1. Sports
  2. /
  3. Rays

Rays take issue with MLB’s non-reversal of replay challenge

They’re not sure how the safe call on Nick Solak in the 11th wasn’t overturned upon review.
Here is the play as shown on video by the official @MLBReplays Twitter account, with Rays 1B Ji-Man Choi making the stretch. [Twitter] [Twitter]
Published Sep. 11
Updated Sep. 11

ARLINGTON, Texas — The Rays had plenty of reason to be happy about Tuesday’s 5-3 11-inning win over the Rangers.

And one seemingly legit reason to be upset.

Specifically, the MLB replay crew’s decision to not overturn what the Rays saw as a blatantly bad call on what would have been the final out of the game. They wanted Matt Duffy throwing out Nick Solak to be turned into what creatively could have been called a replay reversal walkoff.

MORE RAYS: Heredia helps Rays pull out extra-inning win

Instead the crew in New York decided the call “stands” — meaning they didn’t have a definitive view to overturn it — and the Rays had to get one more out for the win.

Several Rays players and staff were grumbling about the call.

"He was clearly out,'' shortstop Willy Adames said. "I was like, What? I don’t know what they were doing.''

Pitcher Pete Fairbanks, who had a good view, offered a complex answer with a simple conclusion.

MORE RAYS: Rays reliever Pete Fairbanks gets a boost from Rangers fans

"That’s not my job to decide,'' Fairbanks said. "I don’t trust the people in New York, I’ll tell you that much. They’re almost as bad as the (NHL) people in Toronto that didn’t call the hand pass from the Sharks against the Blues. I have a distinct distrust of video replay. Maybe that stems from the fact I went to Mizzou, and they’ve gotten screwed more times than you can count.''

Fairbanks said his challenge at that point was to refocus and get the final out, which he did.

This is the second time in recent weeks — the other involving Tommy Pham being initially called out when replays seemed to show he was safe — that the Rays had taken issue with a call not going the way they felt the video showed.


  1. Tim Tebow. [Associated Press)] Associated Press
    Sports Day Tampa Bay podcast: Tom Jones and Rick Stroud debate Tebow, Dickie V, the first-place Bucs and the Rays playoff chase
  2. The Yankees celebrate after defeating the Angels and clinching the AL East on Thursday, Sept. 19, 2019. MARY ALTAFFER  |  AP
    New York wins its first division crown since 2012.
  3. If the Rays end up popping champagne bottles, like they did in 2013 after beating the Texas Rangers 5-2 in an American League wild-card tiebreaker, don't expect the clincher to come at home. TONY GUTIERREZ  |  AP
    Don’t expect a quick clincher as the team enters its final homestand of the regular season.
  4. Pete Alonso may soon join Jose Fernandez (2013), Chris Coghlan (2009), Dwight Gooden (1984) and Lou Piniella (1969) as Tampa Bay area high school products who won a Rookie of the Year Award. Alonso extended his NL rookie record for homers to 49 on Wednesday in Colorado. DAVID ZALUBOWSKI  |  AP
    The Mets rookie from Plant High is on his way to winning NL Rookie of the Year with his 49 homers. Is that the greatest season of a bay area product?
  5. Tampa Bay Rays' Austin Meadows, left, is congratulated by Avisail Garcia after hitting a solo home run during the 11th inning of the team's baseball game against the Los Angeles Dodgers on Wednesday, Sept. 18, 2019, in Los Angeles. The Rays won 8-7. (AP Photo/Mark J. Terrill) MARK J. TERRILL  |  AP
    On Emilio Pagan’s prognosticating prowess, Pete Fairbanks’ colorful celebration, Tommy Pham’s good fortune (and good hitting).
  6. Tampa Bay Rays' Willy Adames, left, scores on a throwing error by Los Angeles Dodgers center fielder Cody Bellinger after a single by Jesus Aguilar, as catcher Will Smith goes after the ball during the sixth inning of a baseball game Wednesday, Sept. 18, 2019, in Los Angeles. (AP Photo/Mark J. Terrill) MARK J. TERRILL  |  AP
    Rays 8, Dodgers 7 (11): A one-out rally in the 9th allows Rays to tie, then a Meadows homer in 11th puts them ahead to stay.
  7. Rays rookie starter Brendan McKay delivers a pitch during the first inning against the Dodgers on Wednesday, Sept. 18, 2019. MARK J. TERRILL  |  AP
    “Super cool” is how he describes the opportunity Wednesday against the Dodgers.
  8. Tampa Bay Rays first baseman Nate Lowe (35) is seen in the dugout during the third inning against Toronto Blue Jays on Saturday, Sept. 07, 2019 at Tropicana Field in St. Petersburg.   ALLIE GOULDING  |  Times
    Lowe make his fourth pro start at third in a critical game for Rays; Brendan McKay is on the mound.
  9. Tampa Bay Rays relief pitcher Colin Poche, shown pitching last month in Houston, has had a tough stretch at times,. (AP Photo/Michael Wyke) MICHAEL WYKE  |  AP
    Rookie relievers, pitching in September for the first time, are high on that list, and it’s quite noticeable when they falter.
  10. Tampa Bay Rays relief pitcher Colin Poche leaves the field after giving up two runs to the Los Angeles Dodgers during the fifth inning of a baseball game in Los Angeles, Tuesday, Sept. 17, 2019. (AP Photo/Chris Carlson) CHRIS CARLSON  |  AP
    Dodgers 7, Rays 5: Snell’s solid return aside, it was a lost night for Rays as rookie relievers Poche and Fairbanks struggled.