Tuesday, September 18, 2018
FSU Seminoles

Matt Baker’s AP Top 25 ballot: A new No. 1 team, and what to do with Miami and UCF

Preseason rankings are hard, because no one has done anything.

Rankings after Week 1 might be harder, because some teams have earned very good wins while others ain't played nobody.

So here's the compromise I came up with for my AP Top 25 ballot: I put extra, obvious emphasis on teams that beat quality opponents (like Auburn over Washington) while trying not to reward or punish teams that beat awful Week 1 competition (UCF over UConn, Georgia over Austin Peay, and so on).

Note how I said trying not to reward or punish anyone. There were exceptions, starting at the top. Clemson did what it was supposed to against Furman. But Alabama was more impressive against a much better team, which is why the Crimson Tide jumped Clemson for the top spot on my ballot. Georgia jumped up to third because of some Wisconsin suspensions that happened after I had to submit my preseason ballot.

Auburn had the week's best win and rose two spots on my ballot to sixth. I could have justified putting the Tigers higher but, again, didn't want to dump the teams ahead of Auburn yet. By next week, we'll have a larger sample size to dump my preseason expectations.

The big mover was LSU, which went from unranked to 15th. Miami stayed on my ballot but fell to 22nd. I'm not sure yet whether LSU is that good, or Miami is that bad, or somewhere in the middle (which would be my guess). We'll see. In the meantime, the Hurricanes stayed as the top team in the state on my ballot, two spots ahead of UCF (again, not reading too much into beating awful UConn).

Florida State, obviously, dropped out after its worst home loss in a decade. The Hokies jumped from unranked to No. 17.

Texas and Florida Atlantic also dropped off my ballot. Northwestern joined Virginia Tech and LSU as newcomers to my rankings.

Here's the AP Top 25 ballot I submitted Tuesday morning:

1.  Alabama (1-0)

2. Clemson (1-0)

3. Georgia (1-0)

4. Wisconsin (1-0)

5. Ohio State (1-0)

6. Auburn (1-0)

7. Oklahoma (1-0)

8. Notre Dame (1-0)

9. Washington (0-1)

10. Stanford (1-0)

11. West Virginia (1-0)

12. Penn State (1-0)

13.  Mississippi State (1-0)

14. TCU (1-0)

15. LSU (1-0)

16. Boise State (1-0)

17. Virginia Tech (1-0)

18. USC (1-0)

19. Michigan (0-1)

20. Michigan State (1-0)

21. South Carolina (1-0)

22. Miami (0-1)

23. Oregon (1-0)

24. UCF (1-0)

25. Northwestern (1-0)

Comments
Willie Taggart inherited a rough offensive line situation that has gotten even worse

Willie Taggart inherited a rough offensive line situation that has gotten even worse

Take your pick of ugly stats or stories about how bad Florida State's offensive line is. Like how only three teams in the nation have allowed more tackles for a loss than FSU (27). Or how one of the most talented running back units in the country ran...
Published: 09/17/18
Willie Taggart can save himself against Syracuse (again) and more state tidbits

Willie Taggart can save himself against Syracuse (again) and more state tidbits

Willie Taggart saved his career three years ago against Syracuse.Perhaps another game against the Orange will salvage his first season at Florida State.His Seminoles have struggled through a 1-1 start that includes a 21-point blowout loss to Virginia...
Published: 09/14/18
Syracuse’s Dino Babers: FSU offense ‘ready to explode on somebody’

Syracuse’s Dino Babers: FSU offense ‘ready to explode on somebody’

Even though Florida State has struggled in the first two games of the Willie Taggart era, Syracuse coach Dino Babers is concerned about what he'll be facing Saturday."Obviously Willie is known for his offense," Babers said Wednesday on the ACC coache...
Published: 09/12/18
From Bandits to Seminoles, Burt Reynolds left a rich Tampa sports legacy

From Bandits to Seminoles, Burt Reynolds left a rich Tampa sports legacy

Although Burt Reynolds is sure to be remembered on a national scale as one of acting’s leading men in the 1970s, longtime residents will surely remember him for his ties to sports — both in Tampa and across the state.Reynolds, who died Thursday at ag...
Published: 09/07/18
Jimbo Fisher vs. Dabo Swinney (again) and more college football nuggets

Jimbo Fisher vs. Dabo Swinney (again) and more college football nuggets

It's all about the coaches when Clemson's Dabo Swinney and former FSU coach Jimbo Fisher meet for the ninth time:Clemson coach Dabo SwinneyHead-to-head wins: 4National titles: 1BCS/College Football Playoff appearances: 3Conference titles: 4Winning pe...
Published: 09/07/18
Willie Taggart skeptical of Virginia Tech’s ‘injuries’

Willie Taggart skeptical of Virginia Tech’s ‘injuries’

While the Willie Taggart honeymoon may be over — or at least winding down — in Tallahassee, FSU's new coach still has fans rallying around him in one regard.Many undoubtedly share his skepticism over Virginia Tech's plethora of ...
Published: 09/05/18
Sports Day Tampa Bay podcast: What does FSU’s loss say about Willie Taggart’s readiness?

Sports Day Tampa Bay podcast: What does FSU’s loss say about Willie Taggart’s readiness?

Times sports columnist Tom Jones joins Rick Stroud on today's episode to discuss Florida State's  loss to Virginia Tech. What does it say about Seminoles head coach Willie Taggart's readiness for the job?Plus, which Florida school did best ...
Published: 09/05/18
A tepid Taggart debut may mean a long season ahead for FSU

A tepid Taggart debut may mean a long season ahead for FSU

TALLAHASSEE — A Florida fan could not have drawn it up any better.The Willie Taggart Era has begun at Florida State. Whether it is the Willie Taggart Error is the question at hand."Tough loss," Taggart said late Monday night. "Not what any of u...
Published: 09/04/18
Matt Baker’s AP Top 25 ballot: A new No. 1 team, and what to do with Miami and UCF

Matt Baker’s AP Top 25 ballot: A new No. 1 team, and what to do with Miami and UCF

Preseason rankings are hard, because no one has done anything.Rankings after Week 1 might be harder, because some teams have earned very good wins while others ain't played nobody.So here's the compromise I came up with for my AP Top 25 ballot: I put...
Published: 09/04/18
Sports Day Tampa Bay podcast: Willie Taggart’s FSU debut doesn’t go as planned

Sports Day Tampa Bay podcast: Willie Taggart’s FSU debut doesn’t go as planned

College football is back, but Florida State and Miami have rough starts as Willie Taggart's debut in Tallahassee doesn't go as planned.Plus, the Bucs cut their roster to 53 and hold their first practice in over four years without Jameis Win...
Published: 09/04/18