1. Opinion

In court threat, GOP hides behind silence

Published Sep. 29, 2012

It's a sad state of affairs when the disgraced former chairman of the Republican Party of Florida has more appreciation for an independent judiciary than the speaker of the Florida House. It's even worse that so many prominent Republicans are biting their tongues as their political party and its allies wage an unprecedented partisan assault on three Florida Supreme Court justices who are up for merit retention on the November ballot. This is no time for Floridians who respect the law and the courts to remain silent against a very real threat that seeks to corrupt the process for political gain.

Former state Republican Party chairman Jim Greer is awaiting trial on charges of stealing about $200,000 from the party through a secret fundraising company. But even Greer had the good sense to say last week that as the party chairman he would not have allowed the party to oppose the merit retention of Justices R. Fred Lewis, Barbara J. Pariente and Peggy A. Quince. At least he recognizes a partisan political power play and acknowledges the danger of allowing Gov. Rick Scott to pack the Supreme Court with three new justices if voters remove the well-qualified incumbents.

Contrast that clear thinking with the bellicose attacks on the court by departing House Speaker Dean Cannon, a Winter Park Republican and a lawyer with no respect for the state Supreme Court, the Florida Bar or the judicial branch in general. Cannon contends it is "ludicrous" to be critical of the Republican Party for wading into the nonpartisan merit retention process. He misrepresents the purpose of merit retention and lashes out at the Florida Bar for trying to educate voters about the process. In fact, the merit retention process was approved by voters in 1976 to protect the court from corruption and political interference by ideologues such as Cannon.

It was the House speaker who was most upset that the court correctly removed three of the Legislature's proposed constitutional amendments from the 2010 ballot because they were so misleading. It was the House speaker, one of the most powerful men in state government, who wanted to add more justices to the seven-member court and then divide it into two courts. And when that plot failed, it was the House speaker who pushed to place on the November ballot Amendment 5, a dangerous attempt to give the Legislature more authority over the courts by requiring Senate confirmation of justices and granting state lawmakers a greater say over court rulemaking. No wonder Cannon, whose speakership was among the most ideologically driven in memory, sees nothing wrong with political parties calling for the ouster of justices who have ruled against them.

There are fair-minded Republicans who respect the courts and recognize the threat posed by politicizing the merit retention process. They include former Supreme Court Justice Raoul Cantero and former state Sen. Alex Villalobos of Miami, who support the retention of the justices; and retired Pinellas-Pasco Circuit Judge Irene Sullivan, who wrote a letter to the Times. But their voices should be joined by other leading Republicans. Incoming Senate President Don Gaetz of Niceville and incoming House Speaker Will Weatherford of Wesley Chapel say they were not consulted before the state party acted. They are now statewide leaders, and that is simply not good enough. Attorney General Pam Bondi dodges the question. The governor's spokeswoman says Scott was not consulted, which defies logic.

And where is former Gov. Jeb Bush, who finds time to endorse legislative candidates and pontificate on public education but has remained silent on this attack on the courts? Bush's hands are not clean on politicizing the courts. It was his administration that won authority for governors to stack the judicial nominating commissions that select the finalists for judicial appointments. And it was Bush who appointed a political hack like Paul Hawkes, the disgraced former appellate judge who resigned rather than face judicial charges over the construction of a lavish Tallahassee courthouse dubbed the Taj Mahal.

This is a serious threat to the independence of the Florida Supreme Court. The state Republican Party chairman inaccurately claims the justices are individually raising campaign money when in fact they are prohibited by judicial canons from soliciting contributions themselves. Americans for Prosperity, a conservative nonprofit backed by the billionaire Koch brothers, is airing a misleading ad about the court's decision to keep off the ballot a poorly worded health care amendment. Now is the time for Florida leaders to educate the voters with facts about the importance of merit retention and an impartial judiciary — not to hide in silence as the misinformation spreads.


  1.  LISA BENSON  |  Lisa Benson -- Washington Post Writers Group
  2. Pasco County is spending $21.9 million to preserve 845 acres in central Pasco though its environmental lands program. Pasco County
    The plot may be too narrow in places, writes a Sierra Club conservationist.
  3. In this Oct. 22, 2018, photo, people gather around the Ben & Jerry's "Yes on 4" truck as they learn about Amendment 4 and eat free ice cream at Charles Hadley Park in Miami. WILFREDO LEE  |  AP
    An errant comma may affect the interpretation of Amendment 4, writes a law professor.
  4. Jacob "Jake" Weinert, 28, was killed on Nov. 12 when a pickup truck struck him from him behind while he was bicycling to work on U.S. 301 near Sligh Avenue in Tampa. Courtesy Izabel Sgie
    Here’s what readers had to say in Friday’s letters to the editor.
  5. Scott Purcell, a senior geophysicist with GeoView, left, and Mike Wightman, president of GeoView use ground penetrating radar technology to scan a portion of King High campus in search for Ridgewood Cemetery in Tampa, Florida on Wednesday, October 23, 2019.  OCTAVIO JONES  |  Times
    The searches are a solemn responsibility for public and private land owners.
  6. The sun sets in the Everglades just east of Naples as seen from the Tamiami Trail. J. PAT CARTER  |  Associated Press
    The environmental challenges of preserving a place that meant so much and drew so many of us here should serve as a rallying cry for all Floridians.
  7. Should we stop changing our clocks twice a year? CHARLES KRUPA  |  AP
    The Republican senator, along with Sen. Rick Scott, introduced the Sunshine Protection Act earlier this year.
  8. U.S. Ambassador to the European Union Gordon Sondland listens to the closing statement of House Intelligence Committee Chairman Adam Schiff, D-Calif., before the House Intelligence Committee on Capitol Hill in Washington, Wednesday, Nov. 20, 2019, during a public impeachment hearing of President Donald Trump's efforts to tie U.S. aid for Ukraine to investigations of his political opponents. ANDREW HARNIK  |  AP
    Trump’s ambassador provided clarity in the impeachment inquiry Wednesday.
  9. Kamalah Fletcher wears a medical mask over her face saying "No Coverage = Death" during a 2015 demonstration in Miami calling for Florida lawmakers to agree to Medicaid expansion. LYNNE SLADKY  |  AP
    Here’s what readers had to say in Thursday’s letters to the editor.
  10. Leonard Pitts undefined
    Columnist Leonard Pitts Jr. rewrites a fairy tale for our times.