1. Sports
  2. /
  3. Bucs

The eye-opening lesson the Bucs should learn from the Titans’ surprising playoff run

“If only we had Derrick Henry” would be the wrong conclusion.
Titans running back Derrick Henry is the first player to gain 377 rushing yards in his team’s first two playoff games. [JULIO CORTEZ  |  Associated Press]
Titans running back Derrick Henry is the first player to gain 377 rushing yards in his team’s first two playoff games. [JULIO CORTEZ | Associated Press]
Published Jan. 13
Updated Jan. 15

Neanderthal Football Guy came out of hiding this weekend. The occasion: to revel in the Ravens’ elimination from the NFL playoffs.

Baltimore had it coming. It dared to challenge football convention. Instead of forcing Lamar Jackson to be a traditional dropback pocket passer, the Ravens built a versatile offense around their multidimensional quarterback. Putting players in position to succeed — the audacity! The unmitigated gall!

Thing is, it worked. During the regular season, Baltimore led in the NFL in points per drive (3.1), yards per drive (41.8) and plays per drive (6.8). The offense seldom punted and rarely went three-and-out. And Jackson? All he did was make history. He became the first quarterback to pass for 3,000 yards and rush for 1,000 yards in a single season. He led his team to a league-high 14 wins and, for the first time in team history, the conference’s No. 1 seed and home-field advantage throughout the playoffs.

On Saturday, what had been working stopped working. The Ravens scored a touchdown on only one of their four trips inside the red zone. They turned the ball over three times. They failed on all four of their fourth-down conversion attempts. Meanwhile, the Titans whaled away, with Derrick Henry delivering one jaw-rattling run after another. The final score: Tennessee 28, Baltimore 12.

Ravens quarterback Lamar Jackson passed for 365 yards and rushed for 143 on Saturday. He also threw two interceptions and lost a fumble. [NICK WASS | Associated Press]

What happened? A bad game at the wrong time. But to Neanderthal Football Guy, forever a prisoner of the moment, it was a complete repudiation of the Ravens and their accomplishments.

Pound the rock! Running the ball is back! Still a winning formula! Ungh!!!!!

You wonder what the Buccaneers’ shot-callers were thinking as they watched the Titans celebrate.

“If only we had Derrick Henry” would be the wrong conclusion. Sure, it would be nice to have a 6-foot-3, 250-pound human bulldozer in the backfield, but it’s worth noting a few things:

• There is one Derrick Henry, and Tennessee had to use a second-round draft pick in 2016 to get him.

• Unless you’re a Titans fan, you probably hadn’t thought about him until recently. His success this postseason is unprecedented. No player has ever gained 377 rushing yards in his team’s first two playoff games.

• Henry has rushed for at least 180 yards five times in his career. Three of those performances have come in the past three weeks. In other words, beware of recency bias.

• Also beware of using yards per carry as a measure of efficiency. As Football Outsiders noted, about 60 percent of Henry’s yardage against the Ravens came on three runs. Thirteen of his 30 carries resulted in gains of fewer than 2 yards, six resulted in a first down and none resulted in a touchdown.

• Running the ball is not the “winning formula” old-school analysts and fans purport it to be. They’re looking for confirmation of what they already believe. In general, teams don’t win when they run. They run when they’re winning. So says math.

No doubt, Henry has been productive — historically so — but how much has he contributed to the Titans’ margins of victory? Thanks to expected points, we can quantify his impact. Expected points isn’t some new-fangled advanced statistic; it has been around for decades. Bob Carroll, Pete Palmer and John Thorn introduced us to the concept in their 1988 book The Hidden Game of Football.

By comparing the expected value of a down-distance-field position situation at the start of a play and the expected value of a down-distance-field position situation at the end of a play, we can measure the value of individual plays. As it turns out, the Titans’ run game is not the advantage it seems to be.

In Tennessee’s win over New England a week ago, the pass offense added 0.07 expected points per play. The run offense added 0.08.

In Tennessee’s win over Baltimore on Saturday, the pass offense added 0.22 expected points per play. The run offense added 0.21.

Titans quarterback Ryan Tannehill has yet to pass for 100 yards in a game this postseason. [JULIO CORTEZ | Associated Press]

So, despite Henry’s historically high output and quarterback Ryan Tannehill’s historically low output, the value of the contributions on a per-play basis were about the same. (And, no, Henry’s runs haven’t set up play-action passes. There is no relationship between running — frequency or effectiveness — and play-action pass success.)

It’s true that the final four teams left in the playoffs — the Chiefs, Titans, 49ers and Packers — can run the ball, but they have something else in common, something more important: Their quarterback play has been exceptional.

All four quarterbacks finished in the top 13 this season in pass DVOA, or defense-adjusted value over average, Football Outsiders’ measure of efficiency. Patrick Mahomes ranked third, Tannehill fifth, Jimmy Garoppolo 11th and Aaron Rodgers 13th. Jameis Winston, by the way, ranked 25th. This quarterback quartet took care of the football, throwing a combined 28 interceptions, two fewer than Winston.

The numbers prove that the most meaningful difference between the Titans and Bucs offenses this season wasn’t how well they ran the ball. The most meaningful difference was that Tennessee’s coaches didn’t stay the course with a quarterback they didn’t trust. They benched Marcus Mariota after six games and a 2-4 start. With Tannehill as their quarterback, the Titans have won nine of their past 12. The Bucs allowed Winston to continue throwing games away.

Related: Jameis Winston and Marcus Mariota share the same fatal flaw, and we ignored it

This isn’t to say Henry hasn’t contributed to Tennessee’s success. Tannehill’s efficiency, however, has been the difference-maker. He finished the regular season first in yards per pass (9.6) and second to only Jackson in touchdown percentage (7.7).

So, no, pounding the rock is not back in vogue. Saturday’s game was a blip. Pass plays are still more valuable than run plays.

Take note, Neanderthal Football Guy. The battle has been fought. The nerds have won. They’ve breached the gates. They’ve reached the front offices of numerous teams throughout the league. Football isn’t going backward.

Change isn’t linear, but it is inevitable. Adapt or die.

Statistics in this report are from Football Outsiders and Pro Football Reference. Contact Thomas Bassinger at Follow @tometrics


  1. Colin Kaepernick, middle, kneels for the national anthem. He hasn't taken a snap in the NFL for three full seasons now.
    "Inspire Change'' campaign is a sanitized version of what Colin Kaepernick tried to get across by kneeling for the national anthem.
  2. New York Giants quarterback Eli Manning (10) runs on the sideline in the second half of an NFL football game against Philadelphia Eagles on Sunday, Dec. 29, 2019, in East Rutherford, N.J. [ADAM HUNGER  |  AP]
    Manning: “From the very first moment I did it my way.”
  3. NFC cornerback Shaquill Griffin of the Seattle Seahawks gives a thumbs up during Pro Bowl NFL football practice, Wednesday, Jan. 22, 2020, in Kissimmee, Fla. (AP Photo/Steve Luciano) [STEVE LUCIANO  |  AP]
    Third-year Seahawks cornerback is being rewarded for his standout season, and is excited to share it with his family. “We all made the Pro Bowl.”
  4. In this Oct. 23, 2016, file photo, a New Orleans Saints helmet rests on the playing field before an NFL football game in Kansas City, Mo. The Saints are going to court to keep the public from seeing hundreds of emails that allegedly show team executives doing public relations damage control for the area's Roman Catholic archdiocese to help it contain the fallout from a burgeoning sexual abuse crisis. (AP Photo/Jeff Roberson, File) [JEFF ROBERSON  |  AP]
    Saints attorneys disputed any suggestion that the team helped the church cover up crimes, calling such claims “outrageous.”
  5. NFC quarterback Drew Brees, of the New Orleans Saints, throws a pass during a practice for the NFL Pro Bowl football game Wednesday, Jan. 22, 2020, in Kissimmee, Fla. (AP Photo/Chris O'Meara) [CHRIS O'MEARA  |  AP]
    The Bucs could be impacted as they decide on Jameis Winston, with Brees’ New Orleans backup Teddy Bridgewater as a possible option.
  6. Kansas City Chiefs outside linebacker Terrell Suggs (94) celebrates a sack of Los Angeles Chargers quarterback Philip Rivers (17) during the second half of an NFL football game in Kansas City, Mo., Sunday, Dec. 29, 2019. [REED HOFFMANN  |  AP]
    John Romano | The Bucs played well enough on both sides of the ball to be one of the top 10 teams in the NFL. One stat kept them from possibly being the Chiefs or 49ers.
  7. Former Georgia quarterback Jake Fromm could be an interesting option for the Bucs to consider, if they want to move on from Jameis Winston. [BILL FEIG  |  AP]
    As the Bucs possibly look into moving on from Jameis Winston, here’s what fans should know about this draft’s quarterback class.
  8. In this Sunday, Sept. 15, 2019, file photo, then-Patriots receiver Antonio Brown roams the sideline during the first half against the Dolphins in Miami Gardens. Law enforcement authorities have issued an arrest warrant for Brown, who along with his trainer has been accused of attacking a man near Brown's South Florida home in Hollywood. [LYNNE SLADKY  |  AP]
    The troubled NFL wide receiver is accused, along with his trainer, of attacking a man in South Florida.
  9. NFC linebacker Shaquil Barrett (58) of the Tampa Bay Buccaneers, hands Sean Silverthorn, of Largo, Fla., two tickets to the Super Bowl after a practice for the NFL Pro Bowl football game Wednesday, Jan. 22, 2020, in Kissimmee, Fla. [CHRIS O'MEARA  |  AP]
    At this time last year, he was a player without a team. Now, having earned his place among the game’s greats, the Buccaneers outside linebacker is making dreams come true for him, his family and a...
  10. In this Feb. 7, 2012 file photo New York Giants quarterback Eli Manning holds up the Vince Lombardi Trophy during the team's NFL football Super Bowl parade in New York. Manning, who led the Giants to two Super Bowls in a 16-year career that saw him set almost every team passing record, has retired. The Giants said Wednesday, Jan. 22, 2020 that Manning would formally announce his retirement on Friday. [JULIO CORTEZ  |  AP]
    The two-time Super Bowl MVP is calling it quits after 16 seasons, all with the same team.