1. Sports
  2. /
  3. HomeTeam

Academy at the Lakes’ Lexi Kilfoyl named Gatorade state player of the year

The Wildcats softball ace makes history, becoming the area’s first two-time winner of the award.
Academy at the Lakes senior Lexi Kilfoyl fires a pitch during a Class 2A state semifinal in Vero Beach last week. (SCOTT PURKS | Special to the Times)
Published May 30
Updated May 30

Academy at the Lakes pitcher Lexi Kilfoyl solidified her status as perhaps the greatest high school softball player ever from the area after being named the Gatorade state softball player of the year for the second straight season.

The senior, who led the Wildcats to consecutive state titles, is the area’s first two-time winner of the award. Former Chamberlain standout Bianka Bell (2012) and former Palm Harbor University star Dani Hofer (2005) are the only other locals who have won.

Kilfoyl also becomes just the third two-time winner from the state, joining Dunnellon’s Kasey Fagan (2009-10) and Spruce Creek’s Kelsi Dunne (2006-07).

RELATED: Spotlight always finds Academy at the Lakes ace Lexi Kilfoyl

Ranked as the nation’s top pitcher in the 2019 class, Kilfoyl was key to AATL defending its title. The Alabama-bound ace overcame a shoulder injury and went 12-1 this season with a 0.48 ERA and had 134 strikeouts in 72 ⅔ innings. She was just as strong at the plate, hitting .562 with 12 homers and 37 RBIs.

In the 2A state championship game, Kilfoyl threw a six-inning no-hitter and finished with 10 strikeouts. She also had the winning hit, a solo home run in the first inning of the Wildcats’ 11-0 victory over Mount Dora Christian. Kilfoyl finished her career on a 37 ⅔-inning scoreless streak.

RELATED: Academy at the Lakes dominates en route to title repeat

Kilfoyl also posted impressive numbers in the classroom. She has a 3.85 GPA and is a member of the Mu Alpha Theta honor society in math. She also volunteers for community beautification projects.

As the state player of the year, Kilfoyl can select a national or local youth sports organization to receive a $1,000 grant as part of the Gatorade Play It Forward program. She also will have the opportunity for an additional $10,000 grant by writing an essay in support of the organization she chooses.


  1. Armwood's Cam'ron Ransom has thrown for 1,224 yards and 14 touchdowns this season and is also a threat to run. Times
    The Hawks quarterback faces Lakeland, the school he envisioned attending, in the Class 7A region final.
  2. Admiral Farragut's Ty Vongvenekeo rotates in under center with Tonio Shavers. Times
    Nine area teams are still alive and looking for state berths.
  3. Seffner Christian's Michael Trigg is tied for the state lead in receiving touchdowns with 15, while his overall yards (1,054) rank among the top 10. LUIS SANTANA  |  Times
    The two-sport star, who led the Crusaders to the state final in boys hoops, is trying to do the same in football.
  4. On a team full of playmakers, TJ Tampa makes the most of his limited time in the spotlight, averaging 20 yards per catch. He has 25 receptions for 501 yards and nine touchdowns. DIRK SHADD  |  Times
    When you boast the receiving, and basketball, skills that this Iowa State commit does, fitting in isn’t really an issue.
  5. Tampa Catholic coach Jeris McIntyre has the Crusaders heading in the right direction, which includes an appearance in a Class 4A region final against Lakewood on Friday night. SCOTT PURKS  |  Special to the Times
    The Crusaders, who have reached the region finals, are certainly practicing what coach Jeris McIntyre preaches.
  6. Lake Wales running back Johnny Richardson races away from Sebring defender Ethan McMillan during a Class 5A region playoff game in Lake Wales on Nov. 8. PIERRE DUCHARME  |  The Ledger
    Armwood, Gaither and Jesuit may have their hands full on Friday night.
  7. USF placekicker Spencer Shrader (32) watches his missed field goal against the Cincinnati Bearcats during the fourth quarter at Raymond James Stadium on Saturday. OCTAVIO JONES  |  Times
    The Bulls have expressed support for the Newsome High alumnus since his four missed field goals Saturday.
  8. Tampa Bay Tech's Janiah Barker was among the state's top freshmen last season. Can she lead the Titans to a second straight state title? Times
    We spotlight 26 of the area’s talented players as the 2019-20 season gets underway.
  9. There's no doubt Kobe Knox and Tampa Catholic have one of the toughest boys basketball schedules in the state ... possibly the nation. SCOTT PURKS  |  Special to the Times
    The contenders, like the Tampa Catholic boys and defending state champ Tampa Bay Tech girls, aren’t leaving their fates to just district matchups.
  10. Northside Christian did not have an answer for Seffner Christian receiver Michael Trigg, who burned the Mustangs for five touchdowns in the teams’ Class 2A, Region 3 semifinal. SCOTT PURKS  |  Special to the Times
    Sunday Morning Quarterback: Rematch revenge, prolific offensive outings, road warriors and more from the region semifinals.