1. Sports
  2. /
  3. HomeTeam

Mitchell High’s Ezra Brennan comes into his own under center

The learning curve isn’t too steep for the first-year Mustangs starter, whose unflappable nature can be traced to the other sport he excels in — baseball.
Mitchell quarterback Ezra Brennan has already surpassed 2,000 yards passing this season. [DOUGLAS R. CLIFFORD  |  Times]
Mitchell quarterback Ezra Brennan has already surpassed 2,000 yards passing this season. [DOUGLAS R. CLIFFORD | Times]
Published Nov. 13

TRINITY — The sample size wasn’t optimal. Mitchell High had a new starting quarterback, and although circumstantial evidence favored Ezra Brennan, the empirical kind was lacking.

“We went into the first game of the season, and Ezra had played two drives — in the spring game,” recalled Mustangs coach Andy Schmitz. “That was the extent of his experience with our offense, with our receivers … with all that stuff.”

Albeit with a little more on-the-fly knowledge than Schmitz might prefer, Brennan has picked up the system pretty well. With the junior at the controls, Mitchell (10-1) rolled through the regular season and first round of the playoffs, and hosts Bradenton Manatee Friday night in a Class 7A, Region 3 semifinal.

Mitchell, used to reaching the second round, is still seeking a first-ever trip to the region finals. With Brennan at the controls, and a solid ball-hawking defense that is among the nation’s leaders in interceptions, the Mustangs appear to have a good shot.

Brennan is a transfer from Alonso but no stranger to Mitchell. His cousin, Jake Mattos, was the Mustangs’ quarterback and baseball team’s ace pitcher two years ago.

Related: MORE PREP FOOTBALL: Milestone victories abound in first round of high school playoffs

Schmitz wasn’t aware of that at first.

“Honestly, I didn’t know much about (Brennan) at all,” he said. “After he enrolled I found that he was Jake’s cousin, so that kinda brought a little bit of familiarity. Through Jake, he knew some of our kids already, so that made our transition a little easier.”

It just so happens that Brennan played quarterback at Alonso and like his cousin is a baseball player. That both helped and hurt the situation.

“I’ve definitely played at a high level of baseball, on some top teams, and it’s definitely prepared me for pressure situations,” Brennan said before Monday’s practice. “And it helps going from one sport to the other, not being so burned out.”

But Mitchell’s success in the sport, a 25-1 regular season, kept Brennan out of spring football for the most part. Though he got in some work with summer 7-on-7 competition Brennan’s “real” debut as Mustang signal caller was later than normal.

Mitchell's Rob Graham is part of a balanced receiving game, but he does have the most receptions on the team with 34. [DOUGLAS R. CLIFFORD | Times]

The preseason contest with Weeki Wachee was washed out, not helping matters.

“It really was a work in progress,” Schmitz said. “And I think that you see that, as the season has gone on, he’s significantly better now. I really like multisport kids. And with baseball I feel like he’s used to being in pressure situations. When you’re up to bat and it’s a crucial moment, it’s just you out there. I really think that stuff helps.”

With 188 yards and two touchdowns in last week’s 33-14 win over visiting Seminole Ridge, Brennan went over the 2,000-yard mark for the season. His touchdown-to-interception ratio is an outstanding 28:5 (compared to 7:10 last year at Alonso).

Fourteen of his touchdowns came in a sizzling four-game stretch that followed the Mustangs’ lone loss. Having a strong group of receivers, and a 1,260-yard rusher in senior Tyler Williams, aids the cause.

“I’ve just been letting my team help me out,” he said. “Make easy throws when they’re there, and once the big shot opens up, take it. Our balance helps a lot. All the eyes are on Tyler, and that opens up the passing game, and once it’s open, we go back to the running game.”

Related: RELATED: One box checked for Mitchell, now on to the next

None of the receivers have eye-popping numbers, but Schmitz said that’s been a key as opponents can’t just focus on locking down one player. Jonathan Fairbank boasts a team-leading 10 touchdowns on just 30 receptions, with Ronnie Fiumara producing a touchdown (six) almost every-other catch (14). Rob Graham leads in receptions with 34; Ethan Phelps and Cole Nerad have chipped in with 10 grabs each.

Everyone will have to be on their game against Manatee.

“Our kids are a very confident group,” Schmitz said. “They know who Manatee is, the type of athletes they have, their history. But our kids just want to go out and play. If our kids were playing the Patriots, they would somehow find a way watching film to say we can beat them.”

He of course means New England, but most recently Manatee rolled past the Pinellas Park version, which happens to be the lone team to defeat Mitchell.

But like his coach said, the Mustangs are confident, and for Brennan, most importantly at home.

“For sure. The atmosphere’s the best here. It’s loud, the student section always has our back,” Brennan said. “Friday should be packed, especially us bring the only Pasco County team left, I think other people will come out. Should be very interesting.”

High school football region semifinals

All games 7:30 p.m. Friday.

Class 2A, Region 3

• No. 3 Seffner Christian at No. 2 Northside Christian

• No. 4 Admiral Farragut at No. 1 Cambridge Christian

Class 3A, Region 3

• No. 5 Clearwater Central Catholic at No. 1 Berkeley Prep

Class 4A, Region 3

• No. 4 Clewiston at No. 1 Lakewood

• No. 3 Tampa Catholic at No. 2 Delray Beach American Heritage

Class 5A, Region 3

• No. 8 Chamberlain at No. 4 Jesuit

Class 5A, Region 2

• No. 4 Nature Coast at No. 1 Orlando Jones

Class 6A, Region 2

• No. 5 Clearwater at No. 1 Gaither

• No. 3 Lake Minneola at No. 2 Largo

Class 7A, Region 3

• No. 3 Manatee at No. 2 Mitchell

Class 7A, Region 2

• No. 5 Bloomingdale at No. 1 Armwood

• No. 6 Tampa Bay Tech at No. 2 Lakeland

Class 8A, Region 2

• No. 4 Steinbrenner at

No. 1 Sarasota Riverview


  1. Tampa Bay Tech sophomores Amiya Evans, second from right, and Janiah Barker, right, could help lead the Titans to one of the highest national rankings of any Tampa Bay area team in history in the 2019-20 season [SCOTT PURKS  |  Special to the Times]
    Dynamic duo Janiah Barker and Amiya Evans met as eighth-graders and vowed to never play apart in high school. They kept that vow.
  2. Senior football players in Pinellas County took to the gridiron for their final prep game Wednesday night. [DIRK SHADD  |  Tampa Bay Times]
    Of the past 15 meetings, the South has been on the losing end 13 times.
  3. In this file photo, Lakewood High School defensive lineman Tre'von Riggins (98) takes a moment during a spring football practice last April. [DIRK SHADD  |  Times]
    Measures to prevent heatstroke deaths were among the key items in a bill that unanimously passed its first committee on Wednesday.
  4. A little more than a month into the season, Nature Coast Tech sophomore Kennedy Weissman leads the state in scoring with 41 goals and 92 points, almost double the totals of the next closest player. [SCOTT PURKS  |  Special to the Times]
    The sophomore has a whopping 41 goals so far this season, easily tops of any player in Florida.
  5. Largo's Julia Violante (6), center, gets a hug from teammate Sarai Faulkner (17), right, while joining Asti Luff (23), left, and McKenzie Emery (14) at midfield moments after scoring her second goal of the night (2-0) against St. Petersburg on Monday. [DOUGLAS R. CLIFFORD  |  TImes]
    The University of Florida commit is having a banner season on the pitch, but is missing her biggest fan.
  6. Hezekiah B. Walters, 14, was a member of Men of Vision, a local non-profit for teens. He collapsed while participating in football conditioning drills at Middleton High School during the summer. [MEN OF VISION  |  Special to the Times]
    The death of Middleton High’s Hezekiah B. Walters during summer conditioning helps spark a bill that seeks better protection for players at practices and games.
  7. East Lake and rival St. Petersburg squared off Tuesday night, this time as non-district foes. [DIRK SHADD  |  Tampa Bay Times]
    The Eagles’ 67-30 victory over the Green Devils is their fourth straight in the series since late last season.
  8. Springstead guard Unique Torain makes a nifty assist during a victory at Nature Coast on Tuesday night. [SCOTT PURKS  |  Special to the Times]
    The Eagles are led by Unique Torain’s 18 points and unselfish play.
  9. Clearwater wide receiver Keedrik Murray (5) catches the ball for a touchdown during the first quarter at Gaither High on Nov. 15. [OCTAVIO JONES  |  Times]
    The 25th edition of the game will be held at Clearwater High.
  10. Clemson co-offensive coordinator Jeff Scott talks with receivers Mike Williams (7) and Artavis Scott (3) during a 2016 game at FSU. Scott was named USF's coach Monday. [DAVID GROOMS/CAL SPORT MEDIA  |]
    Though not the bay area’s primary recruiter for Clemson, Scott’s fingerprints are all over the region.