1. Opinion

Editorial: Sacrificing two kayaks and a Toyota for free speech

Courtesy of Maggy Hurchalla Maggy Hurchalla, right, a former Martin County commissioner, spoke out against the county\u2019s deal with Lake Point Restoration, a mining company owned by billionaire George Lindemann Jr., left, and wound up being sued by the company, which claimed she had interfered with a legal contract. The jury agreed.
Published Jul. 18, 2018

Maggy Hurchalla joked this spring that all she could offer a billionaire who won a $4.4 million judgment against her after she exercised her free speech rights were "two kayaks and an aging Toyota.'' The billionaire didn't laugh. This week, Martin County sheriff's deputies armed with a court order seized the 14-year-old car and the kayaks — the only property owned by the 77-year-old sister of late Attorney General Janet Reno. This bullying should send a chill through every Floridian who cherishes their constitutional rights to free speech and to petition their government, and the Florida Supreme Court ultimately will have to correct this miscarriage of justice.

The David vs. Goliath drama played out on Florida's east coast with themes that include the environment and the water supply, open government and a citizen's right to protest to their elected officials. As the Tampa Bay Times' Craig Pittman reported in May, billionaire George Lindemann Jr. put together a group to buy 2,200 acres of sugar cane fields near Lake Okeechobee in Martin County that is known as Lake Point. The idea was to dig up rocks to sell for construction projects and use the mining pits to store and clean water from the lake. By 2009, the South Florida Water Management District and the Martin County Commission signed off on the deal.

ONLY IN FLORIDA: Battle over water, free speech pits billionaire vs. activist

Then it got more complicated. Lake Point came up with a new idea in 2011 to sell the water in the pits. Lindemann told Pittman that Lake Point actually would have been paid for storing and cleaning the water, because nobody can sell water without state permission. But the idea didn't sit well with the water management district or Martin County, and Hurchalla protested after the concept became public in 2012.

Hurchalla sent emails to Martin County commissioners urging them to get out of their agreement with Lake Point, and the deal fell apart. Lake Point sued the water management district, Martin County and Hurchalla. It turned out that Hurchalla sent some emails to the county commissioners' personal accounts and the county failed to turn them over. Two commissioners have been charged with violating public records laws, and the water management district and Martin County settled for millions with Lake Point in 2017. Hurchalla refused to apologize and went to trial, where Lake Point lawyers suggested there was something "sinister'' about her deleting her emails to county commissioners — which as a private citizen she had no obligation to keep. Yet a circuit court jury in Martin County ruled against her in February and awarded Lake Point absurd damages of $4.4 million.

Talbot "Sandy'' D'Alemberte, the former American Bar Association president working pro bono on Hurchalla's appeal, accurately calls this a classic SLAPP lawsuit — a strategic lawsuit against public participation aimed at intimidating and silencing critics. "She did nothing but send emails to county commissioners,'' he told the Times editorial board Tuesday. "What they're really coming after is your rights to petition the government and free speech.'' The First Amendment Foundation (disclosure: Times Editor of Editorials Tim Nickens serves on the foundation's board), the Florida League of Women Voters and the Florida Press Association are among the organizations planning to file a brief in support of Hurchalla's appeal.

That appeal to the Fourth District Court of Appeal based in West Palm Beach isn't likely to be heard until early next year, and then the case is likely to move to the Florida Supreme Court. Hurchalla could have posted a bond to protect her car and kayaks, but D'Alemberte said the cost would have been prohibitive. So deputies towed away the Toyota Monday, and they picked up the old kayaks, including one Hurchalla and her sister used on the Potomac River as Secret Service agents protecting the attorney general trailed behind.

"There is something very childish about thinking that if they take away my car and my toys I will burst into tears and stop defending the First Amendment,'' Hurchalla wrote in an email to several reporters. "The car and the kayaks can be replaced. The First Amendment cannot.''

Agreed. Florida needs more engaged citizens like Maggy Hurchalla who aren't afraid to tell government officials what they think — not fewer.


  1. Eugene Robinson
    Impeachment is no longer optional. | Eugene Robinson
  2.  LISA BENSON  |  Lisa Benson -- Washington Post Writers Group
  3. Times files Tampa Bay Times
    Organizations that do not represent the entire region should not be using the region’s name, Pinellas County Commissioner Janet Long says.
  4. A Brown Pelican tries to raise its wings as it sits on the beach at East Grand Terre Island along the Louisiana coast after being drenched in oil from the BP Deepwater Horizon oil spill in June 2010.
    Here’s what readers had to say in Friday’s letters to the editor.
  5. An egret wades in the Indian River Lagoon earlier this year as clumps of algae float near mangroves in the background.
    The law was designed to protect all of our waters from pollution, degradation and destruction.
  6. University of South Florida St. Petersburg's campus URSO, CHRIS  |  Tampa Bay Times
    A revised plan better benefits students on all three campuses and more fairly treats the St. Petersburg campus.
  7. Editorial cartoons for Thursday TIM CAMPBELL  |  Washington Post Syndicate
  8. More emphasis on rehabilitation and a review of court fines and fees would be a start, a columnist writes.
  9. A graffiti of modern Turkey's founder Mustafa Kemal Ataturk is seen on the Turkish side of the border between Turkey and Syria, in Akcakale, Sanliurfa province, southeastern Turkey, Tuesday, Oct. 8, 2019. LEFTERIS PITARAKIS  |  AP
    Here’s what readers had to say in Thursday’s letters to the editor.
  10. Donald Baylis, left, kisses Rosalyn Dobson's hand before getting on buses at an assisted living facility in South Florida to evacuate in advance of the arrival of Hurricane Irma in Sept., 2017. [Photo by Andrew Innerarity for the Washington Post]
    A state lawmaker’s bill would scrap the requirement that assisted living facilities report to the state when a resident is hurt or dies within one business day.