Advertisement
  1. Opinion

Book review: James Comey wants to explain himself

NEW YORK, NY - APRIL 18: Former FBI Director James Comey poses for photographs as he arrives to speak about his new book "A Higher Loyalty: Truth, Lies, and Leadership" at Barnes & Noble bookstore, April 18, 2018 in New York City. The book, which went on sale yesterday, focuses on leadership principles and details his interactions with President Donald Trump. Comey served as FBI Director from September 2013 until May 2017, when he was fired by the president. Comey previously served as U.S. Deputy Attorney General and U.S. Attorney for the Southern District of New York. (Photo by Drew Angerer/Getty Images) 775153786
NEW YORK, NY - APRIL 18: Former FBI Director James Comey poses for photographs as he arrives to speak about his new book "A Higher Loyalty: Truth, Lies, and Leadership" at Barnes & Noble bookstore, April 18, 2018 in New York City. The book, which went on sale yesterday, focuses on leadership principles and details his interactions with President Donald Trump. Comey served as FBI Director from September 2013 until May 2017, when he was fired by the president. Comey previously served as U.S. Deputy Attorney General and U.S. Attorney for the Southern District of New York. (Photo by Drew Angerer/Getty Images) 775153786
Published Apr. 20, 2018

In 2016, as the director of the FBI, James Comey publicly dissected Hillary Clinton's email server controversy. Later, we learned that Comey was keeping to himself the beginnings of an investigation into Russia's active interference in the U.S. election and potential connections to the Donald Trump campaign.

It was a perplexing contradiction for someone who said he was apolitical and above the fray.

Now James Comey wants to explain himself. A Higher Loyalty: Truth, Lies and Leadership is Comey's story of what he did and why. You may not agree with him afterward, but his lengthy explanation is more straight-forward and convincing than you might think. On camera, Comey can be a bit holier-than-thou and a touch sanctimonious. His book, however, is an exploration and exhortation of principles that are universal: truth, integrity, order, and protecting those who are weak or struggling.

The book also happens to be a devastating character study of President Donald Trump, whom Comey served until Trump unceremoniously fired him in May 2017. Comey says that Trump tried to coerce Comey's loyalty like a mafia don, making subtle threats against his job and asking him to back off an investigation of the former National Security Adviser Michael Flynn.

Trump seems to repel Comey on a visceral level, with Comey describing Trump as a liar, "unethical, and untethered to truth and institutional values," with a leadership style that was "transactional, ego driven, and about personal loyalty."

Trump, however, takes up a small portion of Comey's book, which shapes up as a fairly traditional memoir of someone who's spent his entire career in law enforcement, shaped by its values of justice and order. It's not too stodgy, though, because Comey has had a front-row seat for some of the biggest legal issues of the past 20 years.

Most notably, Comey was one of several attorneys in the George W. Bush administration to push back about the post-9/11 authorization of torture. Comey also dramatically opposed the Bush administration's attempts — led by Vice President Dick Cheney and Cheney's counsel David Addington — to reauthorize a surveillance program that lacked sound legal footing.

The surveillance program, called Stellar Wind, led to a 2004 showdown in the hospital room of the ailing Attorney General John Ashcroft, whom Comey then served as deputy attorney general. Bush's chief of staff Andrew Card and White House counsel Alberto Gonzales tried to get a weakened Ashcroft to overrule Comey's stand against the program. Ashcroft refused.

Comey was in the room that night; so was Robert Mueller, then serving as Bush's FBI director. The glimpses of Mueller are some of the most intriguing of the book. Comey describes him as someone who "cared deeply about the rule of law. His whole life was about doing things the right way." Comey also repeats an anecdote that Mueller was known to have had knee surgery without anesthesia. Instead, Mueller bit on a leather belt.

Mueller is now special counsel investigating Russian interference in 2016 and Trump's campaign. Comey says that he believes Trump's actions "while disturbing and violating basic norms of ethical leadership, may fall short of being illegal." Mueller and his team, however, "will get to the truth, whatever that is."

Spend your days with Hayes

Spend your days with Hayes

Subscribe to our free Stephinitely newsletter

Columnist Stephanie Hayes will share thoughts, feelings and funny business with you every Monday.

You’re all signed up!

Want more of our free, weekly newsletters in your inbox? Let’s get started.

Explore all your options

The truth is one of the constant preoccupations of A Higher Loyalty. Comey laments, "We are experiencing a dangerous time in our country, with a political environment where basic facts are disputed, fundamental truth is questioned, lying is normalized, and unethical behavior is ignored, excused or rewarded."

Comey justifies his public statements about Clinton's emails during the thick of the campaign as his own way of striving for the highest ethical standards. While the Justice Department and FBI typically don't comment on investigations when no charges are filed, both agencies have "established exceptions to our no-comment policy, for investigations of extraordinary public interest or where our investigative activity is apparent to the public," Comey writes. The Clinton case fit both of those parameters.

"A world-class FBI team had investigated Hillary Clinton for a year, and all of them — to a person — believed there was no prosecutable case," Comey writes, adding, "The FBI was independent and apolitical, and the American people needed to see that." Later, Comey came forward to make more statements about Clinton's emails when a laptop was discovered with additional data on it. (The laptop belonged to Clinton aide Huma Abedin; law enforcement confiscated it while investigating her estranged husband Anthony Weiner for sex offenses.)

Meanwhile, how much to publicize Russian meddling in the election was debated by President Barack Obama's leadership team, not just the FBI. Obama settled on the director of national intelligence and the secretary of homeland security issuing a joint statement. Comey was willing to make a public statement himself, he said, but ultimately found it unnecessary. "Adding the FBI's name would change nothing and be inconsistent with the way we hoped to operate on the eve of an election. … Americans already knew what was happening, so the FBI could reasonably avoid action."

How much were Comey's actions driven by the wrong assumption that Clinton would win and Trump would lose? His answer: "I have asked myself many times since if I was influenced by that assumption. I don't know. Certainly not consciously, but I would be a fool to say it couldn't have had an impact on me."

Taking Comey's arguments in their entirety, it's hard not to wonder whether Comey's obsession with the reputation of the FBI trumped other principles that would have served Comey's ultimate goals better. People who aren't found to have committed a crime typically should not be publicly castigated by law enforcement as some sort of alternative punishment. Comey decided that an exception in Clinton's case was warranted. It's unknowable but possible (and some have argued probable) that his decision led to the election of Donald Trump. Trump has repeatedly castigated the FBI as being filled with partisans on a politically motivated witch hunt. In the end, like a king in a Greek tragedy, Comey's actions may have unintentionally undermined the very goals that were so important to him.

Contact PolitiFact editor Angie Drobnic Holan at holan@politifact.com.

Advertisement

This site no longer supports your current browser. Please use a modern and up-to-date browser version for the best experience.

Chrome Firefox Safari Edge