incredibly sophisticated VAM mechanism to distill a year’s learning to one meaningful score. Many experts don’t see it as a valid measure at all, and even accountability-obsessed Florida school officials no longer require it in teacher evaluations. But state law still requires its use in “turnaround” schools, so designated because of their D and F grades. The goal is to remove ineffective teachers from classrooms where students struggle the most. But the result can be counter-productive.

One of the teachers interviewed by the Tampa Bay Times’ Jeffrey Solochek was Michelle Brandon, a Pasco teacher at Hudson Elementary, who was reassigned despite being evaluated as “highly effective” by her principal. One of her students scored above grade level on state exams, but his achievement was still a strike against her rating because he didn’t meet the even higher VAM projection. Others made double-digit gains, but because they didn’t progress past the lowest level on their exams, still counted against her. The result? She left that classroom just as the school year was under way and routines were established. This is not the way to save struggling schools.

Polk County had to reassign 18 teachers because of their VAM scores, just as the new school year started. “One of our schools was left without a regular fifth-grade teacher,” a Polk School Board member told Solochek.

Worse, teachers who don’t even teach math or reading receive VAM scores based on the school’s average, not what they’ve done in the classroom. They are judged on variables they can’t even influence.

The answer is not that complex. Put in place a good principal -- a good leader -- and let her run the school and build support. If she rates a teacher “highly effective,” the state should trust her judgment and not micromanage by wielding a flawed VAM score as a cudgel. It’s one thing to measure performance in the classroom. It’s another to use a faulty measurement that unfairly punishes some good teachers and deprives students who need them.

Editorials are the institutional voice of the Tampa Bay Times. The members of the Editorial Board are Times Chairman and CEO Paul Tash, Editor of Editorials Tim Nickens, and editorial writers Elizabeth Djinis, John Hill and Jim Verhulst. Follow @TBTimes_Opinion on Twitter for more opinion news.


  1.  [Chip Bok --]
  2. Teachers and supporters march during the Florida Education Association's "Take on Tallahassee" rally at the Old Capitol in Tallahassee. [PHIL SEARS  |  AP]
    Here’s what readers are saying in Saturday’s letters to the editor.
  3. Florida's unemployment rate hit a record low in December. (AP Photo/Lynne Sladky, File) [LYNNE SLADKY  |  AP]
    Nearly every major job sector posted gains from a year earlier.
  4. The entrance to Moffit Cancer Center in Tampa. [Courtesy of Moffitt Cancer Center]
    The secret jobs and payments provided by China to researchers at the University of Florida and Moffitt Cancer Center are greater than initially reported. A House committee should keep investigating.
  5. The Florida Aquarium celebrates its 25th year. And it has much to show for it.
    A magnet in Tampa Bay for tourism, conservation and regional growth.
  6. Mac Stipanovich
    Whether it’s regulating the collection of voter signatures on the front end or passing new laws on the back end, they seek to silence the voices of the governed.
  7. St. Petersburg Police Chief Anthony Holloway and U.S. Attorney, Middle District of Florida, Maria Chapa Lopez, announced the Department of Justice awarded a $741,556 grant to the St. Petersburg Police Department for three years to create a regional Tampa Bay Human Trafficking Task Force at the department. [SCOTT KEELER  |  TAMPA BAY TIMES]
    The Tampa Bay Human Trafficking Force is a unique opportunity to bridge the gap of local law enforcement and reduce human trafficking.
  8. A rule proposed by the U.S. Department of Transportation this week would allow airlines to crack down on personal pets that are carried aboard as so-called service animals. [MARK SCHIEFELBEIN  |  AP]
    Trained dogs are fine. Pigs and turkeys—uh, no.
  9.  [Andy Marlette -- Pensacola News Journal]
  10. Farmers in Florida have the potential to make real impact in the climate crisis, according to these columnists.
    We need science to show how farms can capture more carbon, how forests and pastures can clean more air.