1. Sports
  2. /
  3. Florida State Seminoles

Locals lead Florida State’s charge to College World Series

The Seminoles’ roster is filled with former bay area high school standouts.
Florida State's outgoing pitcher CJ Van Eyk, facing, talks to incoming pitcher Antonio Velez (30) as Van Eyk is pulled in the eighth inning against LSU in Game 2 of the NCAA college baseball super regional tournament in Baton Rouge, La., Sunday, June 9, 2019. Florida State won 5-4 in 12 innings to advance to the College World Series. (AP Photo/Gerald Herbert)
Published Jun. 13
Updated Jun. 13

TAMPA ― He fidgeted with every fastball, died a little inside with every curve that hung a bit too much.

Steinbrenner baseball coach John Crumbley had watched his old Warriors ace, CJ Van Eyk, throw dozens ― maybe hundreds ― of innings, but this was different. On this tense Sunday night, Crumbley could neither counsel nor comfort Van Eyk. He couldn’t even call a pitch.

Like the rest of the ESPN2 audience affixed to this FSU-LSU super regional showdown, all Crumbley could do was observe ― and agonize ― as Van Eyk worked into the eighth inning.

“I would say that as I texted his father, I was more nervous sitting in my La-Z-Boy than I was watching him throw in the state tournament from the dugout in the (2016) semifinal game,” Crumbley said, referring to Steinbrenner’s 2-0 win against Westland Hialeah in the Class 8A semis.

“But as I told his dad, it was definitely a proud moment for Hillsborough County, for Steinbrenner and for CJ.”

That pride oozed from nearly every nook of the bay area. FSU’s roster features 12 players who starred for a local high school.

A handful of them ― including Van Eyk ― played critical roles in Sunday’s 12-inning, 5-4 victory that clinched a College World Series berth.

RELATED: FSU wins on walkoff in the 12th, gives Mike Martin one last trip to College World Series

“Snapchat was blowing up, and everybody was texting, ‘Are you watching? Are you talking?’” former Brandon High coach Matt Stallbaumer said.

As Crumbley squirmed in Lutz, Stallbaumer and his old pitching coach, Ernie Johns, expended enough nervous energy to light up a suburban Bloomingdale block as Eagles alumnus Antonio Velez worked 4.2 scoreless innings to earn the win in relief.

“It was exciting, it was fun to watch,” Stallbaumer said. “We kept looking at each other saying, ‘We don’t see anybody else warming up in the bullpen, this might be Velez’s game to win or lose.’ It was pretty cool.”

Florida State catcher Matheu Nelson during an NCAA college baseball game against Stetson, May 8, 2019, in Deland, Fla. (AP Photo/Gary McCullough)

While FSU’s surreal quest to give retiring coach Mike Martin his first national title ― in his 17th CWS appearance ― remains the prevailing story line of this postseason, subplots abound for bay area viewers.

FSU’s roster features as many players who attended high school in Hernando, Hillsborough, Pasco or Pinellas counties as those of USF, Florida and Miami combined.

“I’m not gonna sugarcoat this at all: Tampa is very dear to me,” Martin said Wednesday.

“And it goes all the way back to when I first started coaching when we had guys like (Plant alumni) Danny Dowell and Rick Figueredo. We didn’t get some of the young men we went after in the mid-80s, and then we started really bearing down on the Tampa area in the last 10 years.”

Van Eyk leads the pitching staff in wins (10-3, 3.80 ERA). Velez (47 strikeouts, 44.1 innings), who earned the win in both super regional games, is enjoying a late-season resurgence.

Freshman catcher Mat Nelson, a Calvary Christian alumnus, began heating up offensively in early April and is hitting .277. Freshman cleanup hitter Robby Martin (Jefferson) has the club’s second-best average (.332).

The guy who helped Martin recruit most of them echoes his old boss when he says the assemblage of local talent is no geographic fluke.

“We understand the strength of Tampa, St. Pete, the 813,” said former FSU assistant Mike Bell, who just wrapped up his first season as coach at Pitt.

“Whether it’s the Saladino Tournament or Legion ball ... I think competition brings out the best in individuals. There’s great competition and great knowledge when you talk about some of the coaches down there.”

Florida State's Robby Martin (26) scores on a fielding error by LSU catcher Saul Garza, left, in the second inning of Game 2 of the NCAA college baseball super regional tournament in Baton Rouge, La., June 9, 2019. (AP Photo/Gerald Herbert)

Martin concurred. “I can’t say enough (about) those (bay area) high school coaches,” he said.

“They really know the game. They teach the fundamentals, the competition is outstanding, and we’ve got (bay area) guys that are making major contributions to our program this year as freshmen.”

Bell, who preceded Stallbaumer as Brandon coach and spent two seasons (2001-02) with the Eagles, said FSU’s coaches weren’t necessarily assigned specific recruiting areas. Instead, they would home in on the areas where they had cultivated solid relationships.

Which caused him to naturally gravitate toward west central Florida. A Sarasota Riverview alumnus, Bell was the first signee in the history of Pasco-Hernando State College (then Pasco-Hernando Community College), and hit the program’s first home run.

MORE FLORIDA STATE: FSU forms direct support organization to align athletic department with Seminole Boosters

His coaching career has taken him to Brandon and Lakeland’s Florida Southern College, in addition to FSU (where he played his final two college seasons).

“He’s always kind of been tied down here in this area for sure, and I think he just built some relationships with the local high school coaches,” Stallbaumer said.

“And he was always at the events, from the Saladino (Tournament) to the big travel-ball tournaments and stuff that are being held seasonally. I think he groomed a lot of these kids from the beginning.”

He’ll be watching them again this weekend, when his old coach ― and those kids he helped nurture ― commence CWS play in Omaha.

Contact Joey Knight at Follow @TBTimes_Bulls.

Locals aplenty

FSU’s 2019 roster features more players who graduated from a bay area high school than any other Division I-A program in the state.

Florida State: 12

USF: 7

Florida A&M: 6

North Florida: 5

Florida Atlantic: 4

UCF: 3

Florida: 3

Jacksonville: 2

Miami: 2

Florida Gulf Coast: 2


  1. Florida State head coach Willie Taggart, right, disagrees with the referee in the first half of his final game with the Seminoles, Nov. 2 against Miami in Tallahassee. MARK WALLHEISER  |  AP
    There are reasons to think quick hooks and mid-season dismissals are the new norm.
  2. Miami quarterback Jarren Williams (15) scrambles as he is rushed by Louisville linebacker Dorian Etheridge (17) during the second half in Miami Gardens. Williams set a school record with six touchdown passes as Miami defeated Louisville 52-27. WILFREDO LEE  |  AP
    The Hurricanes quarterback has a field day in a 52-27 win over Louisville.
  3. Florida State interim head coach Odell Haggins gets a hug from linebacker Jaleel McRae after his team beat Boston College on Saturday in Boston. BILL SIKES  |  AP
    The Seminoles rally from a first-half deficit, surge ahead, watch the Eagles tie the score, then pull ahead for good in the final two minutes.
  4. In this 1987 file photo, Deion Sanders stands on the field during a game against the Florida Gators in Gainesville. ALLEN DEAN STEELE  |  Tampa Bay Times
    Roundtable: Was this just Friday afternoon internet clickbait or an idea worth Seminole consideration?
  5. Quarterback Kyle Trask threw for 257 yards and got the Gators back in the game vs. Georgia in the second half, but Florida lost 24-17. OCTAVIO JONES  |  Times
    The last three times Florida lost to Georgia, the Gators lost the next game by double digits.
  6. In this Dec. 2, 2017, file photo, Florida State interim head coach Odell Haggins watches the team warm up before a game against Louisiana Monroe in Tallahassee. Now he finds himself as the interim coach again just two seasons later. MARK WALLHEISER  |  AP
    Haggins has been at FSU through the highs of two national titles and the last three years of lows.
  7. Former Florida State football player Deion Sanders, left, joins Head Coach Willie Taggart prior to the start of the spring game action Saturday at Doak Campbell Stadium in Tallahassee in 2018. COLIN HACKLEY  |  COLIN HACKLEY
    NFL Network’s Ian Rapoport and Mike Garafolo reported the development Thursday night.
  8. Quarterback Jameis Winston and the Bucs play their first home game in 49 days at 1 p.m. Sunday against the Arizona Cardinals. Times
    Sports Day Tampa Bay podcast: Can Jameis Winston make the Bucs’ welcome-home game a success?
  9. LSU quarterback Joe Burrow (9) passes in the first half against Florida in Baton Rouge, La., on Oct. 12, 2019. BILL FEIG  |  AP
    Bill Clinton once took a nap on Nick Saban’s couch. No, really.
  10. USF Bulls head coach Charlie Strong on the sideline during the second half of the game at Raymond James Stadium in Tampa, Florida on Saturday, October 12, 2019.  OCTAVIO JONES  |  Times
    Here are our picks for this week’s top college football games, including USF-Temple, FSU-Boston College, Florida-Vanderbilt and Alabama-LSU.