Advertisement

FSU football playoff snub ‘unfortunate’ but simple math, LSU coach says

Brian Kelly is the only coach who went up against both the Seminoles and Alabama this season.
 
LSU coach Brian Kelly lost to Florida State and Alabama this year. How did he view the College Football Playoff's decision?
LSU coach Brian Kelly lost to Florida State and Alabama this year. How did he view the College Football Playoff's decision? [ JOHN RAOUX | AP ]
Published Dec. 8, 2023|Updated Dec. 8, 2023

TAMPA — As the only coach to face Florida State and Alabama this season, LSU’s Brian Kelly has a unique perspective on the 12-1 Crimson Tide taking the final playoff spot ahead of the 13-0 Seminoles.

Kelly seemed to understand the decision, even if he feels bad about FSU’s exclusion.

“They were two different teams at the end of the year,” Kelly said Thursday evening during a promotional event for the Jan. 1 ReliaQuest Bowl at Raymond James Stadium.

Kelly said the Alabama team he saw on film in a 17-3 win at USF was a “different team” than the one that beat his Tigers by 14 points seven weeks later.

“And then the Florida State team that we played in the opener in Orlando was a different team than I watched on TV play Florida or Louisville,” Kelly said.

Jordan Travis starred for Florida State against LSU.
Jordan Travis starred for Florida State against LSU. [ JOHN RAOUX | AP ]

His points are similar to what the College Football Playoff selection committee chairperson said Sunday. FSU changed after the injury to star quarterback Jordan Travis — a player Kelly faced four different times and one that commanded his respect.

Kelly didn’t blame the committee for the decision. He said the system had a fatal flaw with five major conferences but only four available spots.

“Somebody was getting left out, one of them,” Kelly said. “The math just said that. There was going to have to be an evaluation process of how somebody was going to get left at the altar. This evaluation came down to that quarterback wasn’t on that roster. And because of it, that team was not the same team.

“It’s unfortunate. I feel for them. I would be upset if I were them. But the reality of it is, you’ve only got four spots for five teams, and you have to find a mitigating factor in there. They did, and that’s the story.”

Kelly was then asked if the process itself is ridiculous.

“Yes…” he said. “It just took us this long to get to 12 teams.

“Because you have so many good programs now that are invested in this, the window was too small to avoid the inevitable. That was a deserving team that got left out. That’s just my opinion.”

Luke Fickell led an undefeated Cincinnati team that was excluded from the College Football Playoff the year before his Bearcats became the first mid-major program to break through.
Luke Fickell led an undefeated Cincinnati team that was excluded from the College Football Playoff the year before his Bearcats became the first mid-major program to break through. [ AARON DOSTER | AP (2021) ]

Kelly’s ReliaQuest Bowl opponent, Wisconsin’s Luke Fickell, said he was “a bit” shocked by the committee’s decision and it’s another data point that “shows us our system is a little bit broken.”

Stay updated on Tampa Bay’s sports scene

Stay updated on Tampa Bay’s sports scene

Subscribe to our free Sports Today newsletter

We’ll send you news and analysis on the Bucs, Lightning, Rays and Florida’s college football teams every day.

You’re all signed up!

Want more of our free, weekly newsletters in your inbox? Let’s get started.

Explore all your options

Fickell went through a similar situation as Cincinnati’s coach. Though his 2021 Bearcats became the first team from a mid-major conference to make the final four, he went 9-0 the year before during the 2020 COVID season and was excluded in favor of 10-1 Clemson and 10-1 Notre Dame.

“We were undefeated. Cincinnati, we weren’t Florida State,” Fickell said. “I knew deep down inside we weren’t going to get in if it was (against) Texas, Ohio State, those were the other teams…

“And I just understand sometimes the bigger picture of these things. I didn’t say it’s right. But the bigger picture of what sometimes the logo and what the followings are.”

• • •

Sign up for the Sports Today newsletter to get daily updates on the Bucs, Rays, Lightning and college football across Florida.

Never miss out on the latest with your favorite Tampa Bay sports teams. Follow our coverage on Instagram, X and Facebook.