Advertisement

How much will USF’s elite academic status help its Power Five pursuits?

Experts say academic profiles are a huge criterion when league presidents contemplate expansion.
 
While USF athletic director Michael Kelly acknowledges the Bulls still have "a lot of athletic things that we have to meet," he says their resume for a possible Power Five invitation has been enhanced by the school's brand-new membership in one of the nation's most elite academic associations.
While USF athletic director Michael Kelly acknowledges the Bulls still have "a lot of athletic things that we have to meet," he says their resume for a possible Power Five invitation has been enhanced by the school's brand-new membership in one of the nation's most elite academic associations. [ IVY CEBALLO | Times ]
Published June 7, 2023|Updated June 8, 2023

TAMPA — For all its efforts to get a foot in the Power Five’s door, USF has come away limping. Poor football performance and slow infrastructure developments have hampered the Bulls’ efforts.

But they have another foot. And this one just might help the school cross that coveted threshold.

Experts say the Bulls’ recent invitation to join the Association of American Universities — an honor bestowed upon fewer than 80 institutions nationally — carries major cachet with university presidents.

At last check, presidents determined which schools enter their respective athletic conferences.

“People don’t understand how important (being an Association of American Universities member) really is,” said Patrick Crakes, a former Fox Sports senior vice president who now advises conferences and TV networks through his consulting firm. “There are some schools that can’t play in the Big Ten, that the Big Ten isn’t going to add them ever because of that. That’s really important.”

Coastal Carolina president Michael Benson has published articles on the subject and has written a biography of Daniel Coit Gilman, a founding member of the Association of American Universities. While not privy to the presidential deliberations inside a power-conference meeting, he said he firmly believes that Association of American Universities membership is “a very strong consideration” when schools are considered for expansion.

“I was at Southern Utah when we finally got our 25-year wish of getting into the Big Sky Conference,” Benson said. “We had wanted forever to be in that conference, and my line was, ‘Getting into a conference is like getting married. You have to be asked.’

“All you can do is make yourself better, improve your academic reputation. And I would argue that … the imprimatur of academic success, the gold standard for any research university, is the(Association of American Universities). When I saw the list, I was like, ‘Good for USF. That’s fantastic.’ "

USF became only the second public school in Florida to be invited to the 71-member association of top-tier research institutions, joining the University of Florida. Invitations are extended based on many factors, including graduation rates, research activity, faculty excellence and the number of low-income students receiving federal Pell grants.

Meantime, college football remains in a staggering state of flux. While the Pac-12′s future remains in limbo until that league signs a new media-rights deal, the Big 12 has said it’s receptive to adding more teams. If the Big Ten ponders a move into the Florida market, consider: Each of its members except Nebraska is a member of the Association of American Universities. That includes incoming members USC and UCLA.

“Obviously, there’s still a lot of athletic things that we have to meet,” USF athletic director Michael Kelly said. “But when presidents and conferences evaluate institutions, there’s a lot of things to consider. And now that you’ve reached this unique status, elite academic status, it certainly gets the attention of any president in the country that would be voting on (expansion).”

Stay updated on Tampa Bay’s sports scene

Stay updated on Tampa Bay’s sports scene

Subscribe to our free Sports Today newsletter

We’ll send you news and analysis on the Bucs, Lightning, Rays and Florida’s college football teams every day.

You’re all signed up!

Want more of our free, weekly newsletters in your inbox? Let’s get started.

Explore all your options

Grabbing the presidents’ attention is one thing. Sustaining it is another.

That’s where on-field success and ongoing infrastructure progress come into play. The Bulls haven’t had a winning football season since 2018 and have had one winning season in men’s basketball since 2012. Shore up those areas, break ground on an on-campus football stadium, and the Bulls’ portfolio, already shimmering academically, elicits a real luster.

“I do think it comes down to building a competent program,” Crakes said. “If (USF) can do that, they stand a really good chance of making it over the (expansion) wall. And they’ve got time to do that. I don’t expect that to happen tomorrow.”

Times staff writer Matt Baker contributed to this report. Contact Joey Knight at jknight@tampabay.com. Follow @TBTimes_Bulls.

• • •

Sign up for the Sports Today newsletter to get daily updates on the Bucs, Rays, Lightning and college football across Florida.

Never miss out on the latest with your favorite Tampa Bay sports teams. Follow our coverage on Twitter and Facebook.