1. Opinion

Column: Why sheriffs, feds are at odds on immigration

Published Apr. 4, 2017

The Department of Homeland Security's Immigration and Customs Enforcement and the nation's sheriffs are at a standoff.

ICE insists that sheriffs detain illegal immigrants in their local jails past the time period legally allowed under their local charges, and it claims that be legally done by following their formal requests called "detainers.'' These are civil, not criminal detainers that carry no proper legal authority and expose sheriffs (and local taxpayers) to costly civil liability for illegally detaining the individual.

While the illegal immigration debate is complex and emotional, I swore to follow the law, even when it's inconvenient. The federal government also must follow the law even when it's inconvenient, and it is wrong for the federal government to ask sheriffs to ignore the U.S. Constitution and the law that we are sworn to uphold by illegally keeping people in our jails.

To be clear, only the federal government has the authority and jurisdiction to deport people and enforce our nation's immigration laws. State and local law enforcement officials, including sheriffs, have no authority to enforce immigration laws. Sheriffs should assist ICE and other federal agencies to the extent permitted by law. But we must not be asked, or in this case expected, to act outside the confines of the law and risk civil liability and financial penalties, which are ultimately paid for by the taxpayers.

Every court in this country that has considered the issue has determined that ICE's civil "detainers," or requests, directed to sheriffs do not provide a lawful basis for sheriffs to hold someone in jail once their local charges are resolved. Even when ICE issues a civil administrative arrest warrant, signed by an ICE agent but not a judge, with their detainer request, the law does not allow sheriffs to serve these arrest warrants. Those warrants may only be served by ICE agents.

The president's recent executive order required the Department of Homeland Security to publish weekly reports identifying sheriffs and jails that will not honor the ICE civil detainer requests. Homeland Security began publishing these report two weeks ago. These misleading reports are, in addition to identifying sheriffs that are following the law, wrongly identifying sheriffs who are, in fact, cooperative.

In Pinellas County, we are not on the Homeland Security list because we have developed a lawful solution with ICE that can be implemented nationwide. I will continue to abide by the law and protect taxpayers from unnecessary civil financial exposure, and I welcome the opportunity to work with ICE in implementing a nationwide lawful solution.

We chastise our children for bullying behavior, and reward cooperative solutions. We should expect nothing less of our federal government.

Bob Gualtieri is the Pinellas County sheriff.


  1. Hernando County community news Tara McCarty
    Letters to the editor from Hernando County
  2. Eugene Robinson File photo
    Racist attitudes lead to tragic outcomes. | Eugene Robinson
  3. Yesterday• Opinion
    Editorial cartoon for Tuesday CLAY BENNETT  |  Chattanooga Times Free Press
    From Times wire services
  4. City Council Member Ed Montanari with a campaign flyer attacking him from the Florida Democratic Party SCOTT KEELER; MARTHA ASENCIO-RHINE  |  Tampa Bay Times
    Here’s what readers had to say in Tuesday’s letters to the editor.
  5. University of Florida researchers hold a 15-foot Burmese python captured in Everglades National Park in 2009. The python had just eaten a 6-foot alligator.
    The Trump administration foolishly shuts down efforts to fight invasive species. Total savings: $30,000.
  6. Mac Stipanovich STEVE CONTORNO  |  Special to the Times
    He becomes the education governor with his plan to raise minimum teacher salaries even if the Legislature takes a different path, columnist Mac Stipanovich writes.
  7. Pasco County community news TMCCARTY80  |  Tara McCarty
    Letters to the editor from Pasco County
  8. [Times files]
    Here’s what readers had to say in Sunday’s letters to the editor.
  9. President Donald Trump applauds the crowd prior to his address at a campaign rally Thursday, Oct. 10, 2019, in Minneapolis. JIM MONE  |  AP
    Here’s what readers had to say in Monday’s letters to the editor.
  10. President Donald Trump (AP Photo/Evan Vucci); Transcript of Trump conversation with Ukraine's newly elected president Volodymyr Zelenskiy (AP Photo/Wayne Partlow) Associated Press
    Here’s some interesting commentary from the opposite poles of the political spectrum.