1. Transportation

Is an electric scooter the same as a bike? Florida law says yes, trail users say no

A sign on the Pinellas Trail in Clearwater makes it clear that motorized vehicles are not allowed. But what about electric scooters? [ROMY ELLENBOGEN   |   Times]
A sign on the Pinellas Trail in Clearwater makes it clear that motorized vehicles are not allowed. But what about electric scooters? [ROMY ELLENBOGEN | Times]
Published Jul. 3, 2019

Along the Pinellas Trail, the signs say it in all caps: "NO MOTOR VEHICLES."

Still, electric bikes zip by. Those who need disability access can take their motorized wheelchairs or other devices, even golf carts, along the way.

And soon, electric scooters from one-word companies like Lime, Bird, Spin and Jump may be vying for space.

With developing technology and Florida law, a banned motor vehicle may not be what people think, said Lyle Fowler, operations manager for Pinellas County Parks and Conservation Management.

RELATED: No scooter rentals in Clearwater, for now

He said they have to look to state statutes for guidance, which defines electric bicycles the same as regular bikes. But that doesn't mean people are happy about it.

"There are some folks who are very strict in their interpretation, their perception of how anything with a motor is beyond the conventional bicycle," he said.

A new state law approved in June also gives micro-mobility devices, like scooters, the same allowances as a bicycle. The law gives local ordinances the chance to regulate differently, which inspired Clearwater officials to put a hold on any electric scooters for six months while they draft out their plan.

ALSO READ: Electric scooters can now ride in Tampa streets and bike lanes

Brian Smith, chairman of the Pinellas County Bicycle Pedestrian Advisory Committee, said though they realize electric bikes have limited speed and power, scooters are entirely different because they aren't powered by a person. He fears it's a safety risk to the slower cyclists and pedestrians who are predominant users of the trail.

"A scooter is not prepared to stop or do evasive action to avoid an accident like a bike or a pedestrian can," Smith said.

Janet Carroll, 60, likes to walk up and down the trail and meets at a gazebo along the way with friends. She said she's shocked the scooters have been allowed elsewhere and finds them dangerous, pointing to the recent death of a man in Tampa killed after being hit while riding a scooter. She worries about them zipping all over the trail.

"We already have so many pedestrians, bicycles, I just worry they're going to get hurt," she said.

Along with safety issues, Smith said the Pinellas Trail and similar trails around the county weren't made for scooters. They were intended to be a safe haven for people who wanted to walk their dogs or ride their bikes.

Mari Watkins, a Clearwater resident, said she likes to take her dog Kiki, a 2-year-old Bichon Frise, for walks along the beach. While on the trail, she said, the dog gets scared enough of regular bicycles, let alone a scooter speeding by. She said the trail is meant for people exercising, not cruising by.

"You're sitting in your motor scooter, you're not exercising," she said.

Contact Romy Ellenbogen at or Follow @Romyellenbogen.


  1. A wrong-way driver headed south in the northbound lanes of Interstate 75 in Pasco County caused a crash that resulted in the death of a 45-year-old motorcyclist, according to the Florida Highway Patrol.  Over a three-year period ending in 2018, the county averaged 97 traffic fatalities annually. [Florida Highway Patrol]
  2. Luis Espel, 22, uses the Cass Street bike lane to commute to work in Tampa. Times (2019)
  3. Hillsborough County Commission chair Les Miller.
  4. FILE - In this Sept. 9, 2019, file photo Southwest pilots prepare for a flight at Tampa International Airport in Tampa, Fla.  (AP Photo/Mike Stewart, File)
  5. Tampa International Airport,
  6. Now in its second year, the Cross-Bay Ferry sails daily, November through April, from St. Petersburg to Tampa and back. Ridership so far this year has nearly doubled over the same period last year.
  7. Ben Limmer addresses the Hillsborough Area Regional Transit Authority board Friday before being terminated as chief executive officer.
  8. One reader wrote to Dr. Delay suggesting the state post more signs that read: "Slower traffic keep right" on the highways to ease traffic stacking up in the left lane. (Times)
  9. Florida stopped providing free juice at welcome centers last year. [Times (2015)]
  10. Chief executive Ben Limmer attended a special meeting of the Hillsborough County transit agency board where members voted to fire him.
  11. The Sierra Club is suing federal environmental regulators to try to block the extension of Ridge Road in Pasco County through a nature preserve.
  12. The St. Petersburg City Council voted Thursday to expand its bike share program by replacing its existing bikes with new ones and adding 50 electric bikes.