1. Sports
  2. /
  3. Florida State Seminoles

Why Jimbo Fisher deserves blame for FSU football’s mess

Fisher said the Seminoles he left behind are in ‘great shape.’ He’s wrong. And it’s partly his fault.
Texas A&M head coach Jimbo Fisher, left, talks to quarterback Kellen Mond (11) during the second half of an NCAA college football game against Mississippi State, Saturday, Oct. 27, 2018, in Starkville, Miss. (AP Photo/Jim Lytle)
Published May 29
Updated May 30

DESTIN — As Texas A&M coach Jimbo Fisher spoke about his team Wednesday during the SEC’s spring meetings, the wreckage he left behind in his previous job was still smoldering 140 miles east.

The 7-6 flop in Fisher’s final season at Florida State in 2017 turned into a 5-7 failure in Willie Taggart’s first season in 2018. One subpar recruiting class led to another. The Seminoles’ short-term future is more likely to resemble its immediate past than the national-champion highs Fisher led them to five years ago.

Fisher doesn’t see it that way.

“I think (Florida State is) in great shape,” Fisher said.

Except there’s little great about the shape Florida State is in. Attendance is down. Its academic progress rate is the worst among the teams in the Power Five conferences: ACC, SEC, Big 10, Big 12 and Pac-12. Its budget faces a multimillion-dollar deficit. Its record over the past two years, 12-13, is its worst since 1975-76, and even a soft schedule might yield only seven or eight wins next season.

RELATED: Florida Gators, FSU football had worst attendance years since the ’90s

So, no, Florida State isn’t in great shape. The only question is how much blame Fisher deserves for the decline.

The answer: a lot.

Fisher will disagree because of the talent Taggart inherited. Fisher’s last four recruiting classes in his 2010-17 tenure were ranked in the top six nationally. He lured one of the most talented running backs in the nation, Cam Akers, and landed Marvin Wilson, who has the potential to become one of the ACC’s top defensive linemen next season.

“They had draft picks, first-round picks,” Fisher said. “They’ve got good players this year. I see they’re picked to go to another good bowl game.”

The Seminoles didn’t make a bowl game at all last season, ending an NCAA record run of 36 in a row, and they didn’t make it to a good bowl in Fisher’s final year, either. Beating Southern Miss in the Independence Bowl doesn’t count.

It’s clear in hindsight that Florida State having to rally to make that Independence Bowl — it had to win its last three games to be bowl eligible at 6-6 — wasn’t a fluke caused by quarterback Deondre Francois’ season-ending injury in a Week 1 loss to Alabama, the snowball effect of that loss or the aftermath of Hurricane Irma, which cost the Seminoles their bye week and a game that wasn’t rescheduled.

Fisher’s Seminoles were rotting.

The offensive line lagged at the end of the Fisher era as recruiting misses, misevaluations and injuries piled up. Running back Dalvin Cook was able to cover up some of the glaring holes, but the mediocrity was still there. It finally, disastrously, caught up to Florida State last season, when Taggart’s Seminoles had one of the worst offensive lines in the sport.

Florida State’s effort lagged so much in a 2016 home loss to North Carolina that the Seminoles had to sign promises vowing their full effort, preparation and trust. Is it any wonder that Taggart said Florida State didn’t handle adversity well last year?

The intangible troubles mushroomed under Taggart, leading to six losses by at least 19 points. But that wasn’t new, either. Florida State got blown out at least once (often by less talented teams) in each of Fisher’s final four seasons, including a 32-point rout at Boston College in 2017.

None of this absolves Taggart of his responsibility for Florida State’s struggles last year. Florida coach Dan Mullen took over an unstable situation in Gainesville last year and turned it into a trip to the Peach Bowl.

But it does explain the hole Taggart is trying to escape, even if Fisher doesn’t see it that way.

“I loved my time at Florida State,” said Fisher, who was an assistant for three years before taking over for Bobby Bowden. “It was an outstanding place.”

FROM THE ARCHIVES: SEC meetings: What’s Jimbo Fisher’s legacy at Florida State?

Now Fisher is focused on his new place, the one that’s paying him $75 million over 10 years. Even if a brutal schedule (games against Clemson, Alabama, Georgia and LSU) keeps his Aggies out of the College Football Playoff mix next season, Texas A&M has top-15 potential.

“I think it’s going to lay the groundwork where we can go in the future,” Fisher said, “which I think is sky high.”

His old program still has sky-high potential, too. But for now, the program he left behind remains stuck near rock bottom.

Contact Matt Baker at Follow @MBakerTBTimes.


  1. Florida State coach Willie Taggart shouts instructions in the second half against Louisville in Tallahassee. Florida State defeated Louisville 35-24. MARK WALLHEISER  |  AP
    Fennelly: The Seminoles rally after blowing the lead against Louisville. Expect to hold your breath every week.
  2. Miami defensive lineman Trevon Hill (94) celebrates a sack against Central Michigan quarterback David Moore (2) during the first half. BRYNN ANDERSON  |  AP
    Central Michigan entered as a 30-point underdog, but pulls within five with three minutes to play.
  3. Florida State quarterback Alex Hornibrook (12) passes underneath to running back Cam Akers (3) in the first half against Louisville. MARK WALLHEISER  |  AP
    Seminoles quarterback James Blackman also leaves with an injury during the second half of the 35-24 victory.
  4. Florida State defensive tackle Marvin Wilson (21) fires off the line during the season opener against Boise State on Aug. 31  in Tallahassee. GARY MCCULLOUGH  |  AP
    Cam Akers isn’t the only draft-eligible Seminole starring, and Miami quietly has one of the top freshman passers in the nation.
  5. Florida State Seminoles quarterback Alex Hornibrook (12) throws during practice at the IMG Academy in Bradenton, Florida on Tuesday, August 13, 2019. OCTAVIO JONES   |   Times OCTAVIO JONES   |   TIMES  |  Tampa Bay Times
    The Tallahassee Democrat and 247Sports expect the Wisconsin grad transfer to see some time against the Cardinals.
  6. Then-USF coach Jim Leavitt argues a call with referees against the University of Central Florida during the third quarter  of the NCAA college football game at Bright House Networks Stadium in Orlando, September 6, 2008. USF won 31-24. (Times file) Tampa Bay Times
    The former USF coach’s contract runs through Aug. 7.
  7. Florida State coach Willie Taggart reacts during the first half against Boise State in Tallahassee on Aug. 31. MARK WALLHEISER  |  AP
    New quarterbacks and coordinators might explain the conference’s struggles at the outset of 2019.
  8. CHARLIE KAIJO   |   Times
Quarterback Kyle Trask (11) practices throws at Jesuit High School in Tampa, Fla., on Thursday, December 29, 2016. University of Florida held practice for the Outback Bowl at Jesuit High School.  Times
    The former Gators coach who recruited Trask to Florida isn’t surprised that Trask didn’t transfer.
  9. Virginia quarterback Bryce Perkins (3) celebrates 2-point conversion with wide receiver Terrell Chatman (9) during the team's NCAA college football game against Florida State in Charlottesville, Va., Saturday, Sept. 14, 2019. Virginia won 31-24. ANDREW SHURTLEFF  |  AP
    Florida State is in the red zone at the end of the game but can’t capitalize.
  10. USF, Florida, FSU and more games on the air.