1. Cooking

Cookbook review: A tale of two Italian cities in 'Florentine' and 'Tasting Rome'

Published Aug. 29, 2016

Cookbooks continue to cover more niche topics, especially when it comes to regional cuisines. The growing appetite for regionally focused cookbooks makes a lot of sense for Italy when you consider that although its cities and cultures have existed for many centuries, Italy as a nation is a fairly new country, younger than the United States. Many Italians often focus on the qualities that distinguish their city or region's cuisine from another's rather than similarities. Two cookbooks out this year, Florentine: The True Cuisine of Florence and Tasting Rome: Fresh Flavors & Forgotten Recipes From an Ancient City, offer food tours through two of Italy's most famous cities.

Florentine: The True Cuisine of Florence

By Emiko Davies

Hardie Grant Books, 256 pages, $39.95

Emiko Davies, who is Japanese-Australian and grew up in Beijing, was a young art student when she first headed to Florence. Eventually, she met her husband in the country and has lived in Tuscany for several years with their daughter. Reading her cookbook on the cuisine of Florence, it's clear she is someone with an eye for detail who enjoys absorbing the story of a city. The capital of Tuscany is a place ripe for exploring food steeped in history.

She describes Florentine food as earthy, rustic and rooted in tradition and the changing seasons. Grape focaccia in bakeries signals the end of summer. A yeasted cake adorned with the city's fleur-de-lis appears in February to celebrate Carnival season.

The thick cookbook with bright coral edges is divided into six chapters based on where one living in Florence might venture for food: the pastry shop, the bakery, the market, the trattoria, the butcher and the street.

Davies is generous in her headnotes and has plenty of knowledge to share about daily Florentine life. Bits of history, references to other books and anecdotes from her trips to Florence's markets give the recipes context and give them a sense of place. Davies writes about the secret bakeries that dish out freshly baked pastries between midnight and 4 a.m., and explains how Florentines were some of the first Europeans to embrace unusual foods from the New World like tomatoes and beans, which became staples of the cuisine.

For anyone planning a trip to Florence, this cookbook will give you a great sense of what you'll find to eat. In the back of the book, the author lists some of her favorite bakeries and trattorias.

Though Florentine kicks off with a simple apricot jam crostata that will save many a dinner party (it's as impressive as it is easy to make), I suggest starting with the ribollita. Davies goes into detail about Tuscan bread, known for its lack of salt and a springy crumb that grows stale after a day. But Florentines are resourceful, and they give that loaf many other lives as the days go on. Tuscan bread becomes bread crumbs, can be soaked back to life for a panzanella or can be stirred into a soup like ribollita to thicken it up.

Dig in to Tampa Bay’s food and drink scenes

Dig in to Tampa Bay’s food and drink scenes

Subscribe to our free Taste newsletter

Get the restaurant and bar news, insights and reviews you crave from food and dining critic Helen Freund every Thursday.

You’re all signed up!

Want more of our free, weekly newsletters in your inbox? Let’s get started.

Explore all your options

Many classic Florentine recipes taste better the next day, and ribollita, which translates to "reboiled," is the poster child. The dish, a mainstay of Florentine trattorias, seems to embody the ethos of Florentine cooking: Waste nothing.

Tasting Rome: Fresh Flavors & Forgotten Recipes From an Ancient City

By Katie Parla and Kristina Gill

Clarkson Potter, 256 pages, $30

Like Davies, Katie Parla and Kristina Gill are expats. Parla has lived in Rome for more than a decade and writes about Roman food and beverage culture for several publications, including the New York Times, blogs and travel guides. Gill, a food and drinks editor for a lifestyle website, is a food and travel photographer who has lived in Rome since 1999.

In Tasting Rome, they say Roman cooking was strongly influenced by Italians from other regions who migrated to the city as it transformed "from a malarial backwater into a thriving city." This is an ongoing transformation, Parla and Gill write, as is reflected in their cookbook's inclusion of both traditional Roman dishes and more contemporary takes on the city's food. Their shared depth of knowledge of Roman food and culture is evident throughout.

In the foreword for the book, Mario Batali writes, "Traditional recipes don't just change from region to region; they also vary from cook to cook." Why all the variations? He says this book answers that question.

The pair worked with local chefs to develop the recipes. As a result, some of the recipes in Tasting Rome end up seeming more restaurant-inspired than the homier dishes of Florentine. There's a recipe for a Carbonara Sour cocktail featuring a guanciale-washed vodka, inspired by the carbonara sauce traditionally served with pasta. (There's also a recipe for making your own guanciale, an Italian cured meat.)

While Florentine opens with pastries and saves street food for last, Tasting Rome flips this organization and jumps right in with several variations of rice croquettes that seem right at home for happy hour. Romans, the authors note, always pair drinks with food, and nearly all bars serve complimentary snacks.

I have been on something of a meatball bender this year, making mostly pork, beef or turkey versions, so I gravitated first toward Tasting Rome's recipe for chicken meatballs in a light white wine and lemon sauce. The ingredient list calls for an intriguing mix of cinnamon, nutmeg and pistachios to flavor the chicken. Soaked bread, in part, makes for a very sticky meatball mixture, but this possibility was noted in the recipe. I could overcome this small hurdle if the result was tender, excellent meatballs that I look forward to making another night.

Detailed headnotes manage to pack in a lot of historical and practical information for when and with what to serve a dish. These notes framing the recipes are also filled with intimate details about specific bakeries and local ingredients. Parla and Gill may be American-born, but they've adopted Rome wholeheartedly. At one bakery, they note that the slightly charred tops of the baked goods are a trademark to be embraced, not eschewed. In a recipe for braised oxtail, they dare you to eat it the traditional way, with your hands.

Contact Ileana Morales Valentine at


This site no longer supports your current browser. Please use a modern and up-to-date browser version for the best experience.

Chrome Firefox Safari Edge