Advertisement
  1. Pinellas

'We will fight this.' Legal action stops work on new Caddy's restaurant in St. Pete Beach

This aerial view shows a St. Pete Beach inlet leading to the former Silas Dent's restaurant (painted yellow). At left is a finger of land with homes along 55th Avenue, where one resident has taken legal action to halt a project that would turn the old Silas Dent's into a Caddy's restaurant and bar. [Courtesy of Edward Stapor]
This aerial view shows a St. Pete Beach inlet leading to the former Silas Dent's restaurant (painted yellow). At left is a finger of land with homes along 55th Avenue, where one resident has taken legal action to halt a project that would turn the old Silas Dent's into a Caddy's restaurant and bar. [Courtesy of Edward Stapor]
Published Mar. 19, 2019

ST. PETE BEACH — Renovation work on the new Caddy's restaurant on the Intracoastal Waterway has been halted pending the outcome of two legal actions filed by a nearby resident who is challenging the building permit issued by the city.

Donald J. Schutz, a long-time resident and lawyer, filed an administrative appeal and a lawsuit in Pinellas-Pasco Circuit Court earlier this month in an effort to invalidate the permit issued to Caddy's St. Pete Beach by the city's building department.

A number of nearby condominium residents had unsuccessfully protested the permit when it was pending several months ago, despite efforts by the restaurant owners to ease their concerns about noise coming from an open-air section at the rear of the restaurant.

"We will fight this," said Marcus Winters, one of the Caddy's owners. "As far as we are concerned, there is no reason Caddy's can't be open at the back."

The new restaurant, on the site of the closed Silas Dent's Steakhouse at 5501 Gulf Blvd., would be the sixth Caddy's location in the Tampa Bay area. The original Caddy's is in Treasure Island, with the others in Gulfport, Indian Shores, downtown St. Petersburg and Bradenton.

Winters said a seventh restaurant is planned on the Gulf of Mexico in Madeira Beach.

Schutz, who owns a single-family home and dock with a number of boats on the inlet leading to the restaurant, echoed and expanded on other residents' complaints in his lawsuit.

"The permit is in clear violation … (and) the city has knowingly and culpably enacted municipal policy … that damages the property rights of all property owners in the vicinity," he wrote in a letter to the city's attorney before filing the lawsuit.

City officials have maintained that the permit is lawful and adheres to all zoning and building regulations. However, as a result of Schutz's legal actions, they recently issued a stop-work order on the Caddy's renovations.

"We had started work and had to pull all our men and materials off the job" said Bill Karns, whose Treasure Island-based firm is the contractor for the restaurant renovation. "The Caddy's folks were extremely disappointed."

Schutz objects to the noise he says will emanate from the rear of the restaurant and negative impacts on his home from visiting boat traffic.

He says the inlet — framed by the restaurant, condominiums and homes — is essentially an "amphitheater" that would amplify sound from music and patrons at Caddy's.

The adjacent homes would experience "late night sound within a few feet," he wrote, adding: "Would anyone with a multimillion-dollar home want to be out in their back yard swimming or barbecuing with dozens of restaurant patrons watching them?"

No date for the administrative appeal hearing has been set and the city has yet to file a response to Schutz's lawsuit, which claims the permit violated state law and the city's own comprehensive plan and land use regulations.

It says the dock was never legally permitted for commercial use, even though it had previously been used by patrons of the former Silas Dent's restaurant.

Schutz also claims that a lack of buffering between the rear wall and nearby residential buildings legally bars any opening in that wall during business hours.

Caddy's permit allows one opening in a section of wall to allow patrons to view the waterway and enjoy its natural breezes.

During inclement weather and non-business hours, the opening would be closed with a roll-down door.

YOU MIGHT ALSO LIKE

  1. A contractor with Pinellas County uses a tiller to fluff sand on the shoreline of Redington Shores beach Thursday. The tiller fluffs the sand making it easier for sea turtles to dig nests to lay eggs. [DOUGLAS R. CLIFFORD  |  Times]
  2. People wearing masks walk in a subway station in Hong Kong early this month as the coronavirus continued to spread. Travel in China is one of the topics health care officials in Florida are bringing up with patients as concern about a pandemic grows. [KIN CHEUNG  |  Associated Press]
  3. Kermon Williams is wanted in connection with a January 2019 shooting in which two people died. [St. Petersburg Police Department]
  4. The antebellum mansions of Charleston's East Battery are a highlight of the city's historic district. SUSAN C. HEGGER  |  St. Louis Post Dispatch (2004) [SUSAN C. HEGGER  |  KRT]
  5. The scene of a double stabbing death in Largo, left, (photo courtesy Bay News 9) and booking photo of Wiley S. Mackenzie, arrested on two counts of murder. [Bay Nes 9/Pinellas County Sheriff's Office]
  6. A mystery billboard. A Tampa photographer's journey. A cruise to the Bahamas. Here's what leap day means to Floridians. [Clockwise from left: Times archives, Amie Santavicca and screenshot from leapdaycruise.com]
  7. Pinellas Park City Council member Patricia "Patti" Johnson, 74, has died of cancer, according to the city. [City of Pinellas Park]
  8. Benjamin Martin, 31, left, attacked Clearwater parking lot shooter Michael Drejka, 49, right, while they were inmates at Lancaster Correctional Institutional on Feb. 11, according to the Florida Department of Corrections. [Florida Department of Corrections]
  9. Sara, Mouse, Lilly and Mario are looking for their forever homes. [Courtesy of Hernando County Animal Services, St. Francis Animal Rescue, Pasco County Animal Services, Friends of Strays]
  10. Thomas Henry Shayhorn, left, and Dennis Phillip Lermy, right, were arrested after Pinellas deputies received a report of a man driving a Jaguar recklessly while shooting up with a needle. [Pinellas County Sheriff's Office]
  11. An unidentified fisherman wades into the water as storm clouds build over Tampa Bay as seen from the Gandy Bridge in St. Petersburg Wednesday. [MARTHA ASENCIO-RHINE  |  Times]
  12. An artist's rendering shows one view of Tyrone Middle School in St. Petersburg after a $28 million renovation. Work is expected to start in February 2021. The Pinellas County School Board approved a contract with Rowe Architects Inc. to work on the project. [Pinellas County Schools]
Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement