1. Arts & Entertainment

Review: 'Personal Shopper' changes the conversation on Kristen Stewart

Kristen Stewart’s seeming indifference works as Maureen Cartwright, employed by a demanding supermodel-designer. French writer-director Olivier Assayas grasps her essence, her twitchy elusiveness. 
IFC Films
Published Mar. 30, 2017

Time for a reassessment of Kristen Stewart, a divisive actor with a penchant for appearing detached from everything around her in a movie.

Like many viewers — not her devoted Twilight fans — I've often thought Stewart's withdrawn, uneasy persona got in the way of her characters. Yet two striking performances directed by Olivier Assayas and several middling movies in which she still shined puts Stewart in the discussion of her generation's finest actors.

Personal Shopper is Stewart's current collaboration with Assayas, following 2014's Clouds of Sils Maria signaling her emergence with a Cannes acting prize. There's always something vaguely European about Stewart's seeming indifference, so a French filmmaker may have an advantage in grasping her essence, her twitchy elusiveness.

Stewart is practically the whole show in Personal Shopper, on screen throughout, largely left to convey her character's thoughts in extended passages of silence. It's a ghost story not built upon jump scares but creeping dread that gets boring at times. Not Stewart's performance, though.

Stewart plays Maureen Cartwright, an American in Paris employed as a personal shopper for a demanding supermodel-designer (Nora von Waldstatten). Maureen dutifully picks up and drops off her client's fashion and jewelry, sometimes trying glamor on for size. Notice how Stewart's posture and expressions change in these moments, subtly conveying Maureen's needy side. She sorely wants to be someone other than herself. That's the connecting tissue of Stewart's best roles.

Maureen also has a psychic gift shared with her late twin brother, Lewis, who died in Paris of a heart defect. Maureen has the same medical issue. They promised each other that whoever died first would contact the other from beyond. Paris seems like the right place for that to happen.

Assayas puts a ghost in the machine, specifically Maureen's ever-present cellphone that begins receiving messages from "Unknown," who seems to be her brother. Or could it be someone else from the netherworld with darker plans in mind.

That's the framework of countless ghost stories that Assayas' screenplay attempts to make more metaphysical than a simple haunting. There's a subtext of social media as a disembodying force that doesn't quite click. The more Maureen chases her brother's ghost, the more she's cut off from the living. Obsession in solitude, where Stewart does much of her finest work.

Personal Shopper is wildly imperfect, wandering like Maureen through surroundings matching her dark, curious mood. Dead ends abound with scenes running long then abruptly dropping their subjects. Thrills aren't part of the bargain unless Stewart's intense vulnerability counts. Now more than ever, it should.

Contact Steve Persall at or (727) 893-8365. Follow @StevePersall.


  1. Michael McDonald, right, will rejoin the Doobie Brothers for a 50th anniversary tour that will hit Tampa's MidFlorida Credit Union Amphitheatre on June 10, 2020. Clay Patrick McBride
    The Doobies and McDonald haven’t toured together in 25 years.
  2. White bean stew with salami and kale MICHELLE STARK  |  Tampa Bay Times
    Salami and kale bolster this creamy one-pot meal.
  3. A mermaid attraction at the Shine mural festival finale is an example of what to expect at Fairgrounds, an immersive art attraction coming to The Factory St. Pete. Courtesy of Liz Dimmitt
    Two art compounds include hands-on ways to appreciate art, plus breweries that encourage visitors to make a day of it.
  4. Director Dan Myrick, left, and Kristian Krempel are pictured on Seventh Avenue in Tampa's Ybor City.
    The series features six 15-minute fictional horror stories based on Ybor history.
  5. Elevation Coffee Roasters will serve everything from lattes to cold brew when it launches in the Northdale area of Tampa. Elevation Coffee Roasters
    Owners Jonathan and Michelle Mitchell will roast on-site.
  6. Sweet Buns Bakery & Cafe has premiered in Tampa with savory and sweet Asian goodies. MEAGHAN HABUDA  |  Times
    Tampa has also scored Old School Bar & Grill and another Tampa Pizza Company.
  7. Melissa Etheridge will perform at Ruth Eckerd Hall in Clearwater on May 1. Lauren Dukoff
    Catch up on today’s Tampa Bay concert announcements.
  8. Candice Anderson, left, and Alsace Walentine, co-owners of Tombolo Books, rearrange books as attendees of the Times Festival of Reading leave the University Student Center behind them. [Jack Evans | Times]
    The shop plans to open next to Black Crow on First Ave. S before the new year.
  9. The Jonas Brothers show off bottles of their collaboration with Coors Light in this undated photo. MillerCoors
    The beer isn’t exactly small-batch, but it is a limited edition, and Tampa is one of the few cities to get it.
  10. Sugar Factory's shock-and-awe selection of milkshakes are coming to the Seminole Hard Rock Hotel & Casino in Tampa. Courtesy of Sugar Factory
    The chain, part restaurant and part confectionery, will offer a floor-to-ceiling candy wall, among other sweet features.