Advertisement
  1. Opinion

Dockery: Stop relying on private prisons

The U.S. Justice Department has announced it is ending its use of private prisons. Its inspector general released a report that found private-run prisons do not provide the same level of service, save on costs and/or maintain the same level of safety and security.

The scathing report, combined with the decline in the federal prison population, led to the decision to phase out using private companies to manage 13 facilities housing 22,100 prisoners — roughly 12 percent of the Bureau of Prisons' total inmate population.

It won't happen overnight. To achieve the goal of reducing and ultimately ending the use of privately operated prisons, officials are directed not to renew contracts when they expire or substantially reduce the scope of the contract.

While it's a significant move by the Justice Department, it only directly affects a small portion of total inmates. The vast majority of those incarcerated in the United States are housed in state prisons. Additionally, the action does not apply to Immigration and Customs Enforcement and U.S. Marshals Service detainees.

Advocates are hoping Justice's decision will spill over to other federal agencies and to the states, where 91,000 inmates are in privately run prisons.

What gave rise to private prisons?

In 1980, there were 300,000 state and federal prisoners. Through a series of tough-on-crime measures — including mandatory minimum sentences, limiting discretion for judges and establishing new crimes — lawmakers created more offenders and kept them incarcerated longer. By 2013, the inmate population had exploded to 1.5 million.

Private prisons became an answer to swelling prison populations. They promised cost savings, but those savings didn't materialize. For-profit private prisons were the beneficiaries of the criminalization of minor infractions and increased penalties.

National outrage has grown against overincarceration. While the United States represents about 5 percent of the world's population, we have 25 percent of all those incarcerated.

A diverse group of criminal justice reform advocates including religious leaders, tax reformers and billionaire businessmen — like the Koch brothers — are working with the Obama administration in a bipartisan effort to correct the overcriminalization that distorted our once fair system of justice.

Some states started addressing the problem by changing their sentencing laws, giving discretion back to judges and reducing the use of mandatory minimums. They're also focusing resources on treatment for addiction, programs to reduce recidivism and job training and work release.

The inmate population in some states has dropped, reducing the need for private prisons. Colorado closed four of its seven private prisons. Mississippi, facing budget shortfalls, shut down one.

California is in a different position. It's under a federal court order to reduce its prison population. Because of overcrowding, it houses some 5,000 inmates in out-of-state private prisons.

Kentucky ended its three private prison contracts by 2013, but now, due to a rise in its prison population, is considering reopening two.

What's happening in Florida?

Florida's inmate population was on a growth spurt and then remained steady for a few years before starting to decline. In 2014, the Department of Corrections incarcerated 100,873 offenders in 56 state prisons. The prison population dropped to 98,892 in May 2016.

Ten percent of Florida's inmates are housed in seven private prisons at a cost of $142 million. The state has closed nine prisons but continues to send inmates to the seven private prisons.

The corporations seeking private prison contracts are politically powerful and well connected. They spend millions of dollars in Florida on lobbying teams and campaign contributions.

The Florida Legislature tried to turn 25 percent of state prisons over to private companies to operate by targeting all prisons south of Orlando. They failed in 2011 when a circuit court judge ruled their actions unconstitutional, and again in 2012 when a bipartisan group of senators voted to kill the prison privatization bill on a 19-21 vote.

It's fundamentally wrong to privatize this function of government. A handful of private companies have gained disproportionate power and influence in shaping criminal justice policy, often at odds with what's in the public interest. The state benefits when recidivism is low; the opposite is true for for-profit prisons. Their financial success is dependent on individuals being incarcerated and detained.

That comes at a cost to taxpayers and to society.

Florida should follow the Justice Department's lead and stop using corporations to manage its decreasing prison population.

Paula Dockery is a syndicated columnist who served in the Florida Legislature for 16 years as a Republican from Lakeland. She can be reached at PBDockery@gmail.com.

YOU MIGHT ALSO LIKE

Advertisement
Advertisement