The Florida Gators are back where they started the season (off my Associated Press top 25 ballot), while Florida State sits just outside the top 20.
We’ll start with UF. My general rule is to honor head-to-head results, unless the resumes grow too far apart. That philosophy helped UF stay in my top 20 last week, despite the close win over USF; I valued the Utah win highly and wanted to reward the Gators accordingly.
Not after a loss at Tennessee dropped UF to 2-2. Granted, the two losses were to top-12 teams, one on the road. The Gators made a game of it late at Tennessee, an extremely hostile road environment, and improved on offense. But I can’t justify ranking a 2-2 team at this stage. UF has one very impressive performance (Utah), one unimpressive win (USF) and two losses. The Bulls’ struggles at Louisville on Saturday hurt the Gators, too, weakening the Week 3 win.
Add it up, and UF is off my ballot.
Last week, I gave the final spot on my ballot to Florida State, ahead of Miami. I obviously feel better about that decision after FSU blew out Boston College and the Hurricanes suffered a home beatdown to Middle Tennessee State. The Seminoles are the only state team on my ballot this week; they moved up four spots to 21st. Among the teams FSU passed: Wake Forest, this week’s opponent for what should be a fun matchup in Tallahassee.
Other notable moves in my rankings:
My skepticism of Tennessee and former UCF coach Josh Heupel is disappearing. I’ve got the Volunteers all the way up to seventh after their win over Florida. That’s one spot ahead of Kentucky. I’ve seen both teams with my own eyes and would pick Tennessee to win on a neutral field tomorrow.
I considered dropping Georgia from No. 1 after an unimpressive win over Kent State but opted not to. The Bulldogs’ blowout win over Oregon remains the best performance among the top teams (Ohio State and Alabama), so I still gave them the edge. I didn’t change No. 4 (Michigan) or No. 5 (USC), either. The Trojans’ tight win over Oregon State showed some grit, and I try not to drop a team for winning conference games on the road.
Follow the state’s college football teams
Subscribe to our free Florida Football Fix newsletter (coming soon)
You’re all signed up!
Want more of our free, weekly newsletters in your inbox? Let’s get started.Explore all your options
Kansas State reentered my rankings at No. 17 after knocking off Oklahoma on the road. Yes, it’s the same Kansas State team that lost a week before to Tulane. This season makes no sense. I slid the Wildcats one spot ahead of the Sooners (who fell a dozen places).
Washington dropped from 16th to 24th in my rankings despite an 18-point win over Stanford. Why? Because I was impressed by the Huskies’ Week 3 win over Michigan State. That’s not quite the case anymore after the Spartans were blown out by Minnesota.
The 4-0 Golden Gophers joined my rankings after crushing the Spartans on the road. I also welcomed Kansas — yes, Kansas — to my ballot. The unbeaten Jayhawks have wins at Houston and West Virginia, plus a home win over previously unbeaten Duke. That was enough to edge Kansas past Cincinnati for the final spot on my ballot.
Florida and Texas dropped off, as did the Bearcats. Cincinnati’s close loss to Arkansas doesn’t look as good now after the Razorbacks lost to Texas A&M. Texas Tech and Pitt were among the other teams I considered.
Here’s the AP top 25 ballot I submitted Sunday morning:
3. Ohio State
9. Penn State
10. Oklahoma State
13. North Carolina State
14. Texas A&M
17. Kansas State
21. Florida State
22. Wake Forest
• • •