1. Sports
  2. /
  3. Lightning

One year later, has Ryan McDonagh made you a believer?

At last year’s trade deadline, there was talk the Lightning might acquire star defenseman Erik Karlsson. Instead, Tampa Bay traded for Ryan McDonagh.
The Lightning acquired defenseman Ryan McDonagh (27) in a Feb. 26, 2018 deal that also brought forward J.T. Miller to Tampa Bay for Vladimir Namestnikov, two prospects and two draft picks. DIRK SHADD | Times
Published Feb. 11

TAMPA — What did you want?

When the Lightning went looking for a defenseman at the trade deadline last year, did you want flash? Sizzle? A big name? Did you want two-time Norris Trophy winner Erik Karlsson?

Because Tampa Bay got something else.

A smaller headline, yes. A lesser player, certainly. But, as we approach the one-year anniversary of Ryan McDonagh’s arrival in Tampa Bay you could argue the Lightning also got a more natural fit.

Offense has not been a problem around here for a while. Tampa Bay was the NHL’s top-scoring team last year and has kicked it up a notch this season. At the current pace, the Lightning will blow past last season’s franchise record for goals in a season.

So Karlsson’s offensive skills would have been a clear upgrade, but in some ways a bit of a luxury. What the Lightning needed then, and now, was a more defensive-minded player. A steadier hand. A guy who competes in the corners and stands firm in front of the net.

What the Lightning needed was a player who looked a lot like Ryan McDonagh.

“For the guys on the bench, when you see Mac go down on one knee and turn his head and take a shot in the back of the shoulder,’’ said Tampa Bay assistant coach Todd Richards, “it’s hard not to go out on the ice on the next shift and, if somebody is going to shoot, to get out of the way of that shot.’’

This is not an argument for McDonagh instead of Karlsson. It’s more of a snapshot in time. The Lightning needed a defenseman who could routinely take on an opponent’s top lines and stars.

Victor Hedman was already playing the role of a puck-moving defenseman for Tampa Bay, and was eating up an appropriate amount of space under the salary cap. With Karlsson scheduled to be a free agent this summer, the Lightning would have struggled to fit him in on a future payroll, which means he would have essentially been a 15-month loaner had they traded for him last February.

Instead, they got McDonagh, 29, and signed him to a seven-year, $47 million extension.

A year later, the Lightning has improved from 13th to 7th in the NHL in goals-against average and Hedman’s per-game ice time is the lowest it’s been since 2013-14. That bodes well for both the Lightning and Hedman with the possibility of a long postseason ahead.

“We knew what we were getting when we acquired him, and he’s been great for us,’’ Hedman said. “As you say, he’s evened out (our) ice time a little, and he’s going 5-on-5 against the top lines and playing on the (penalty kill) for us. This wasn’t something for a quick run, we wanted him here for a long time.’’

It’s been a few years since McDonagh was making All-Star teams and getting Norris votes but the numbers suggest he’s playing at the same high level he did early in his career with the Rangers.

He leads the Lightning in blocked shots and plus-minus and is tied for third in even-strength assists. Over the past seven seasons, his plus-minus mark of 122 is second in the NHL behind Brad Marchand and just ahead of players such as Patrice Bergeron, Jonathan Toews and Sidney Crosby. If you’re counting from 2014-15, McDonagh actually leads the NHL in plus-minus at 98.

The point is, the Lightning found a player who checked most of the boxes they were looking for last February. The price was high (Vladislav Namestnikov, two prospects and two high draft picks for McDonagh and J.T. Miller) but it’s had a rolling effect on the rest of the roster, including 21-year-old Eric Cernak who has been his most recent partner on the blue line.

“He helps me everywhere, on the ice and off,’’ Cernak said. “Even when I do something bad, he’ll come tell me not to worry about it because we all make mistakes. He trusts me, and that’s important to me.’’

So ask yourself again what you really wanted at the trade deadline last year.

Because a little less might turn out to be a little more.

Read more:

Ryan Callahan returns with a force and flourish

Lightning holding its own in physical games

Jon Cooper, meet Bruce Arians

Contact John Romano at Follow @romano_tbtimes


  1. Tampa Bay Lightning center Mitchell Stephens (67) defends against Carolina Hurricanes defenseman Brett Pesce (22) who challenges in the Tampa Bay zone during the first period of the preseason game on Tuesday, September 17, 2019, between the Tampa Bay Lightning and the Carolina Hurricanes at Amalie Arena in Tampa. DOUGLAS R. CLIFFORD  |  Tampa Bay Times
    There were flashes of promise, like good play from Mitchell Stephens, but not a great showing for Tampa Bay
  2. Tampa Bay Lightning head coach Jon Cooper gives direction during drills on the first day on the ice at the beginning of training camp. DIRK SHADD  |  Times
    In the first four games of the preseason, Lightning coach Jon Cooper wants to see how prospects have developed.
  3. At 23 years old, Tampa Bay forward Brayden Point already has 91 career NHL goals, including 41 last season. Now that his entry level contract has expired, Point is looking for a big payday but the Lightning has salary cap issues. CHRIS O'MEARA | AP Photo CHRIS O'MEARA  |  AP
    John Romano: History says restricted free agents almost always stay put, and there’s too much at stake for Tampa Bay to allow this impasse to go on.
  4. The Tampa Bay Lightning has tapped Cigar City Brewing to bring its Jai Alai, Guayabera, and Florida Cracker beers to Amalie Arena as the team’s official craft beer partner. (Photo via Tampa Bay Lightning) Tampa Bay Lightning
    Cigar City also will move its popular annual Hunahpu’s Beer Festival to Amalie Arena starting next March.
  5. Tampa Bay Lightning center Steven Stamkos (91) smiles as his team has some offensive success after a goal during a scrimmage on the first day on the ice at the beginning of training camp at the Ice Sports Forum on September 13, 2019 in Brandon, FL. DIRK SHADD  |  Times
    Tampa Bay takes on Carolina in their first preseason game.
  6. Tampa Bay Lightning forward Pat Maroon (14) during drills on the first day on the ice at the beginning of training camp at the Ice Sports Forum on September 13, 2019 in Brandon, FL. DIRK SHADD  |  Times
    The veteran left winger, fresh from a championship in St. Louis, prepares to dig in with Tampa Bay
  7. Lightning goaltender Andrei Vasilevskiy signs the jersey of Piper Mattacchione, 7, during the Lightning Fan Fest which featured photo ops and autograph sessions on Sunday. LUIS SANTANA  |  Times
    The team hosted a kids press conference and fans interacted with players at the annual Fan Fest.
  8. Lightning owner Jeff Vinik briefly, on left, said he briefly feels the sting of last year's playoff disappointment. DIRK SHADD  |  Times
    Vinik sees growth of the team brand across the country and still wants an outdoor game in Tampa Bay.
  9. As training camp continues, the Lightning and Brayden Point still have a gap in negotiations. DIRK SHADD  |  Times
    The changing restricted free agent market could force the Tampa Bay to depart from its usual contract dealings.
  10. In this Jan. 31, 2018, file photo, Maple Leafs center Mitch Marner celebrates his goal against the Islanders. With training camps opening this week, Marner was among roughly a dozen prominent restricted free agents who didn't have contracts until he agreed to terms with Toronto on Friday. Still among the unsigned is the Lightning's Brayden Point. FRANK GUNN  |  AP
    The contract could impact the Lightning’s negotiations with holdout restricted free agent Brayden Point.