1. Sports
  2. /
  3. Gators

Georgia football’s rise comes at the expense of Florida, in more ways than one

Georgia has 44 prep coaches who make six figures. That’s attracting top coaches, who are helping innate talent develop more.
Georgia quarterback Jake Fromm is part of the state's growth as a football power. (Times, 2018)
Published Aug. 19

When the preseason Associated Press top 25 poll comes out Monday with Kirby Smart’s Bulldogs in the top five, it will be the latest sign of Georgia’s status as a national football power.

Not only for the championship contender in Athens but for a booming Peach State prep scene.

RELATED: Matt Baker’s preseason AP Top 25: Florida Gators in top 10, UCF cracks the list

Georgia has solidified itself behind Florida, Texas and California as the nation’s clear No. 4 state in producing top-tier talent. As that state’s undisputed top Dawg, Smart’s team is the primary beneficiary.

“It's certainly been an impact on our program,” Smart said.

And that impact is coming at the expense of Florida — in more ways than one.

• • •

Georgia’s status as a football hotbed isn’t new. Fran Tarkenton, Herschel Walker and Charlie Ward all played high school ball there.

But the Peach State has ramped up its supply of talent, beyond recent superstars like Deshaun Watson, Trevor Lawrence, Nick Chubb and Roquan Smith.

• Fifteen years ago, Georgia produced 80-100 Division I-A recruits in a class, said Rusty Mansell, a Georgia-based recruiting analyst for 247 Sports. Now that number exceeds 250.

• In 2006, Rivals’ top 250 national recruits included 14 players from Georgia. The state had 27 such players in ’19 with another 27 in this next class.

• In 2017, Georgia high schools produced more NFL draft picks (29) than any other state. Over the last five years, only Florida (165), Texas (137) and California (128) have had more players drafted than Georgia (99).

Former Georgia star running back Nick Chubb is among the recent homegrown talent to play for the Bulldogs. (MONICA HERNDON | Times)

Many factors have played into Georgia’s rise. A booming population (from 6.5 million in 1990 to 10.5 million last year). A high school football participation rate that’s relatively steady compared to the nationwide decline.

And, most importantly, money.

At least 44 Georgia public high school coaches make more than $100,000 a year, according to a report this spring by First Coast News. That’s double the number from three years ago and enough to lure some of the top prep minds in the country to the pressure-packed environment.

“Anytime a job in Georgia comes open, my phone blows up from other states…” Mansell said. “Everybody wants to get into Georgia because of that pay and what they’re able to do with their community and the investments they make.”

That includes coaches from Florida.

At least a dozen of those 44 six-figure coaches came from the Sunshine State, according to First Coast News. XOS Digital’s Dwight Thomas counts almost 250 Florida prep coaches who have defected for Georgia in the two-plus decades he’s been scouting the Southeast.

“We lose more coaches coming to Georgia than anybody,” former Armwood High coach Sean Callahan said.

Callahan should know; he could have been one of them.

Powerhouse Valdosta High was among the Georgia schools who reached out to him after he led the Hawks to Class 4A state titles in 2003-04. Callahan didn’t go — he stayed at Armwood until his 2017 retirement — but said there was “a lot of money on the table.”

Valdosta’s coach earns a $35,753 coaching supplement, according to First Coast News. That’s almost 10 times last year’s head coaching stipend in Hillsborough County ($3,736).

Georgia is also investing more in infrastructure — a handful of high schools have indoor practice facilities — and educator salaries. The average teacher in Georgia made $56,329 during the 2017-18 school year, according to National Education Association. That’s the largest figure in the Southeast and $8,000 more than Florida, where most coaches also balance teaching loads.

Those things don’t create talent on their own, but they attract better coaches. Better coaches mean better coaching, which helps hone a prospect’s natural ability.

That leads to a maxim Mansell remembers hearing from a college coach: Florida players might have more raw speed and athleticism, but Georgia players are generally ready to contribute earlier.

RELATED: Georgia-Florida is the state’s top game in 2019

“Yes, Florida has always had very good talent,” Callahan said, “but you kind of get what you pay for, too.”

• • •

The Bulldogs aren’t the only beneficiary of their state’s increase in talent. Clemson has won two of the last three national titles thanks to Watson and Lawrence.

But the Bulldogs are capitalizing on it as much as anyone, widening the gap between themselves and rival Florida in the process.

Although Smart recruits nationally more than his predecessor (Mark Richt) did, Smart signed 57 homegrown players over his four consecutive top-six recruiting classes. The 89 Georgia natives on the Bulldogs’ roster includes seven preseason all-SEC honorees (including quarterback Jake Fromm and offensive tackle Andrew Thomas) and at least seven other potential starters for the SEC East favorites.

Thanks in part to in-state talent, Georgia's Kirby Smart has beaten Florida each of the last two years, by a combined 54 points. (MONICA HERNDON | Times)

The Bulldogs are cashing in on the state’s rise because they have little internal competition. While Florida, Texas and California all have at least three major programs battling for in-state recruits, Georgia’s only other Power Five team is the rebuilding Georgia Tech. That means a lot of the state’s blossoming prospects dream of wearing red and black.

“Coming from the state of Georgia, I always wanted to play for the Dawgs,” Fromm said.

Fromm embodies the growth of Georgia as a program and football state.

RELATED: Georgia’s Jake Fromm ready to do more for national title contenders

He had innate talent as a top-50 national recruit at Houston County High, about 30 miles south of Macon. He had quality coaches developing that ability to prepare him to start as a true freshman. He turned down offers from Alabama and elsewhere to play for the teams he grew up watching.

And now he and his fellow Georgia-bred teammates are turning their home-state program into a power that can compete with anybody — especially their rival to the south.


  1. In this Jan. 2, 2017, file photo, Florida Gators coach Jim McElwain looks at the action on the field in the first half against Iowa in the Outback Bowl. Times
    Coaches hired early in the 2017-18 carousel are 40-38. Coaches hired late: 39-52.
  2. Florida Gators quarterback Kyle Trask runs the ball in for a touchdown during the third quarter against Charleston Southern last season. MONICA HERNDON  |  Tampa Bay Times
    If Kyle Trask gets the first snap, it will be his first start since he was a freshman in high school.
  3. Notre Dame running back Tony Jones Jr. (6) runs through a hole in the line during the first half against Louisville on Sept. 2. TIMOTHY D. EASLEY  |  AP
    More national college football: Jimbo Fisher, meanwhile, should be hyper focused on his quarterback, who hasn’t looked all that spiffy this season. Plus staff predictions.
  4. Tim Tebow. [Associated Press)] Associated Press
    Sports Day Tampa Bay podcast: Tom Jones and Rick Stroud debate Tebow, Dickie V, the first-place Bucs and the Rays playoff chase
  5. Notre Dame defensive lineman Jonathan Bonner (55) celebrates a sack of Georgia quarterback Jake Fromm (11) during the second half of 2017 game. Georgia defeated Notre Dame 20-19. MICHAEL CONROY  |  AP
    Unlike last week, Saturday’s slate is loaded. Sit back and enjoy. Plus: Times staff predictions.
  6. The Bucs will get their first look at rookie Daniel Jones Sunday when he starts for the New York Giants in a 4:25 p.m. game against Tampa Bay at Raymond James Stadium. FRANK VICTORES  |  AP
    Sports Day Tampa Bay podcast: Exploring quarterback changes for the New York Giants, Florida Gators and USF Bulls.
  7. Tennessee head coach Jeremy Pruitt yells to his players in the second half of an NCAA college football game against Brigham Young Saturday, Sept. 7, 2019, in Knoxville, Tenn. (AP Photo/Wade Payne) WADE PAYNE  |  AP
    The Florida Gators’ next opponent is still stuck on Rocky Bottom thanks to bungled coaching searches.
  8. Tim Tebow answers a question during an interview on the set of ESPN's SEC Network in Charlotte, N.C. Associated Press
    Martin Fennelly: His sanctimonious rant against college athletes being paid is out of line
  9. Jim McElwain, now the Central Michigan coach, endured a rocky tenure as the Florida Gators coach from 2015-2017. He brings his Chippewas to the state to play Miami on Saturday. MORRY GASH  |  AP
    Jim McElwain’s Chippewas will play at Miami. If he had recruited that area better, maybe he’d still be leading the Florida Gators.
  10. Quarterback Kyle Trask (11) winds up to pass during the third quarter of the Orange and Blue Debut at Ben Hill Griffin Stadium in Gainesville. TAMPA BAY TIMES
    Could Trask-Jones be the next Chris Leak-Tim Tebow? “We’ll see,” Dan Mullen says.