1. Sports
  2. /
  3. Rays

Rays 2019: Is Tampa Bay’s opener plan really that radical?

Here’s what’s critics missing about the Rays’ pitching philosophy that is spreading.
Photo illustration of Rays pitcher Diego Castillo. Illustration by Sean Kristoff-Jones. Times staff photo.
Published Mar. 22

The critics are missing the point, which often happens in matters of baseball and tradition. Maybe more so when you add money and pride.

This is the story of Tampa Bay’s flirtation with innovation, specifically the idea of using relief pitchers as openers. Surely, you’ve heard the outrage. It was as if the Rays left graffiti on Cy Young’s headstone.

Opposing players called it a farce. Oldtimers hated it. Agents worried it would upend salary structures, and even baseball iconoclast Joe Maddon doubted its staying power.

But here’s what many of the critics failed to see:

The plan helped the Rays win.

And, really, what other argument is there?

The Rays were not trying to make a mockery of convention or hold salaries down or be the coolest kids in the dugout. They simply wanted to maximize their potential and decided this was one way to do it.

“That’s exactly it. We’re just trying to put ourselves in position to win as many games as possible,’’ said senior vice president Chaim Bloom. “That’s the only objective here and it’s behind everything we do.’’

It might seem like Giants pitcher Jeff Samardzija or Astros pitcher Gerrit Cole were defending the integrity of players or old-school baseball when they blasted the Rays for minimizing starting pitching, but in the end they look a little self-serving for failing to understand either the concept or the results.

There are a lot of ways you can measure Tampa Bay’s experiment with openers, but nothing is quite as stark as this:

In 55 games using an opener, the Rays had a .582 winning percentage.

In every other game, they had a .542 winning percentage. And that includes 31 starts by Cy Young Award winner Blake Snell.

“I think if you want to make a blanket statement here, it’s that we are putting guys in position to be successful,’’ pitching coach Kyle Snyder said. “More successful than they’d be with any of the traditional ideologies. And we’re giving ourselves a better chance to win ballgames.’’

Rays officials have been kicking this idea around for years, convinced of its potential but less sure about its reception in their own clubhouse. As it so happened, the tumblers fell into place last May.

Tampa Bay had lost several starting pitchers to season-ending injuries. They had a handful of other candidates who could have taken on the role of the fourth or fifth starter in the rotation, but there was concern those pitchers might struggle when facing batters for the third time in a game.

That made the opener concept a plausible solution.

Instead of putting inexperienced starters on the mound in the first inning, with the risk of pulling them in the third or fourth inning, the Rays went the other way. The first inning or two — and theoretically the best hitters — would be handled by high-octane relievers. The bulk guys could then come in with more advantageous matchups, and a chance to pitch a little deeper in the game.

This accomplished two things: It kept hitters off-balance because they were facing different pitchers early, and it also allowed the Rays to better control individual matchups. The bulk guy would ideally pitch to between 18-21 hitters, but had the flexibility of going longer depending on the circumstances.

As for the results? Ryan Yarbrough had a 4.71 ERA in his six appearances as a traditional starter. Working in relief, including 12 appearances of five innings or more, his ERA was 3.72. Yonny ­Chirinos was the same. He had a 4.73 ERA in six starts, and a 2.83 ERA working out of the bullpen.

“There’s some push-pull to what we’re doing,’’ Snyder said. “There’s a lot of velocity at the beginning of the game and then there’s some craft with off-speed pitches behind them and then we go straight to matchups in the bullpen after that. Yeah, we are offsetting (a hitter’s) rhythm and ­timing by managing it this way.

“It’s definitely disruptive. I think it was (Anaheim’s) Zack Cozart who made the comment that it was like a spring training game and you can’t get used to a guy. Well, that just supports what we’re doing.’’

Does this mean openers are a permanent part of Tampa Bay’s strategy?

RELATED: More from John Romano

Not even the Rays are prepared to say that. They will use openers again this year because Yarbrough, Chirinos, Jalen Beeks and others fit nicely in the profile of bulk guys, but it’s possible this is just a snapshot in time. Maybe Yarbrough and Chirinos eventually become traditional starters. Maybe the next crop of Rays pitching prospects are better suited for starting roles.

“I don’t think we know enough to say,’’ Bloom said. “The point of this is two-fold. No. 1, is to learn as we go. To say we know how things are going to be in 5 or 10 years would defeat that purpose. No. 2, we always wanted to make a plan that fit our pitchers and their strengths and weaknesses and that’s going to continue to be the objective moving forward.’’

Yes, the Rays are eschewing traditional notions about when pitchers come and go in a game, but they’re still just trying to reach 27 outs as quickly as possible.

Is that really such a radical idea?

Contact John Romano at Follow @romano_tbtimes


  1. Tampa Bay Rays center fielder Tommy Pham (29) celebrates inherent dug out after hitting a two run homer in the third inning against the Toronto Blue Jays, September 27, 2019 in Toronto, Ontario. DIRK SHADD  |  Times
    Pham said he enjoyed the team Rays had, expected to be pushing with them for a 2020 World Series championship.
  2. Rays fans grew accustomed to scenes such as this last season. Tommy Pham got thrown out on the bases 20 times, which was third-most in the majors. It was also part of a disturbing trend. He was also thrown out 15 times in 2017 and 18 in 2018. DIRK SHADD | Times Photo DIRK SHADD  |  Times
    John Romano | Deciphering Tampa Bay’s offseason moves feels like playing 3D chess. You cannot judge their trades simply by the stats on the back of a baseball card.
  3. San Diego Padres' Hunter Renfroe bats against the Arizona Diamondbacks during the third inning of a baseball game, Saturday, Sept. 28, 2019, in Phoenix. (AP Photo/Ralph Freso) RALPH FRESO  |  AP
    Trade with Padres also yields Rays touted prospect Xavier Edwards, costs them Jake Cronenworth.
  4. In this Dec. 6, 2013, file photo, Yankees GM Brian Cashman rappels down One Landmark Square during a charity event in Stamford, Conn. While Cashman was descending the Landmark Building in Stamford on Friday, Dec. 6, 2019, in preparation for a holiday celebration this weekend, he came across a message taped to a 10th-floor window from a fan: Please sign Gerrit Cole. DRU NADLER  |  AP
    New York’s general manager, who met with the prized free agent pitcher on Tuesday, says the sign was taped to a 10th-floor window of the 22-story building in Connecticut.
  5. The post of Blake Snell's reaction to the trade was popular on Twitter Friday. Twitter
    Snell said his comments about Xavier Edwards captured on the Twitch gaming stream weren’t meant to be disrespectful.
  6. San Diego Padres' Hunter Renfroe is congratulated in the dugout after hitting a home run during the fourth inning of a baseball game against the Colorado Rockies on Aug. 10. ORLANDO RAMIREZ  |  AP
    Powerful outfielder, prospect are return in deal that sent Tommy Pham and prospect Jake Cronenworth to San Diego.
  7. Mayor Rick Kriseman on Wednesday said he will not allow the Tampa Bay Rays to explore splitting their season between the Tampa Bay area and Montreal prior to the 2027 expiration of the team's lease of Tropicana Field. CHRIS URSO  |  Times
    Politicians on both sides of the bay weigh in on St. Petersburg Mayor Rick Kriseman’s decision to cease talks with the team.
  8. Rays team presidents Brian Auld and Matt Silverman in their office at Tropicana Field in St. Petersburg. WILL VRAGOVIC  |  Tampa Bay Rays
    Team presidents Brian Auld and Matt Silverman on the Montreal plan, stadium sites, downtown St. Pete development and more.
  9. Tampa Bay Rays left fielder Tommy Pham (29) takes a moment in the dugout after the Rays 6-2 loss to the Houston Astros in Game 1 of the American League Division Series Friday, Oct. 4, 2019 in Houston. DIRK SHADD  |  Times
    When deal is announced Friday, Rays will add a power bat and young talent, and shed Pham’s projected $8.6 million salary.
  10. It would help if regular season crowds were as large and enthusiastic as the American League Division Series against Houston last month. As it is, the Rays have been at the bottom of the American League in attendance for much of the past decade despite one of the highest win totals in baseball. MARTHA ASENCIO-RHINE  |  Times
    John Romano | Mayor Rick Kriseman’s decision to dismiss the shared city plan with Montreal means the Rays probably won’t get a stadium deal until their lease runs out in St. Pete in 2028.