1. Opinion

Blumner: A code that must change

Published Dec. 6, 2013

There WAS an accusation, a terrible one, against Jameis Winston, the star quarterback for Florida State University, that he raped a woman off-campus a year ago. • DNA links them. She says it was rape. He says it was consensual sex, and State Attorney Willie Meggs decided Thursday not to file charges of sexual assault. • Whatever happened, Winston was treated differently from others accused of such a crime. The Tallahassee police failed to fully investigate at the time the victim complained, and the university has been unreasonably sluggish in its own review.

The woman's attorney was allegedly told by a Tallahassee detective in January that the accuser's life would be made miserable if she pursued the case. That sounds like an effort to help a football player avoid a potential felony.

My natural sympathies lie with the victim. Just as in the military, too often in college campus sexual assaults the institution adopts a close-the-ranks attitude. The subtext is, "Sorry, dear, but you were drunk or you shouldn't have gone back to his room, or get over it."

But there is a flip side, too. That is the campus justice systems that deny due process rights to the men who are accused. Campus disciplinary hearings have the trappings of due process such as notice of the charges and a right to present evidence and cross examine witnesses. But they fall short where it really counts.

It starts with the quality of the investigation. Robert Shibley, senior vice president of the Foundation for Individual Rights in Education, says universities don't often employ experienced law enforcement to look into disciplinary complaints, leading to botched investigations. He described one case that turned on whether a person was at the scene or not and investigators had failed to take the obvious steps of checking the closed-circuit television recordings and reviewing the electronic door swipes to see who came and went.

The standard of proof used to convict also is often too low. Under FSU's campus disciplinary process, Winston could be found guilty of rape based on the "preponderance of the evidence." Think of it this way. If the "beyond a reasonable doubt" standard used in criminal proceedings requires 99 percent probability of guilt to convict, the preponderance standard requires a 51 percent likelihood.

On that weak showing, Winston could have a sexual assault on his academic record, get expelled and potentially be barred from any future job that requires a background check.

FSU is not an outlier. This is what the U.S. Education Department wants. In April 2011, the department sent a letter to colleges and universities reminding them of their obligation under Title IX to police sexual assaults and harassment on campus. The letter, a blueprint for schools, told them to use "preponderance of the evidence" to find guilt.

Couple this with a vague definition of what constitutes actionable sexual misconduct, and the process becomes even more unfairly weighted against men. FSU defines a nonconsensual sexual act as one where there is "no clear verbal consent," a definition so broad that it equates rape with ambivalence.

Also actionable are "unwelcome, inappropriate, or irrelevant sexual or gender-based behaviors, actions or comments."

That last bit covers about half of everything college students do and say.

Students accused of sexual misconduct at FSU don't get a lawyer. They can bring an advocate to the hearing, but that person can only quietly advise the student. Essentially, students are expected to represent themselves on charges that can ruin their academic careers.

To fight back, male students who say they are victims of kangaroo campus justice are suing universities around the country for wrongful expulsion. Meanwhile the Education Department is taking up the complaints of women who say their schools allow assailants to go virtually unpunished.

Universities are stuck in the middle, but on the need for more due process I side with the accused.

The state attorney has declined to file criminal charges, but Winston still could face the disciplinary process at Florida State. If he does, the case will be the focus of intense public interest even as it is shrouded in secrecy. The process will be scrutinized for its fairness toward the victim and the accused. Other less celebrated college students, when facing equally serious charges, won't enjoy those same privileges.


  1. Addison Davis, Clay County Superintendent, was chosen Tuesday as Hillsborough County's new schools superintendent [HCPS]
    Addison Davis will have an impact on the entire region.
  2. About 100 people gathered on Bayshore Boulevard in remembrance of George Gage, who was killed at Bayshore Boulevard and West Julia Street. [LUIS SANTANA  |  Times]
    Here’s what readers are saying in Wednesday’s letters to the editor
  3. The Trump National Doral clubhouse in Doral. [WILFREDO LEE  |  AP]
    National Republican leaders should make it known that they understand that Florida — with its 1,200-plus miles of valuable coastline — is ground zero for the growing and costly threat of sea-level...
  4. Justices of the Florida Supreme Court attend the opening session of the Florida Legislature in January. Left to Right: Chief Justice Charles T. Canady, Justice Ricky Polston, Justice Jorge Labarga, Justice Alan Lawson, and Justice Carlos G. Muniz.  (Two vacant justice positions need to be appointed by Gov. Ron DeSantis.) [SCOTT KEELER  |  Tampa Bay Times]
    It’s bad enough the court ignored voter intent on restoring felons’ voting rights. It also embraced the rigid approach of the late U.S. Supreme Court Justice Antonin Scalia.
  5. Health experts say that the people who benefit most from fluoridation are the poor, who often don't have access to the foods and dental health products they need to keep their teeth in good shape.
    A retired dentist reminds us of the value of having fluoridated the water systems.
  6. In this image from video, presiding officer Supreme Court Chief Justice John Roberts swears in members of the Senate for the impeachment trial against President Donald Trump at the U.S. Capitol in Washington, Thursday, Jan. 16, 2020. (Senate Television via AP) [AP]
    The Senate should consider new evidence, hear from witnesses and conduct the trial of President Donald Trump in full public view.
  7. A shopper carries groceries in a plastic bag after shopping at the Silver Street Market in downtown Albuquerque, N.M. [ROBERTO E. ROSALES  |  AP]
    Here’s what readers are saying in Tuesday’s letters to the editor.
  8. Dr. Martin Luther King Jr., head of the Southern Christian Leadership Conference, addresses marchers during his "I Have a Dream" speech at the Lincoln Memorial in Washington on Aug. 28, 1963.
    Across Tampa Bay and the nation, the holiday is a day of service.
  9. Leonard Pitts [undefined]
    Leonard Pitts explains that diversity doesn’t happen by itself.
  10. San Francisco has benefited from the growth of nearby Silicon Valley. That metro area added 30,000 jobs in the past year.
    Here’s some interesting commentary from the opposite poles of the political spectrum.