1. Opinion

Column: The challenge of selling the carbon tax

Published Apr. 27, 2018

The carbon tax, a price regulation for the control of human-produced CO2 emissions, should have broad appeal, both to those skeptical of government regulation and to those skeptical of market forces. It should even appeal to those skeptical that humans contribute to climate change. But the carbon tax is based on an idea over 100 years old, so why hasn't it gained sufficient support to be implemented? Part of the answer lies in the commonly held, non-rigorous opposition to tax increases, whether of general taxes or of user fees like carbon taxes, that retards careful discussion of this promising approach to a serious public policy problem.

What Does the Interposition of a Carbon Tax Accomplish?: The atmosphere is a "common access resource." Consequently, an unregulated "free market" cannot require payment when polluters emit CO2 into the atmosphere. This absence of a price encourages excessive discharges of these heat-trapping gases. The implementation of a carbon tax will insert the missing price, reducing the incentive to emit CO2. Profit-seeking firms will direct their engineers and scientists to continually seek emission-reducing methods that are cheaper than paying the tax.

Recognition of the potential of this tax to curtail climate-altering CO2 emissions is growing, and support for it is gaining ground on both sides of the aisle. Recently, Sens. Sheldon Whitehouse, D-R.I., and Brian Schatz, D-Hawaii, proposed charging polluters $49 per ton for their carbon emissions. Ehe Climate Leadership Council (CLC), a group of top Republicans co-chaired by George Schultz and James A. Baker III and economist Gregory Mankiw, endorsed a fee of $40 per ton.

The Carbon Tax is Helpful but not Sufficient: Many "small government conservatives," who recognize the need to reduce CO2 emissions, overestimate the "free-market solution" offered by the carbon tax. It has great appeal for them because, as a complement to market forces, they mistakenly regard it as a substitute for the heavy hand of government command and control actions (quotas, bans, equipment requirements, measurement techniques, inspections, and compliance rules that restrict managerial prerogatives). However, while a carbon tax reduces the scope of the required regulatory oversight, it does not eliminate the role of regulation altogether. As it complements the market, a carbon tax also complements the regulator's role in reducing emissions. The regulatory authorities will still be required to continually monitor carbon emissions to determine how high to set the tax — the higher the tax, the lower the emissions. Moreover, the government must also monitor compliance.

Insurance for Climate Skeptics: Even climate skeptics can find the carbon tax appealing as insurance against the disaster that looms if the scientists are right. Baker, a self-described skeptic, backs the carbon tax as insurance against the immeasurably bad climate outcome if he is wrong.

Policy Stability is Essential: If polluters expect policy to flip-flop with every change of dominant political party in Washington, they will make less of an investment in expensive abatement equipment. Bipartisan acceptance of the carbon tax is a key step in assuring investors of a stable policy.

Closing the Sale: How to Spend the Carbon Tax Revenue: This measure would generate considerable revenues (e.g., the CBO estimates that the Whitehouse/Schatz proposal would generate more than $2 trillion per decade). Many opportunities present themselves. First, the money could be spent partially offsetting the increase in the national debt following the recent debt-financed tax cut. Or, the money could be spent to beef up safety net programs for the poor, shore up the national retirement and health programs, fix the nation's crumbling infrastructure, or as the CLC proposes, distribute the revenue by sending each citizen a dividend check, essentially using the revenue to sell the proposal to the voters.

William L. Holahan is emeritus professor of economics at the University of Wisconsin at Milwaukee. Charles O. Kroncke, retired dean of the College of Business at UW-M, is also retired from USF. They are co-authors of "Economics for Voters."


  1.  Bill Day --
  2. Jomari DeLeon, is pictured at at Gadsden Correctional Facility in Quincy, Florida August 7, 2019. Jomari is three years into a 15-year sentence for drug trafficking. She sold 48 tablets of prescription tablets over two days to an undercover officer. JOHN PENDYGRAFT   |  Times
    Even Oklahoma, a state not famous for progressive reform, has done more than Florida to fix sentencing inequities, Carl Hiaasen writes.
  3. In this photo from June 28, 2019, a Coalition for Life St. Louis member waves to a Planned Parenthood staff member. ROBERT COHEN  |  AP
    Florida law already requires that parents be notified prior to an abortion, writes senior policy counsel at the ACLU of Florida.
  4. Students say the Pledge of Allegiance as thousands gather at a candlelight vigil for several students killed in the Saugus High School shooting in Central Park, Sunday, Nov. 17, 2019, in Santa Clarita, Calif. CAROLYN COLE  |  AP
    We doctors treat diseases, but what of the epidemic of gun violence, writes a St. Petersburg doctor.
  5. Hillsborough Classroom Teachers Association members protest outside of the school board building in Tampa in December 2017. MONICA HERNDON  |  Tampa Bay Times
    Here’s what readers had to say in Tuesday’s letters to the editor.
  6. Muhammad Abdur-Rahim points out the location of what is believed to be a former African-American cemetery next to the parking lot of Frank Crum Staffing located at 100 S. Missouri Ave. in Clearwater.  The empty lot is part of the former Clearwater Heights neighborhood which featured Bethany CME church and Williams Elementary School.   Photo taken Wednesday, Nov. 13, 2019.  JAMES BORCHUCK  |  Times
    Tampa Bay’s lost cemeteries are part of our collective history.
  7. A business man and woman holding a sign depicting their political party preference. SHARON DOMINICK  |
    Here’s what readers had to say in Monday’s letters to the editor.
  8. Leonard Pitts undefined
    Don’t wall ourselves off from contradictory opinions, writes Leonard Pitts.
  9. President Donald Trump, right, and former New York Mayor Rudy Giuliani pose for photographs as Giuliani arrives at the Trump National Golf Club Bedminster clubhouse in Nov. 2016 in Bedminster, N.J.
    Here’s some interesting commentary from the opposite poles of the political spectrum.
  10. (left to right) Nupar Godbole, medical student at USF, and Tiffany Damm, medical student at UCF, take part in a papaya workshop at the University of South Florida Medical Students for Choice Second Annual Florida Regional Conference held in the Morsani College of Medicine on February 24, 2019 in Tampa, Florida. Some of the instruments used in abortions, like the manual vacuum aspirator, are used in an exercise with a papaya, to simulate an abortion. MONICA HERNDON  |  Times
    Here’s what readers had to say in Sunday’s letters to the editor.