Advertisement
  1. Transportation

Florida Supreme Court to decide future of Hillsborough's transportation tax

The Florida Supreme Court in Tallahassee, where justices will hear a challenge to the one-cent transportation sales tax approved by Hillsborough County voters in November. [SCOTT KEELER   |   Times]
The Florida Supreme Court in Tallahassee, where justices will hear a challenge to the one-cent transportation sales tax approved by Hillsborough County voters in November. [SCOTT KEELER | Times]
Published Jul. 19

TAMPA — A lawsuit challenging Hillsborough County's one-cent transportation tax is going to the Florida Supreme Court.

Bob Emerson, 65, of Apollo Beach, filed an appeal Thursday regarding the tax's bond validation, a process in which a judge decides whether the county can borrow against the new revenue source. Its purpose is to reassure potential lenders that the tax money used to repay bond holders won't be challenged in the future.

Commissioner Stacy White followed with an appeal of his own Friday morning in a separate lawsuit. White's case challenged the constitutionality of the tax, arguing it usurped power from county commissioners.

The two suits, which each asked a court to decide whether the tax was legal, were linked and heard by the same judge in May.

Circuit Court Judge Rex Barbas issued a final ruling on both matters July 9, triggering a 30-day window for any party to appeal. He validated the bonds and upheld the tax, but struck certain portions of the charter amendment as invalid.

Appeals in bond validations skip the district court of appeals and go directly to the state Supreme Court. White's case would go next to the second district court of appeals, but the commissioner said he is asking that his appeal bypass the district court so it can travel through the legal system alongside the bond validation.

"The good news is the Florida Supreme Court decision, either way, will be the law of the land with these types of issues," White said.

PREVIOUS COVERAGE:

Judge: Hillsborough's transportation tax is legal, but spending allocations and oversight committee are not

In close vote, Hillsborough's transit tax will stick to the plan

Why is a Jacksonville personal injury law firm helping to challenge Hillsborough's transportation tax?

Barbas upheld the tax in his June ruling, but agreed with White on some facets. The judge struck parts of the charter amendment related to an independent oversight committee and language that specified how the tax revenue should be spent.

"We saw so much severed ... you can't help but ask how would that have impacted voters' decisions at the ballot box," White said. "It's just impossible to predict what the outcome would have been.

"The best thing to do now is just to throw the whole thing out and let the dust settle and let the county commission or the citizens start from scratch and put something out there that's lawful."

White said he is optimistic that the Supreme Court will rule on the legality of the tax by the end of the year.

Earlier this week, Hillsborough County Commissioners voted to reinstate the spending categories Barbas had struck from the charter amendment. The allocations send 45 percent of the tax revenue to the county's transit agency and divide the rest of the money between the county, Tampa, Temple Terrace and Plant City. The local governments must then spend a certain amount of the revenue in different categories, such as intersections and safety.

That ordinance will face two public hearings and a final commission vote before going into effect.

Fifty-seven percent of voters approved the sales tax in November, but it faced challenges almost immediately. White filed his case Dec. 4, and county commissioners filed a motion for the bond validation hearing in February. A class-action suit followed shortly after.

Emerson replaced John Cimino, a Temple Terrace resident, as the plaintiff in that case in April.

Emerson also joined the bond validation case as an intervener, which allows him to file motions, make arguments and participate in the proceedings. Coker Law — a Jacksonville firm that specializes in medical malpractice cases along with vehicle crashes, personal injury and workers compensation — represents him in both matters.

Emerson did not return calls for comment.

Other parties in the bond validation — including Tyler Hudson, chair of All For Transportation, the advocacy group that put the sales tax on the ballot — can file a separate appeal within the next few weeks.

"The public spoke loudly in November when they overwhelmingly approved our plan," Hudson said in a statement. "We will continue to fight all the way to the Florida Supreme Court further attempts to obstruct the will of the voters and to delay progress."

Times staff writer Anastasia Dawson contributed to this report. Contact Caitlin Johnston at cjohnston@tampabay.com or (727) 893-8779. Follow @cljohnst.

ALSO IN THIS SECTION

  1. State Road 52 was closed for an hour and a half Thursday morning after a car hauler overturned. [Florida Highway Patrol]
    The driver lost control of his vehicle as he tried to turn into the Flying J parking lot.
  2. Cleveland, Ohio, has one of the highest rated bus rapid transit lines in the country, with features including a dedicated traffic lane. Hillsborough transit officials are making plans for bus rapid transit line between downtown Tampa and the University of South Florida. [Greater Cleveland Regional Transit]
    The project, using All For Transportation sales tax revenue, would run along Florida Avenue, Fowler and Bruce B. Downs.
  3. The new Maydell Drive Bridge will be a multi-use bridge to cater to cars, bicyclists and pedestrians with travel lanes, 8-foot shoulders, and a barrier-separated 5' sidewalk & 10' trail. [Hillsborough County]
    Hillsborough County closed the bridge in December 2015 after an independent engineering study found it was structurally unsound.
  4. "Lefty Lucy, Righty Tighty?", Siomara Bridges-Mata, 32, asks her coworkers as they assemble one of 900 bikes Friday when Amalie Arena transformed into Santa's Bike Shop. Bridges-Mata volunteered with Frameworks of Tampa Bay, Inc. [JOHN PENDYGRAFT  |  Times]
    Local nonprofit Onbikes organizes the annual bike build to provide bicycles to kids in the community
  5. Service dog Eleanor Rigby unexpectedly gave birth to eight puppies at Tampa International Airport as her human family was waiting near gate F81 to board a flight to Philadelphia in May 2018. The airport is getting ready to add pet-relief areas at its airsides for service dogs. (EMILY NIPPS | Tampa International Airport) [Tampa International Airport]
    Work on the new amenities is expected to be completed by next July.
  6. This Wednesday, June 21, 2017, file photo shows the building that houses the headquarters of Uber, in San Francisco. Uber acknowledged more than 3,000 sexual assaults occurred during U.S. Uber rides in 2018, the company said in a long-awaited safety report. [ERIC RISBERG  |  AP]
    That figure includes 229 rapes across the company’s 1.3 billion rides.
  7. Michele Arceneaux, former president of the Jefferson County Chamber of Commerce, speaks during a press conference against three proposed toll roads in the Florida Capitol on Thursday, Dec. 5, 2019. [LAWRENCE MOWER  |  Lawrence Mower]
    The announcement came as the Florida Chamber of Commerce touted the proposed roads.
  8. The Cross-Bay Ferry cruises along the Vinoy Yacht Basin as it heads toward Tampa. The Vinoy condominiums can be seen in the background. The city hopes to attract more vessels for entertainment and tourism to the downtown waterfront. [SCOTT KEELER   |   Times]
    Most of the increase is tied to an additional round-trip sailing on Sundays.
  9. The intersection at Seminole Boulevard and East and West Bay Drive forbids drivers from turning right, even on a green light. [FDOT]
    The intersection at Seminole Boulevard and the East/West Bay Drive is the only one in the district where drivers are restricted on green-light turns.
  10. Abiona Adadevoh addresses the Hillsborough Area Regional Transit Authority board Monday about an attack last month on bus driver Schnaider Prophete. Prophete, center, was saved bus bus rider John Phelps, right, when a passenger attacked him with mace and a box cutter. [Caitlin Johnston]
    The agency has installed safety shields to protect operators on about 80 percent of its fleet so far.
Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement