Friday, November 16, 2018
Editorials

Editorial: Preserve diversity on the Florida Supreme Court

Interviews conclude Friday for the 59 candidates who want a seat on the Florida Supreme Court, which will decide issues critical to all Floridians for decades. With the court’s two female justices and one African-American justice set to retire, the panel screening the candidates should commit to maintaining diversity on the state’s highest court. Florida is becoming a younger, more colorful place all the time, and the state Supreme Court should reflect that diversity.

The interviews were scheduled over four days, wrapping up today in Tampa. The applicants include a handful of well-qualified Tampa Bay area judges and attorneys vying for one of the three spots. The Florida Supreme Court Judicial Nominating Commission, a nine-member panel appointed either directly or indirectly by Gov. Rick Scott, will soon send between nine and 18 names to the new governor, who must choose from among those finalists.

The commission members should commit to ensuring that the court reflects Florida’s population. Justices Peggy Quince, Barbara Pariente and R. Fred Lewis have reached the mandatory retirement age and will leave in January. Their departures mean that the court is losing both its female justices and its only African-American justice. Among the 59 applicants are at least six African-Americans, 10 women and four Hispanics. Choosing the most qualified justices should be a careful, apolitical process and should include examining the candidates’ backgrounds and life experiences and how their gender and race shaped them. It’s not about meeting any quota but about assembling a group of justices who bring varying perspectives to the cases they will hear.

The three retirements created a contentious dispute over who should get to appoint their replacements. Scott insisted the task should fall to him, which conflicts with precedent and the will of the voters. Thankfully, the Florida Supreme Court itself ruled on the issue, deciding that the authority lies with the next governor. That did not stop the Judicial Nominating Commission — all appointees of Scott — from going ahead with applicant interviews. That process should have been delayed until after Tuesday’s election, and allowing the process to start fresh for Gov.-elect Ron DeSantis. That might have inspired others to apply, and nothing would have stopped those who already applied from re-submitting their names. Scott’s influence looms large over the process regardless. He has put his political loyalists on the JNC, which was never supposed to be an apparatus for a governor wielding his ideology over the courts. Yet that is what has happened — and why these three appointments deserve so much scrutiny.

The three upcoming vacancies on the Florida Supreme Court will be filled by judges who could sit on the court for a generation, deciding cases with far-reaching impact on issues including privacy, criminal justice, education equity and women’s health. To be frank, they should not be decided by seven white men but by a panel of justices who represent and reflect all Floridians.

Comments
Column: Following through on Hillsborough education referendum

Column: Following through on Hillsborough education referendum

Your vote sends a message to our leaders that we value education.
Updated: 1 hour ago
Editorial: No substitute for state support of schools

Editorial: No substitute for state support of schools

Local referendums cannot make up for Tallahassee’s cuts.
Updated: 1 hour ago
Editorial: Riverwalk a defining civic space in Tampa

Editorial: Riverwalk a defining civic space in Tampa

Tampa's Riverwalk continues to grow into its own.This month, the American Planning Association named the linear park along the Hillsborough River through downtown Tampa as the winner of its "People's Choice" award. Part of the association's...
Updated: 2 hours ago
Editorial: Fee on single-use bags reasonable

Editorial: Fee on single-use bags reasonable

St. Petersburg’s proposed 5-cent fee on shopping bags could encourage better consumer habits.
Updated: 2 hours ago
Editorial: The enormous public cost of domestic violence

Editorial: The enormous public cost of domestic violence

Domestic violence carries a huge price tag in addition to the human toll.
Published: 11/15/18
Editorial: Warren takes positive step to advance justice in Hillsborough

Editorial: Warren takes positive step to advance justice in Hillsborough

The Conviction Review Unit follows through on a campaign pledge to review past conviction cases.
Published: 11/14/18
Editorial: Tone down the rhetoric, focus on counting votes

Editorial: Tone down the rhetoric, focus on counting votes

President Donald Trump, Sen. Marco Rubio and Gov. Rick Scott should stop making unfounded claims of voter fraud.
Published: 11/13/18
Editorial: Get Hillsborough transit priorities in shape

Editorial: Get Hillsborough transit priorities in shape

Hillsborough County scored a historic win this month when voters approved a one-cent sales tax to pay for transportation improvements. The $9 billion or more it will generate over the next 30 years should transform mobility across the region and impr...
Published: 11/12/18
Editorial: Deadly danger of wrong-way driving

Editorial: Deadly danger of wrong-way driving

The state is taking action to minimize wrong-way crashes
Published: 11/11/18
Updated: 11/12/18
Editorial: Makeover on the Pinellas School Board

Editorial: Makeover on the Pinellas School Board

Three veterans depart, clearing the way for new faces
Published: 11/09/18
Updated: 11/12/18