Advertisement
  1. Opinion

Ban solitary confinement of children

Published Nov. 6, 2012

We don't let teens under 18 vote. We don't let them buy cigarettes or beer. Yet we have no problem treating them like adults when they are sent to jail or prison for serious crimes.

Not only are they often sent to jails and prisons for adults, they are frequently placed in solitary confinement to "protect" them from predators and violence behind bars. That so many incarcerated teens are treated this way is at once an avoidable tragedy and a gross violation of human rights and constitutional law.

In preparing a recently released report, "Growing Up Locked Down," for the American Civil Liberties Union and Human Rights Watch, I entered a world where rehabilitation or redemption was held all but out of reach. Instead, I found varying degrees of desperation or worse. A girl, one of 38 youths I spoke or corresponded with in Florida, told me how she coped: "Me? I cut myself. I started doing it because it is the only release of my pain. I'd see the blood and I'd be happy. … I did it with staples, not razors. When I see the blood … it makes me want to keep going."

Her cry for help, which is all too common, should be a call to action.

Solitary confinement is a common practice in U.S. jails and prisons, and one that has been the subject of increasing scrutiny in recent years due to its cruelty. An estimated 95,000 people under 18 were held in adult jails and prisons in the United States last year. Many are held in isolation for 22 to 24 hours a day, in some cases for weeks or months at a time. While there, they are often denied exercise, counseling, education and family visits.

In Florida, the state Department of Corrections reported holding 398 youths under 18 in adult prisons in fiscal year 2010-11, and county jails held 527 statewide this past August alone. Not only are there no restrictions against holding them in solitary confinement in jail or prison, there are no differences in the criteria for when a youth would be placed in solitary, as opposed to an adult.

"The only thing left to do is go crazy — just sit and talk to the walls," another Florida teen told me. "I catch myself (talking to the walls) every now and again. It's starting to become a habit because I nothing else to do. I can't read a book. I work out and try to make the best of it. But there is no 'best.' "

Sending young people to solitary confinement is the perverse consequence of treating them like adults. They may often think they are, but every parent knows better.

Consistent with recent advances in neuroscience showing that our brains continue to develop until we are in our mid 20s, the U.S. Supreme Court has repeatedly affirmed, in the context of crime and punishment, that young people are constitutionally different. They are still evolving and in need of age-appropriate treatment and care to grow, mature and be rehabilitated. Prolonged solitary confinement of kids, in contrast, holds back development and slams the door to opportunities for rehabilitation.

A disturbing number of the youths I met told me about attempting suicide; family members shared painful stories about those who succeeded. There is no question that detaining and managing young people can be a challenge for jail and prison officials, which is why they shouldn't be in adult facilities in the first place.

Youth are vulnerable to abuse from older inmates, and they can be defiant and break the rules. Thus officials often use solitary to protect young people from adult inmates or simply to punish them. Yet no one who deals with rebellious teens would recommend locking them in a closet. Even if some limited amount of segregation and isolation is needed, there's no justification for it to last for 22 — or even 24 — hours at a time.

There is a better way. Corrections officials — even those who use solitary confinement — told me that facilities can use positive reinforcement or proportional punishment, such as taking away privileges, rather than prolonged solitary confinement.

Solitary confinement is a bad idea for prisoners of any age. It is costly, does nothing to rehabilitate prisoners and exacerbates mental health problems. All of that is never more evident than when young people are isolated in tiny cells. They don't emerge contrite. They come out damaged. Or, in the words of another Florida teen, solitary "makes you wild; makes you feel like a lion in a cage." This practice should be banned.

Ian Kysel is the Aryeh Neier Fellow at Human Rights Watch and the ACLU and author of a new report, "Growing Up Locked Down" about the use of solitary confinement for juvenile prisoners. He wrote this exclusively for the Tampa Bay Times.

ALSO IN THIS SECTION

  1. House Judiciary Committee session during a House Judiciary Committee markup of the articles of impeachment against President Donald Trump, Wednesday, Dec. 11, 2019, on Capitol Hill in Washington. (AP Photo/Jose Luis Magana, Pool) [JOSE LUIS MAGANA  |  AP]
    There is a reason Republicans continue to embrace debunked conspiracy theories over Ukraine and the 2016 election, writes a columnist.
  2. Connor Lovejoy, 12, (center left) is pictured with his grandmother Cathy Lovejoy, 57, (center right) who legally adopted him, Coco (left) his therapy dog, Loki, who is a trained service dog (right) and a new kitten named Weasley (center). Connor is diagnosed with autism, fetal alcohol syndrome, intermittent explosive disorder, oppositional defiance disorder (ODD), and attention deficit hyperactivity disorder (ADHD). The boy has been taken for mental health evaluations in the back of a police cruiser under Florid'a Baker Act more times than his grandmother can remember. [JOHN PENDYGRAFT  |  Times]
    Too often, the decisions are being made by officers without proper training and without notifying parents first.
  3. Ukraine Nazi concentration camp survivor Petro Mischtschuk, 78 years old, kneels with a red rose in his hand in front of the camp entrance at the former Nazi concentration camp Buchenwald near Weimar, eastern Germany, in April 2005. [JENS MEYER  |  AP]
    Here’s what readers had to say in Friday’s letters to the editor.
  4. We asked readers the eternal question in polls on Facebook and Twitter. Here are the results.
  5. A simplified version of the first 10 amendments to the U.S. Constitution hangs prominently in Dawn Brown's classroom at Crews Lake Middle.  [JEFFREY S. SOLOCHEK | Times]
    Here’s what readers had to say in Thursday’s letters to the editor.
  6. Yesterday• Opinion
    Mexico's Treasury Secretary Arturo Herrera, left, Deputy Prime Minister of Canada Chrystia Freeland, second left, Mexico's President Andres Manuel Lopez Obrador, center, Mexico's top trade negotiator Jesus Seade, second right, and U.S. Trade Representative Robert Lighthizer, hold the documents after signing an update to the North American Free Trade Agreement, at the national palace in Mexico City on Tuesday. (AP Photo/Marco Ugarte) [MARCO UGARTE  |  AP]
    The new North American trade pact is good for the nation and for Florida.
  7. Dwight D. Eisenhower (center) in front of a grid the SS had fashioned from railway tracks for the purpose of burning the corpses of dead inmates from the mass graves, April 12, 1945 [MOORE, U.S. SIGNAL CORPS  |  National Archives Washington]
    Some things are not up for debate. The Holocaust happened, write two officials from the Florida Holocaust Museum.
  8. There are great programs in Hillsborough public schools to provide free or low-cost breakfast and lunch for students who qualify.
    Proposed changes by the Trump administration would make some students go hungry.
Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement