1. Stage

Review: 'A Christmas Carol' is back with new thrills at Freefall Theatre

David Mann lends a gruff bark as Ebenezer Scrooge with Daniel Schwab as Fred in A Christmas Carol at Freefall Theatre.
Published Dec. 2, 2014

ST. PETERSBURG — To best measure the strength of a holiday classic, watch it unfold on the faces of young people.

At Freefall Theatre's A Christmas Carol on Sunday afternoon, one little girl screamed for her life when Jacob Marley came raging on stage, awash in green lights and clanking his chains of regret. Her brother spent the rest of the scene alternately giggling and hiding in his shirt like a mole.

Christmas glee! Yes, there is still plenty of satisfying fear and joy in Charles Dickens' redemption tale. Everyone knows Ebenezer Scrooge, the curmudgeon so curmudgeonly he delights in steam rolling all holiday spirit.

"Your sentimentality is sickening," he sneers at his cheerful nephew. "And also a great waste of my time."

It's Christmas, and such petulance can't last. Scrooge has to suffer through his dreary past, present and future with helpful hints before he decides to go nice. The cautionary tale from 1843 still resonates, performed every year in theaters around the world.

This is Freefall's fourth year doing the musical, with book and lyrics by Keith Ferguson and music by Bruce Greer. The songs are traditional English carols and original numbers that bolster the narrative without distracting from it.

Freefall has aimed to turn the show into a community tradition, while finding ways to keep it fresh. This year's production welcomes new faces, including David Mann as Scrooge and Joey Panek as Bob Cratchit. Freefall fans will spot Kelly Pekar and Taylor Simmons from the recently wrapped Into the Woods.

Mann, who played the Emcee in Freefall's Cabaret, lends a gruff bark to Scrooge, a meanness he subtly transforms. Sarasota-based performer Panek, known for his Internet show How Bout Joey, gives Cratchit warmth, sweetness and a really big smile.

Director Eric Davis does his usual strong work filling the stage with creative interpretations. Costumes by Mike and Kathy Buck Designs and Davis are luscious to look at, as is the set by Greg Bierce and Matt Davis. The lighting by Mike Wood is up to Freefall's engaging standards. And there's even snow.

The chief challenge for A Christmas Carol is in the sound, which felt uneven much of the time Sunday. The cast sang to a recorded track, and it seemed hard to find cohesion and rhythm without the benefit of live musicians. The track often drowned out the singers, especially the children and the high sopranos.

The show is just spooky enough for both kids and adults. Davis pinpoints the tale's inherent darkness in a few ways, including the time-tested practice of putting haunting masks on small children. And I almost yelped myself when the Ghost of Christmas Future came lumbering out. Wait for the thrill.

Here's a note from the Ghost of Intermission Present: If you're going to have the festive hot cocoa at the half, enjoy. But hold tight to the ceramic mug, a few of which went clunk on the stairs toward the show's end. Scrooge needs everyone's full cooperation to turn jolly.

Contact Stephanie Hayes at or (727) 893-8716. Follow @stephhayes.


  1. The cast of American Stage's production of "Vietgone" includes Sami Ma as Tong and Jeff Kim as Quang. Courtesy of Joey Clay Studio
    An immigrant story with voice offers a fresh perspective.
  2. On Saturday, J.B. Smoove will perform at Ferguson Hall, part of Tampa's Straz Center. RICHARD SHOTWELL  |  Invision/AP
    The comedian known for portraying Leon Black on ‘Curb Your Enthusiasm’ likes to wing it. He hits the Straz Center’s Ferguson Hall on Saturday.
  3. The cast performs 'On The Deck Of A Spanish Sailing Ship, 1492' in the Stage West production of 'Songs for a New World', which will be presented Oct. 17-27. Pictured at top, from left: Paris Seaver, Anthony Agnelli and Nicki Poulis. Standing in front: Jay Garcia. Timothy Rooney
    See ‘Songs for a New World’ and other shows in the north Suncoast
  4. Wayne Brady will perform at the Mahaffey Theater in St. Petersburg on Sunday. Courtesy of Mahaffey Theater
    There’s Jeanne Robertson and an inventive Florida Orchestra collaboration, too.
  5. Emilee Dupre and Eric Davis star in Freefall Theatre's production of "The Turn of the Screw." Courtesy of Thee Photo Ninja
    A spooky, risk-filled performance will leave you with questions. | Review
  6. "Charlie and the Chocolate Factory" will roll through Tampa as part of the Straz Center's 2019-20 Broadway series. JOAN MARCUS  |  Straz Center
    ‘Charlie and the Chocolate Factory,’ Roy Wood Jr., ‘Vietgone’ at American Stage, Piff the Magic Dragon and more.
  7. Music director Michael Francis leads the Florida Orchestra in the Star-Spangled Banner on Friday during the season-opening program at the David A. Straz Jr. Center for the Performing Arts in Tampa. JAY CRIDLIN  |  Tampa Bay Times
    Friday’s opening night portrayed Tampa as a melting pot, delivering diverse pieces pulled from around the world. | Concert review
  8. Bernadette Peters is pictured at Radio City Music Hall in New York in 2015. CHARLES SYKES  |  AP
    Peters follows the likes of Sting and Seal playing with the orchestra.
  9. Aldo Lopez-Gavilan, shown performing "Rhapsody in Blue" with the Florida Orchestra at St. Petersburg's Mahaffey Theater in January, will join the orchestra for its 2019-20 season-opening program this weekend. J.M. LENNON  |  Lennon Media
    Plus, SuicideGirls at Tampa Theatre and comedian Bryan Callen at Tampa Improv.
  10. Ned Averill-Snell, Ami Sallee, Emilia Sargent and Alan Mohney, Jr. in Tampa Repertory Theatre's Dinner With Friends, 2019. Courtesy of KLGold, LLC
    The Pulitzer-winning play illustrates the aftershocks of divorce on marital friendships. | Review