1. Sports
  2. /
  3. Rays

Baseball found its scapegoats, but did it really frighten the cheaters?

Houston’s manager and GM were suspended a year (and later fired), but the players involved in the cheating scandal and the team itself got off rather easily.
Astros manager AJ Hinch didn't come up with Houston's sign-stealing scheme and he didn't participate in it. But he ended up paying for it. Hinch and general manager Jeff Luhnow were suspended for the entire season by MLB commissioner Rob Manfred on Monday, and both were later fired by owner Jim Crane. [DAVID ZALUBOWSKI  |  AP]
Astros manager AJ Hinch didn't come up with Houston's sign-stealing scheme and he didn't participate in it. But he ended up paying for it. Hinch and general manager Jeff Luhnow were suspended for the entire season by MLB commissioner Rob Manfred on Monday, and both were later fired by owner Jim Crane. [DAVID ZALUBOWSKI | AP]
Published Jan. 13
Updated Jan. 14

ST. PETERSBURG — What are you willing to pay to win a World Series?

A $5 million fine? Pfft! The last two World Series champions had an average payroll in the $200 million range. So a $5 million fine is a 2.5 percent penalty.

A handful of first- and second-round draft picks? Yeah, that hurts. But when you’re winning pennants, there are already 28 teams drafting ahead of you.

Suspensions of your manager and general manager? Get the bus schedule and let’s see who pushes them off the curb.

Look, I’m not saying the punishments for cheating handed down Monday by Major League Baseball commissioner Rob Manfred to the Houston Astros weren’t harsh. Just ask manager A.J. Hinch and general manager Jeff Luhnow. They were both suspended for a year and, 20 minutes after that announcement, were fired by team owner Jim Crane.

So why does it still feel as if it wasn’t enough?

Related: Houston Astros manager, GM fired for sign stealing

Because the players who were the admitted cheaters in 2017-18 got no penalty whatsoever. And the organization, which reaped huge financial benefits from the success of recent seasons, was only nominally penalized.

Instead, two middle management officials took the fall. And that’s supposed to discourage players in the future?

Essentially, the message that filters down to the players is that they’re free to break the rules as long as they keep it hidden from the coaching staff.

I’ll admit, Manfred was in a difficult position. As he pointed out while announcing his decision on Monday, it’s difficult to pinpoint which players were active participants, which were marginally involved and which merely had knowledge of what was happening.

On the other hand, baseball’s first commissioner, Kenesaw Mountain Landis, didn’t seem to equivocate with the Chicago Black Sox.

In case you haven’t followed the story, the Astros were found to have used television replay monitors and other electronics to steal signs from opposing pitchers and catchers despite MLB’s explicit instructions that this was against the rules.

This wasn’t gamesmanship. And it wasn’t a handful of rogue players. Former Houston bench coach — and current Red Sox manager Alex Cora — was one of the ringleaders, and all of the hitters were involved to some degree. (The Red Sox are currently under investigation, and Cora could conceivably receive the harshest penalty of all when that’s completed.)

Hinch was supposedly uncomfortable with the notion, but admitted to Manfred that he was aware it was going on. Luhnow denied knowing anything about it, but emails suggested he was in the loop.

So their penalties, while severe, were entirely justified.

Related: If you’re looking for victims of baseball’s cheating scandal, you can start with fans

But, institutionally, it feels as if the Astros got a reprieve. In real terms, they are the same contenders for the 2020 American League pennant as they were 24 hours ago.

In other sports, medals and titles are stripped from cheaters. And the NCAA issues postseason bans and severe scholarship restrictions.

I’m not advocating MLB vacates the World Series titles won by the Astros (2017) and Red Sox (2018). That seems a little overboard. But shouldn’t the pain be worse than losing a couple of non-playing personnel and four semi-valuable draft picks?

For instance, Houston should have had its allotment of international signing bonuses slashed. And I’m sure the commissioner’s office could have figured out other creative ways to punish the franchise from a competitive standpoint.

Instead, while saying Luhnow and Hinch should have had their fingers on the pulse, the commissioner basically said team ownership had no responsibility.

That’s a cop-out. And it’s not much of a deterrent.

Granted, no owner wants to go through another embarrassing offseason the way Crane did. And, after all this publicity, it’s not likely we will see another sign-stealing scandal in the next few years.

But somewhere down the line, it’s not hard to imagine another franchise looking back at this episode and doing a cost/benefit analysis.

Let’s see:

The players don’t get penalized, the owner gets praised for his cooperation and the team wins two pennants and a World Series in a three-year span?

Yeah, that seems worth the risk.

John Romano can be reached at Follow @romano_tbtimes.


  1. Tampa Bay Rays manager Kevin Cash and new Japanese slugger Yoshi Tsutsugo, shown during December press conference, will have a lot to talk about during spring training. [CHRIS URSO  |  Times]
    Rays Tales | Learning where Yoshi Tsutsugo and other newcomers best fit will be a priority in Port Charlotte.
  2. With pitching coach Kyle Snyder keeping a close eye on him at Tropicana Field on Friday, Rays prospect Brent Honeywell continues his recovery from Tommy John surgery in 2018 and a fractured arm in 2019. [DIRK SHADD  |  Tampa Bay Times]
    John Romano | Once Tampa Bay’s top pitching prospect, Brent Honeywell has had elbow surgeries in successive seasons. Healthy again, he hopes to be in the majors this summer.
  3. Tampa Bay Rays pitcher Tyler Glasnow prepares to warm up on the field during a player workout at Tropicana Field on Friday. [DIRK SHADD  |  Tampa Bay Times]
    Discipline for sign-stealing scheme was lax, Rays pitchers say, as participating hitters should have been disciplined as well.
  4. Members of the All-American Girls Professional Baseball League, who inspired the movie "A League of Their Own," will be honored at the Feb. 1 Ted Williams dinner at Tropicana Field. [GLOBE PHOTOS  |]
    Players from the All-American Girls Professional Baseball League, like Englewood’s Sue Parsons Zipay, will be honored at Ted Williams Museum event at the Trop.
  5. Diego Castillo (63) kicks a ball around during spring training at Charlotte Sports Park in Port Charlotte last February. [TAILYR IRVINE  | TIMES  ]
    Games will be available on TV and streamed; 21 of the exhibitions will be carried on radio.
  6. Derek Jeter speaks during the Baseball Hall of Fame news conference on Wednesday Jan. 22, 2020, a day after joining Larry Walker as members of the 2020 Hall of Fame class. [BEBETO MATTHEWS  |  AP]
    The New York Yankees great and the Baseball Hall of Fame say they are both OK not knowing who the lone voter is that kept Jeter from being a unanimous selection.
  7. Commissioner Rob Manfred says it will be used during the Class A Florida State League season.
  8. Baseball America released its annual list on Wednesday. [Baseball America]
    Wander Franco is No. 1 again, and Brendan McKay No. 14 as Rays lead the way.
  9. Out of 397 ballots cast, only one did not elect Derek Jeter to the Hall of Fame. [DAVID SANTIAGO  |  TNS via ZUMA Wire]
    A unanimous selection was the only remaining question and Jeter falls one vote short.
  10. In this file photo, American League All-Star Derek Jeter of the New York Yankees acknowledges the crowd before his first at bat during the 85th MLB All-Star Game at Target Field on July 15, 2014 in Minneapolis, Minnesota.
    John Romano | A clear majority of readers reacted harshly to my suggestion that Derek Jeter, while being an all-time great shortstop, might be a little overrated.