1. Sports

NCAA's new targeting rule sparks college football debate

Notre Dame’s Zeke Motta, right, hits Navy’s Trey Miller with a tackling technique that could lead to an ejection this season.
Published Jul. 3, 2013

Ask college football coaches about safety concerns and most would say making the game safer for players is a top priority, even if it means drastically changing some long-standing rules.

"I think player safety is really important to our game right now," Alabama coach Nick Saban said. "And I think any rules that we can implement in our game that's going to protect players are good rules."

In theory.

The practical applications? Well, sometimes, that's another story.

Which is why the NCAA's new targeting rule and the potential penalty it carries has gotten so much attention of late, and was among the hottest topics at the recent SEC spring meetings.

The rule, passed by the NCAA Playing Rules Oversight Panel in the spring, allows officials to eject players who target and hit defenseless players above the shoulders. It will be implemented this season.

The goal is to eliminate head-to-head hits that could seriously endanger players. The rule calls for immediate ejection if the lead field official determines a player "targeted" a defenseless player above the shoulders. The official's call is final unless the replay official overrules it.

That gray area — and how it could impact a game and possibly a team's championship hopes — has some coaches worried about the rule's impact.

"It's a little severe right now," South Carolina coach Steve Spurrier said. "Any hit to the head and the guy could be ejected and miss the next half, or if he does it in the first half, he'll miss the second half. If it's intentional or somebody really trying to hurt somebody, I can see that. But sometimes, with two guys going for the ball, you're going to have some helmet-to-helmet stuff."

First-year Arkansas coach Bret Bielema has been a member of the NCAA Player Safety Committee the past two seasons, and he said the group spent "a lot of time" discussing the best ways to make the game more player-safety driven without severely altering it. The helmet rule was a big part of those discussions.

"I know some people aren't happy, but I felt overall we had a huge, huge impact on the game in modifying the targeting (rule)," Bielema said. "We saw some examples from very, very potentially life-changing plays. You can change a young man's life in a split second, so we're trying to deter players from leading with their heads. To take that initiative and make it be immediate and have a player expelled from the game was a huge step, but I think that was the (right thing). Players don't understand anything except for the loss of playing time."

The SEC was already moving in that direction. Last season, SEC commissioner Mike Slive suspended two players for above-the-shoulder hits on defenseless opponents.

Florida coach Will Muschamp said he doesn't have a problem with the ejection part of the rule because it's reviewable, but he would like to see the rule include blocking below the waist.

"You want to talk about player safety? Let's talk about ACLs and the injuries that occur with blocking below the waist if you want to continue to talk about player safety," Muschamp said.

Bielema said it's imperative that coaches review the way they teach players how to tackle, particularly if they are instructing players to lead with their heads. He said the rule isn't meant to be punitive. It's meant to protect.

"I don't know if there's going to be a lot of ejections, but what's going to happen is you're going to change player behavior, which is the ultimate goal," Bielema said. "I don't think anybody made the rule with the objective, let's kick people out of the game. What we're trying to do is change the behavior and the way people play the game and target with their head. That's the ultimate goal."

Antonya English can be reached at


  1. Alabama sive lineman Alex Leatherwood (70) checks on quarterback Tua Tagovailoa (13) after he was injured in the first half of an NCAA college football game against Mississippi State in Starkville, Miss., Saturday, Nov. 16, 2019. Alabama won 38-7. (AP Photo/Rogelio V. Solis) ROGELIO V. SOLIS  |  AP
    The Florida Gators moved back into Matt Baker’s top 10 this week.
  2. Tampa Bay Buccaneers wide receiver Mike Evans (13) makes a pass reception in Cardinals territory during the first quarter of the game between the Tampa Bay Buccaneers and the Arizona Cardinals on Sunday, November 10, 2019, at Raymond James Stadium in Tampa. DOUGLAS R. CLIFFORD  |  Tampa Bay Times
    Encina’s Early Read: Bucs made adjustments since last New Orleans game, and it’s led to some big receiving days for Mike Evans.
  3. Earlier today• Lightning
    The Lightning hosted 5,000 middle school students at Friday's practice. Courtesy of Everfi
    Slap Shots: Plus, thoughts on the Hockey Hall of Fame, a scary moment in Calgary and Military Appreciation Night.
  4. Northside Christian did not have an answer for Seffner Christian receiver Michael Trigg, who burned the Mustangs for five touchdowns in the teams’ Class 2A, Region 3 semifinal. SCOTT PURKS  |  Special to the Times
    Sunday Morning Quarterback: Rematch revenge, prolific offensive outings, road warriors and more from the region semifinals.
  5. Free agent quarterback Colin Kaepernick participates in a workout for NFL football scouts and media, Saturday, Nov. 16, 2019, in Riverdale, Ga. TODD KIRKLAND  |  AP
    The Bucs aren’t among the teams reported to have attended after a late venue change as the QB and NFL trade accusations.
  6. USF Bulls place kicker Spencer Shrader (32) misses the field goal to take the lead over the Cincinnati Bearcats during the fourth quarter at Raymond James Stadium on Saturday. OCTAVIO JONES  |  Times
    The Bulls miss four field goals of their own in a 20-17 loss.
  7. Tampa Bay Lightning center Steven Stamkos (91) celebrates with the bench after his goal against the Winnipeg Jets during the third period of an NHL hockey game Saturday, Nov. 16, 2019, in Tampa, Fla. CHRIS O'MEARA  |  AP
    Victor Hedman calls the milestone “an unreal accomplishment by an unreal player.”
  8. USF running back Jordan Cronkrite, center, is tackled by Cincinnati linebacker Joel Dublanko during the second quarter at Raymond James Stadium in Tampa on Saturday night. OCTAVIO JONES  |  Times
    Journal: The University of Florida transfer now is among USF’s top 10 rushers of all time.
  9. Bucs host the Saints and more sports on the air.
  10. Tampa Bay Lightning left wing Pat Maroon (14) is taken down by Winnipeg Jets defenseman Dmitry Kulikov (7) as he tries to wrap the puck past goaltender Connor Hellebuyck (37) during the second period Saturday in Tampa. CHRIS O'MEARA  |  AP
    They lose to the Winnipeg Jets after a power-play goal scored due to a failed challenge.