1. Opinion

The Florida Supreme Court needs to be more diverse | Editorial

Gov. Ron DeSantis left the court without a black justice for the first time in 36 years. Now he has a chance to correct that mistake.
Florida Supreme Court Justice Charles Canady, new justice Carlos Muñiz and Gov. Ron DeSantis. [Gov. Ron DeSantis' Press Office]
Published Oct. 7

Gov. Ron DeSantis has a second chance to do the right thing and ensure the Florida Supreme Court looks more like Florida. The governor left the court without a black justice for the first time in 36 years when he appointed three new justices in January. Now two of those three new justices are leaving the court for the federal bench, and DeSantis has an opportunity to correct his serious oversight and appoint a black justice.

This is a remarkable period of turnover for the state’s highest court, which DeSantis already has transformed into a more conservative institution. Three of the seven justices -- R. Fred Lewis, Barbara Pariente and Peggy Quince, the court’s only black justice -- retired in January because they reached the mandatory retirement age of 70. After a legal battle over whether the departing governor or the incoming governor had the authority to appoint the three new justices, that duty went to DeSantis. By then, the Florida Supreme Court Judicial Nominating Commission was working to winnow a list of 59 applicants, six of whom were black, to a final selection of nominees. But curiously, none of the 11 on the final list sent to the governor were black. DeSantis should have asked the commission to go back to the drawing board, but he did not.

Before they could get their seats warm in Tallahassee, two of the new justices -- Barbara Lagoa and Robert Luck -- were nominated last month by President Donald Trump to serve on the 11th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals. Both Lagoa and Luck would have to be confirmed by the U.S. Senate before their new posts are official and before the state’s nominating commission can begin looking for their potential successors. The commission has nine members, five appointed by the governor and four recommended by the Florida Bar, with veto approval by the governor. That’s one of the issues leading to the further politicization of the court.

State legislators are trying to change that selection process back to the fairer version that served the state well for decades: Three appointments by the governor, three by the Florida Bar, and three selected by those six appointees. Don’t hold your breath; similar legislation did not receive a hearing this year. Meanwhile, the current nominating commission will again recommend a list of candidate for the court,, and the governor selects from that list. While DeSantis most certainly should have asked the commission in January to put at least one black candidate on the list of nominees, the commission should have recognized that was necessary in the first place.

To his credit, DeSantis’ record of appointing black judges to lower state courts is already better than his predecessor’s. Former Gov. Rick Scott appointed fewer blacks to lower courts during his eight years in office than DeSantis has in less than a year, the Orlando Sentinel reported last month. Four of DeSantis’ 32 lower court judicial appointments so far have been black, while only one of Scott’s 34 appellate court appointments was black, and that occurred in his final month in office. Now DeSantis has another opportunity to set things right at the Supreme Court.

A more diverse judiciary makes for a more informed and fairer court. About 17 percent of Florida’s population was black in 2018, according to the U.S. Census. Diversity by race, ethnicity and gender on the state’s highest court is imperative for all Floridians to have confidence in the system. DeSantis made a serious mistake in January by not demanding a more diverse pool of applicants for the three vacant seats on the Florida Supreme Court. Now he unexpectedly has an opportunity for a do-over. He should do the right thing and appoint at least one black justice.

Editorials are the institutional voice of the Tampa Bay Times. The members of the Editorial Board are Times Chairman and CEO Paul Tash, Editor of Editorials Tim Nickens, and editorial writers Elizabeth Djinis, John Hill and Jim Verhulst. Follow @TBTimes_Opinion on Twitter for more opinion news.


  1. President Donald Trump applauds the crowd prior to his address at a campaign rally Thursday, Oct. 10, 2019, in Minneapolis. JIM MONE  |  AP
    Here’s what readers had to say in Monday’s letters to the editor.
  2. President Donald Trump (AP Photo/Evan Vucci); Transcript of Trump conversation with Ukraine's newly elected president Volodymyr Zelenskiy (AP Photo/Wayne Partlow) Associated Press
    Here’s some interesting commentary from the opposite poles of the political spectrum.
  3.  Bill Day --
  4. Dustin Cullison 28, places Spin scooters Wednesday in a designated area for deployment on Zack Street in downtown Tampa. [OCTAVIO JONES   |   Times ]
    The City Council’s proposed ordinance sets reasonable restrictions that should improve safety.
  5. St. Petersburg High, where a video was made showing a student using a whip to strike another student in the back.
    Letting social media get ahead of the truth hurts everyone.
  6. The Florida Capitol. SCOTT KEELER   |   Times
    A federal judge says lawmakers made a mess of the constitutional amendment aimed at restoring felons’ voting rights. But he’s ready to give them one more chance to fix it.
  7. Paula Dockery of Lakeland served in the Florida Legislature for 16 years. Paula Dockery
    The group has been wildly successful in getting conservatives appointed to state and federal courts, columnist Paula Dockery writes.
  8. Times Columnist Dan Ruth. [Times file]
    The senator should not brush off the president’s invitation to China to interfere in U.S. elections, columnist Daniel Ruth writes.
  9. Aaron Corrales, 10, left, talks with his fifth-grade teacher Jessica Morgan about the book Esperanza Rising as part of the class curriculum at Forest Hill Elementary School in Tampa, Florida on Thursday, September 19, 2019. Forest Hills Elementary School is taking part in a new pilot program with materials and curriculum designed by Harvard University to help students improve their reading and writing skills.  OCTAVIO JONES  |  Times
    The school district needs to show a greater sense of urgency.
  10. An oil rig sits off Louisiana in the Gulf of Mexico.
    Here’s what readers had to say in Saturday’s letters to the editor.