1. Sports
  2. /
  3. Bucs

The Super Bowl is finished but the second guessing goes on forever

John Romano | Looking back at Kansas City’s victory in Super Bowl 54 through the perspective of Gimme 5.
That would be the Lombardi Trophy. And that would be Kansas City Chiefs head coach Andy Reid's reflection in it. Reid disposed of the title of the best coach to never win a Super Bowl when the Chiefs beat the 49ers 31-20 in Super Bowl 54. [BRYNN ANDERSON  |  AP]
That would be the Lombardi Trophy. And that would be Kansas City Chiefs head coach Andy Reid's reflection in it. Reid disposed of the title of the best coach to never win a Super Bowl when the Chiefs beat the 49ers 31-20 in Super Bowl 54. [BRYNN ANDERSON | AP]
Published Feb. 3
Updated Feb. 4

Five topics suitable for inane debate on talk radio

1. Salt? Meet wound: In the moments before the opening kickoff, nearly every Super Bowl can feel like a toss-up. Seven of the past 10, for instance, had a betting spread of three points or fewer. Even when a team is a huge favorite (the Patriots were favored by 12 in 2007 and lost 17-14 to New York) there are moments of uncertainty before the kickoff. The point being, a team should never feel badly about losing a Super Bowl. Except in cases such as this. When the game is down to its final seven minutes, and you have a 10-point lead, the odds dramatically shift in your favor. With 7:13 remaining, an index used by ESPN to calculate percentages put San Francisco’s chance of winning the Super Bowl at 95.4 percent. And yet the 49ers lost.

Related: Did Patrick Mahomes just write the greatest comeback story in NFL history?

2. One play that changed everything: So what happened? At that zenith in odds, Kansas City had third and 15 from its own 35. The 49ers might as well have had a jeweler on the sideline taking ring measurements. Except that’s when Patrick Mahomes hit Tyreek Hill for a 44-yard reception. Replays showed safety Jimmie Ward biting on an inside fake, which left Hill wide open. Chiefs quarterback coach Mike Kafka told NBC’s Peter King that they ran the same play earlier in the game except Hill ran toward the middle of the field. So when they ran it in the fourth quarter, Ward fell for Hill’s inside fake.

3. Thank you, sir: A tweet from the president congratulated the Chiefs for representing “the Great State of Kansas.’’ Sure was nice of Mr. Trudeau.

Kansas City Chiefs quarterback Patrick Mahomes (15) looks to make a pass during the first half of Sunday's Super Bowl. [STEVE LUCIANO | AP]

4. Show him the money: It’s a simplistic way of looking at it, but the difference in the game was the two quarterbacks. Jimmy Garoppolo was fairly efficient through three quarters, but was mostly throwing underneath. Mahomes was not nearly as impressive as we’re used to seeing but came through with some downfield passes when necessary. If you want to sum it up in two plays, Mahomes hits Hill for the 44-yard gain when the Chiefs were trailing, and Garoppolo badly overthrows Emmanuel Sanders on a play that could have regained the lead in the final two minutes.

Related: Drugs and a viral video wrecked Chris Foerster’s NFL career. Super Bowl 54 offers redemption

5. Run for your life: The 49ers handed the ball off to running backs more than any team in the NFL this season. Yet, curiously, their percentage of running plays decreased when they got the lead on Sunday. In the game’s first 35 minutes, the 49ers called 14 runs and 16 passes. Once they took the lead in the second half, they called five running plays and nine passes in their next three drives. You could defend a fair number of those play calls, but the bottom line is Mahomes was getting the ball back quickly while trailing.

A list of five

Five ways the Chiefs are better than the Bucs

5. Utilizing this new position called tight end.

4. Bucs threw five interceptions in Week 6. Chiefs had five interceptions in 2019.

3. Decided biscuits weren’t worth the risk.

2. Hardly ever auction off their home games to London.

1. Don’t have a standing reservation in Maui every January.

Related: Is the Niners defense elite? Not without a championship

Five potential legacies from Super Bowl 54

Kansas City Chiefs head coach Andy Reid is doused on the sideline during the second half of the Super Bowl. [JOHN BAZEMORE | AP]

1. Andy Reid: His place in the Hall of Fame is now secure. Of retired coaches with more than 175 regular-season victories, the only ones not in the Hall of Fame are the three (Marty Schottenheimer, Dan Reeves, Chuck Knox) who never won an NFL title. That’s no longer an issue for Reid.

2. Richard Sherman: He’s one of the top defensive backs of his era, but the sight of Sherman getting beaten badly by Sammy Watkins on a 38-yard reception to set up the go-ahead touchdown in the fourth quarter will be hard to forget.

3. Kyle Shanahan: He’s 40. He’s got plenty of time, and plenty of smarts, so this isn’t the last you’ll hear of Shanahan. But, for now, he has to live with the stigma of blowing big fourth-quarter leads as offensive coordinator in Atlanta (against New England) and now as a head coach in San Francisco. Shanahan’s teams have been outscored 46-0 in the fourth quarter and overtime in two Super Bowl appearances.

San Francisco 49ers general manager John Lynch watches his team warm up before Sunday's big game. [DAVID J. PHILLIP | AP]

4. John Lynch: Not his fault, but the sight of the San Francisco general manager impotently calling for a time-out from the press box has to sting. The 49ers had 59 seconds and three timeouts when they got the ball back late in the second quarter of a 10-10 game. Instead of going for broke, Shanahan played it conservative, apparently to Lynch’s chagrin. Giving away a possession against a high-powered offense is tough to defend.

Related: Pro Football Hall of Fame continues to elude John Lynch

5. Patrick Mahomes: Sacked four times, threw two interceptions, fumbled once and was still the biggest difference-maker on the field. Between Reid and Mahomes, the Chiefs have a chance to be contenders for a very long time.

Five young QBs with Super Bowl rings

Mahomes is not the youngest quarterback to win a Super Bowl, but you could argue he was the most impressive of the kiddie corps.

1. Ben Roethilsberger, 23 years, 340 days: The Steelers did not beat the Seahawks 21-10 because of Big Ben. His passer rating of 22.6 was the worst of any winning quarterback in Super Bowl history.

2. Patrick Mahomes, 24 years, 138 days: The two interceptions were atypical, but Mahomes is one of only two quarterbacks to come from behind by 10 points or more in the fourth quarter. He’s also the youngest Super Bowl MVP in history.

3. Tom Brady, 24 years, 184 days: The first of Brady’s six Super Bowl titles, he took New England on a 53-yard drive in the final minutes to set up Adam Vinatieri’s 48-yard field goal to beat St. Louis 20-17. On the other hand, the Patriots took a 17-3 lead into the fourth quarter.

4. Russell Wilson, 25 years, 65 days: Statistically, Wilson had the best Super Bowl among quarterbacks under 26. He was 18-of-25 for 206 yards, but the game was a laugher. Seattle beat Denver 43-8.

5. Joe Namath, 25 years, 226 days: A solid passing day for Namath (17-of-28 for 206 yards) but the game is most notable for upsetting the supposedly unbeatable Colts in Super Bowl III.

Final five words

Re-starting the clock on Jameis.


  1. Teddy Bridgewater could be on the market if Drew Brees returns to New Orleans, and Bucs head coach Bruce Arians likes Bridgewater.
  2. Tampa Bay Buccaneers head coach Bruce Arians shakes hands with quarterback Jameis Winston (3) after his touchdown pass against the Indianapolis Colts on Dec. 8 in Tampa.
  3. Tampa Bay Buccaneers quarterback Jameis Winston (3) is seen during warmups just prior to taking on Houston Texans Saturday, Dec. 21, 2019 in St. Petersburg.
  4. The Bucs posted a video Tuesday that teases changes to the team's uniforms.
  5. FILE - In this Sept. 17, 2017, file photo, New Orleans Saints owner Tom Benson sits on the sideline with his wife, Gayle Benson, before an NFL football game in New Orleans. An Associated Press review of public tax documents found that the Bensons' foundation has given at least $62 million to the Archdiocese of New Orleans and other Catholic causes over the past dozen years, including gifts to schools, universities, charities and individual parishes. (AP Photo/Bill Feig, File)
  6. Cardinals rookie David Johnson manages only 35 yards on 15 carries in Saturday’s game vs. the Packers.
  7. Whether Quinton Flowers (9) lines up at quarterback, running back or wide receiver this season for the Tampa Bay Vipers, the XFL's double-pass rule will allow him to use his arm as a weapon.
  8. Derrick Brooks, co-chairman of the Super Bowl 55 host committee, holds a helmet with the new logo during a press conference last September in Tampa.
  9. The 1979 Rams got to play a Super Bowl in Pasadena, right down the street from their own stadium, because the Bucs, with quarterback Doug Williams and coach John McKay, failed to score a point in the NFC Championship Game at Tampa Stadium.
  10. Raymond James Stadium will be filled on Feb. 7, 2021, for Super Bowl 55, but will the Bucs be on the field or in front of their televisions? Coming off a 7-9 season, the Bucs are nobody's darlings when it comes to preseason betting lines, but they may be closer to the big game than you think.
  11. In the new XFL, quarterbacks won't have to relay play calls to offensive skill position players. They will hear the calls directly from the sideline.
  12. Tampa Bay Buccaneers defensive end Jason Pierre-Paul (90) works with kids from Roland Park K-8 during a presentation introducing the Jr. Bucs School Program after Tampa Bay Buccaneers training camp at One Buc Place on August 22, 2018. The program will work with more than 300 middle and high schools in Hillsborough and Pinellas counties. It includes player-led instructional videos, flag football kits, new fitness equipment and an enhanced reading program for every student.