1. Sports
  2. /
  3. Lightning

Women’s hockey three-on-three could be best part of NHL All-Star Game

Diana C. Nearhos | Women’s hockey is at a crossroads as players try to figure out what kind of professional league they want.
United States' Kendall Coyne skates during the Skills Competition, part of the NHL All-Star weekend, in San Jose, Calif., Friday, Jan. 25, 2019. [BEN MARGOT  |  AP]
United States' Kendall Coyne skates during the Skills Competition, part of the NHL All-Star weekend, in San Jose, Calif., Friday, Jan. 25, 2019. [BEN MARGOT | AP]
Published Jan. 21

The most heated, most fun rivalry in hockey is coming to the NHL. And, no, it’s not Calgary and Edmonton’s Battle of Alberta.

The NHL is bringing 10 women from both the United States and Canada’s national programs to play a 20-minute three-on-three game as part of the All-Star Game skills competition.

The trend started at the 2018 event in Tampa, when members of Team USA, which was training in Wesley Chapel, demonstrated skills events.

Related: Re-live some of Alex Killorn's best rebound goals as he reached 20 goals for the first time

The best moment of last year’s NHL all-star weekend was when Kendall Coyne Schofield took off on a lap of the rink in 14.346 seconds. I’d wager that the best part of this year’s festivities will be the women’s USA-Canada three-on-three.

Three-on-three overtimes are fun for their speed and skill, which is what the women’s game is all about. Add in one of the fiercest rivalries in sports (anyone remember the three brawls leading up to the Sochi Olympics?), and this is going to be fun.

For hockey fans, this is a definite win. For women’s hockey, it’s more complicated though.

Playing a game, even three-on-three, in front of a NHL audience is great for exposure, but there is a larger question around what it does for women’s hockey.

The sport is at something of a crossroads. This year, after the Canadian Women’s Hockey League folded, almost 200 players boycotted the National Women’s Hockey League to create the Professional Women’s Hockey Players Association. The PWHPA has hosted its own games and showcases.

The argument is over what kind of league is best for women’s hockey, and it’s come to a head again over this NHL all-star appearance.

The NWHL pays its players, but not a living wage; most of its players also work other jobs and some fly in just for the weekend games. Some of its players say the PWHPA members could be working toward sponsorships and marketing to grow the league. Others in the sport say they shouldn’t have to.

Related: The Lightning finished a stretch of 13 games in 21 days. Where are they now?

Where is the NHL in all of this? It’s both in the middle and nowhere. Last year, commissioner Gary Bettman said the NHL contributed financially to both leagues but wasn’t going to choose between them.

Much of the PHWPA would like to see the NHL create a women’s league, like the NBA created the WNBA. The other side says the women should run their own league, like the NWHL is trying to do.

It would be great to see the NHL step up as a bigger partner, and it would strengthen their weakly-supported #hockeyisforeveryone campaign. BUT (all caps) the men shouldn’t step in and “solve the problem” for the women.

Women’s hockey needs to pick its direction, then the NHL should figure out how to best support that initiative. Whatever that means, it should be more than just providing exposure once a year.

Contact Diana C. Nearhos at Follow @dianacnearhos.


  1. Trading Martin St. Louis was hard, but the Lightning's return turned out to be even better than they thought at the time.
  2. Colorado Avalanche left wing J.T. Compher, left, flies into Tampa Bay Lightning goaltender Curtis McElhinney while pursuing the puck in the third period of an NHL hockey game Monday, Feb. 17, 2020, in Denver. The Lightning won 4-3 in overtime.
  3. Tampa Bay Lightning right wing Nikita Kucherov, right, drives past Colorado Avalanche center Nathan MacKinnon to score the winning goal in overtime of an NHL hockey game Monday, Feb. 17, 2020, in Denver. The Lightning won 4-3.
  4. New Jersey Devils center Blake Coleman during the second period of a Feb. 8 game in Newark, N.J.
  5. New Jersey Devils center Blake Coleman (20) during warmups before a recent hockey game against the Dallas Stars in Newark, N.J.
  6. Distant Thunder fan Eva Cervenkova fist bumps Nikita Kucherov before the Lightning's game against the Flyers on Saturday.
  7. Members of the men's ice hockey team from the United States pose in front of the Olympic rings during the 2014 Winter Games in Sochi, Russia.
  8. New Jersey Devils' Blake Coleman (20) brings the puck up the ice against the Carolina Hurricanes in Raleigh, N.C., on Friday.
  9. It was that kind of game Saturday night. Philadelphia Flyers defenseman Robert Hagg (8) collides with Tampa Bay Lightning goaltender Andrei Vasilevskiy (88) as defenseman Luke Schenn (2) comes to help out during the third period of Tampa Bay's 5-3 victory. JASON BEHNKEN | AP Photo
  10. Tampa Bay Lightning center Brayden Point (21) handles the puck against Philadelphia Flyers defenseman Travis Sanheim (6) during the second period of an NHL hockey game Saturday, Feb. 15, 2020, in Tampa, Fla.
  11. February 13, 2020: Edmonton Oilers Right Wing Zack Kassian (44) and Tampa Bay Lightning Defenseman Eric Cernak (81)during the NHL game between the Edmonton Oilers and Tampa Bay Lightning at Amalie Arena in Tampa, FL. Brian McWalters/CSM(Credit Image: © Brian Mcwalters/CSM via ZUMA Wire)
  12. Tampa Bay Lightning's Pat Maroon, center, is congratulated by teammates, from left, Luke Schenn, Braydon Coburn, Mitchell Stephens and Cameron Gaunce after scoring against the Edmonton Oilers during the second period of an NHL hockey game Thursday, Feb. 13, 2020, in Tampa, Fla.